A scientist examines the folly of 'I am not a scientist.'
A few weeks back, I wrote a piece about the political, social and journalistic implications of a phrase that has been bothering me like a burr under a saddle. Im not a scientist has become a go-to cop out for politicians, big corporate press reps, and activists who want to evade deliberate scientific questions about things like climate change, GMOs, vaccines, stem cells and all the other hot button scientific issues that expose raw political leanings or moral ideologies.
Judging by the magnitude of the response, Im not the only one who feels this is a problem.
My call to action is to rally journalists (and you at home) to demand better, more complete answers and explanations from both scientists and the politicians and leaders who are using Im not a scientist as an excuse to avoid engaging with the science. When it comes to explaining the myriad roles science plays in our everyday lives and our policy choices we need to elevate the dialogue.
If that is going to happen, the scientific community and the press will have to do a better job of communicating. But this new foundation cant be built on 30 second sound bites.
http://mashable.com/2015/11/29/folly-of-i-am-not-a-scientist/#v2M08JJNbGq3
3catwoman3
(23,973 posts)I am a pediatric nurse practitioner.
I am NOT:
- a plumber
- a lawyer
- a pilot
- a dentist
- a hairstylist
- a car mechanic
- a veterinarian
...etc, etc, etc
When I need the services of those who have skills I do not, I ask around, I check credentials, and I choose someone who seems to have the appropriate resume'.
The "I'm not a scientist" dodge is a load of BS.
greymattermom
(5,754 posts)a member of NIH review panels on traumatic brain injury, but I'm not qualified to comment on climate change.
Galileo126
(2,016 posts)I am NOT
- a planetary scientist
- a galactic astrophysicist
- a cosmologist
- an astrobiologist
and more importantly -I am NOT an atmospheric scientist studying climate change. So I listen to all of them for things I wish to learn more about.