Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)Should the United States extradite Amanda Knox if the Italian government requests it? [View all]
34 votes, 2 passes | Time left: Unlimited | |
Yes | |
6 (18%) |
|
No | |
28 (82%) |
|
2 DU members did not wish to select any of the options provided. | |
Show usernames
Disclaimer: This is an Internet poll |
114 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Should the United States extradite Amanda Knox if the Italian government requests it? [View all]
DemocratSinceBirth
Mar 2015
OP
For those that would care to look at the Treaty before rendering an international law legal opinion:
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#1
Italy passed legislation AFTER the treaty was signed that had a huge impact on the fairness of the
pnwmom
Mar 2015
#24
Some folks are not reading the actual Treaty or understanding it, or why there can NEVER be another trial by
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#67
Evidentiary rules of admission of recorded out of Court statements in criminal trial procedures do not meet any of the treaty exemptions.
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#31
The US could never have anticipated the need to have such an exemption in the treaty,
pnwmom
Mar 2015
#34
All of what you say may be true, but the rule of law remains. The current treaty is what governs.
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#41
Except this particular "evidentiary change" removed the presumption of innocence, which is a basic
pnwmom
Mar 2015
#45
I disagree with your opinion of the result being so drastic...no one would bring that argument up
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#48
A re-trial is not double jeopardy. Happens all the time, right in America...appeals are not trials.
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#55
All I can say is your comparisons between these two legal systems is erroneous on several points.
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#66
In what respect? You obviously aren't familiar enough with the Italian system to say. n/t
pnwmom
Mar 2015
#73
And given that Miss Knox's case has been overturned, with no future redress available to that
MADem
Mar 2015
#112
You would think our diplomats and their diplomats can come to a mutually face saving solution./NT
DemocratSinceBirth
Mar 2015
#3
It would not be hard for a strong man armed with a knife to rape and murder a smaller woman.
pnwmom
Mar 2015
#25
Chan doesn't seem to know much about male female physical interactions.
dolphinsandtuna
Mar 2015
#68
Her parents said that this petite woman had taken some kind of self-defense lessons,
pnwmom
Mar 2015
#72
Bottom Line: As bad as the US court system is, Italy's is absolutely horrific by comparison. -eom-
HuckleB
Mar 2015
#6
Rule of law. Believe in it or not. This is an actual white hat/black hat question.
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#36
If the U.S. is not going to honor a treaty they should not have signed it.
former9thward
Mar 2015
#16
After the US signed the treaty, Italy passed fast track trial legislation that effectively removed
pnwmom
Mar 2015
#33
Was the treaty changed? How do in-trial evidentiary law amendments fall within the exemptions in the treaty?
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#37
It is an evidentiary and criminal procedure change, not a question of fundamental rights.
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#44
Actually, it's Italy, and not the U.S., who is attempting to circumvent the treaty.
Xithras
Mar 2015
#65
"An acquittal was issued" is not the same as your phrase "was aquitted". The words are different....
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#70
Reasonable doubt. Reasonable doubt. Reasonable doubt. What is the point of your continuing
pnwmom
Mar 2015
#43
Please read the Hellman report section by the two Court-appointed independent forensic
pnwmom
Mar 2015
#53
OK, or I could tell you to read the Nencini report, which refutes the Hellman report...
DanTex
Mar 2015
#57
I have read the Nencini report and if you have, you must realize that it is nonsense. n/t
pnwmom
Mar 2015
#63
Italy seems fine with it - and around another one hundred countries with Italian Extradition Treaties.
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#40
Italy and the Ukraine have the worst track record with the European Supreme Court
TexasMommaWithAHat
Mar 2015
#104
Seems like celebrity status, either guilty or innocent, brings with it a complete disregard for rule of law...
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#52
You know,Canada will refuse to extradite if the death sentence will apply.
Wash. state Desk Jet
Mar 2015
#109
And it doesn't mean "Irrelevant", it means "debatable" (see: "moot court" in law school).
Spider Jerusalem
Mar 2015
#78
Yes. In MOOT Court....in which debate is the entire purpose. But the result is moot.
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#80
that may not come to any satisfactory conclusion or whose conclusion may be meaningless.
wyldwolf
Mar 2015
#88
The poll results are moot. I have to go now, so I will be mute for a while.
Fred Sanders
Mar 2015
#79
My prediction: within the next 10 years, Ms. Knox will find herself before another court
alcibiades_mystery
Mar 2015
#100
RIP PSH: That's one of the best lines of his long and storied career
alcibiades_mystery
Mar 2015
#103