Appeals Court Rejects New York City’s Large Soda Ban, Ensuring It Will Remain Overturned
[font size=4]
Appeals Court Rejects New York Citys Large Soda Ban, Ensuring It Will Remain Overturned[/font]
A state appeals court has
upheld a lower court decision that overturned New York Citys ban on large sugary drinks, ensuring that Mayor Michael Bloombergs (I) public health initiative will remain unable to take effect. A unanimous panel of judges determined that the law represented an illegal overreach of executive power.
The policy, which banned restaurants from selling sugary drinks larger than 16 ounces, intended to
address the citys rising rates of obesity. Sugary products like soda have been
linked to obesity-related health conditions like diabetes, heart diseases, and cancer. The soda ban was just one of multiple public health policies championed by Bloomberg, who has also focused on
regulating tobacco products and encouraging
more people to exercise.
In March right before the soda ban was scheduled to take effect a state judge
struck down the initiative, citing the loopholes in the law that would lead to uncertain enforcement throughout the city. Indeed, New Yorkers insistent on consuming more than 16 ounces of soda could have circumvented the ban in any number of ways: by going to New Jersey, by buying soft drinks at any local supermarket or convenience store (which wouldnt have fallen under the regulation), or by purchasing several smaller-sized sodas at once.
Public health officials tend to agree that its important to figure out how to
better regulate junk food in order to promote public health, and theres widespread consensus that Americans need to cut down on their consumption of sugary drinks. They
werent convinced that Bloombergs ban was a perfect policy, although many conceded that it was a well-intentioned
step in the right direction.
< . . . . >