Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Stop The Construction the TMT Telescope on Mauna Kea and the Arrest of Mauna Kea Protectors [View all]Warren DeMontague
(80,708 posts)172. I also highly doubt an important scientific observatory breaks on "red/blue" lines.
Last edited Tue Apr 7, 2015, 03:49 AM - Edit history (1)
(Edited to add: I think this thread is proof enough, of that)
Petition away, I guess we'll see.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
212 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Stop The Construction the TMT Telescope on Mauna Kea and the Arrest of Mauna Kea Protectors [View all]
ellisonz
Apr 2015
OP
Most in this thread who say that are not listening to the answers. The US has nearly wiped out...
Hekate
Apr 2015
#198
Ellisonz, the dynamic you are arguing against is the mainstay of American practice.
freshwest
Apr 2015
#109
I may have missed it, but you might do better to tell Ellisonz their belief system is medieval.
freshwest
Apr 2015
#114
That's not true. The amount of chemicals used on the telescopes is significant.
ellisonz
Apr 2015
#167
Once again, why must this sacred ground be protected, when other sacred ground is free to develop?
jeff47
Apr 2015
#187
What Controversy - What Ethics - Telescopes Are Already On The Mountain Top
cantbeserious
Apr 2015
#10
Hey, don't poop on the lichens. I've spent an inordinate amount of my life studying lichens. :)
LTX
Apr 2015
#123
A sacred place that's off-limits to everyone except the high priests who declared it sacred.
LTX
Apr 2015
#79
Personally, I would rather see this telescope built as opposed to more vacation houses. nt
Quackers
Apr 2015
#13
BumRush, you are one of the few Mainland haoles that actually gets the problem....
Hekate
Apr 2015
#190
Mahalo again. I encapsulated some of my own history in Post 198, if you are interested. nt
Hekate
Apr 2015
#203
Yes, and there's a reason it's already an established center for Astronomy, the climatalogical and
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2015
#22
We're kind of going around and around. "is bigger always better"? No, but when you are talking about
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2015
#32
This is the largest telescope in the world (the current largest is ten metres).
Spider Jerusalem
Apr 2015
#102
What did the gentleman mean that the police would be held accountable for war crimes? nt
Quackers
Apr 2015
#20
He means that the United States illegally overthrew and annexed the Kingdom of Hawaii.
ellisonz
Apr 2015
#23
I also highly doubt an important scientific observatory breaks on "red/blue" lines.
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2015
#172
The relocation of Native Americans and despoliation of their lands was a war crime. ...
Hekate
Apr 2015
#196
Also, just saw a thread with the heading "It's easier to beg forgivness than ask permission"
salib
Apr 2015
#39
It's not out of the blue at all. The native Hawai'ian movement has been building for 40 years, afaik.
Hekate
Apr 2015
#211
Hawaiians have a consensus culture, so you've made a very astute observation. I'd say not.
Hekate
Apr 2015
#212
What better use for "sacred ground" than exploring the hidden secrets of our vast cosmos?
Fumesucker
Apr 2015
#42
It's just my opinion, it may or may not be an effective argument with some people
Fumesucker
Apr 2015
#58
Nothing wrong with it at all. It's a quite different approach, however, since...
stone space
Apr 2015
#143
I can almost guarantee if Obama came out and said we should preserve this land for cultural
liberal_at_heart
Apr 2015
#90
No, it wouldn't. I've heard several folks make claims like that. It wouldn't change anyone's opinion
stevenleser
Apr 2015
#188
If a telescope is seeing farther than we have ever seen before, how is anyone going to know
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2015
#107
Let both sides argue their case. Then let the people of Hawaii decide by vote.
Tierra_y_Libertad
Apr 2015
#74
no I'm sure it doesn't. Many on here care more about science than people.
liberal_at_heart
Apr 2015
#86
I've never understood the concept of "sacred ground", or "holidays" (Holy days).
eppur_se_muova
Apr 2015
#84
Is there such as thing as a religious commitment to building gigantic telescopes?
Cheese Sandwich
Apr 2015
#113
Preservation of natural spaces doesn't necessitate large amounts of flora and fauna living there.
KittyWampus
Apr 2015
#134
There is a huge movement in the US that considers Stem Cells to be sacred
SomethingFishy
Apr 2015
#106
It's not about whether something is actually sacred or not. I am not Hawaiian. I don't consider
liberal_at_heart
Apr 2015
#111
Or maybe they could embrace the fact that they had the greatest observatory on the planet.
longship
Apr 2015
#115
The culture isn't going to disappear because another telescope is built on Mauna Kea.
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2015
#121
I'm not getting how putting a telescope there is "destroying a minority culture" (nt)
Nye Bevan
Apr 2015
#124
Mahalo for bringing this here. I'll check your links later on -- didn't know there was a controversy
Hekate
Apr 2015
#120
Were native Hawaiians ever compensated for taking this location where other telescopes were
KittyWampus
Apr 2015
#131
Telescopes serve different purposes... plus only one team can use the telescope at a time.
Adrahil
Apr 2015
#150
Native Hawai'ians were never compensated for diddly squat. Hawai'i was annexed without treaties...
Hekate
Apr 2015
#177
I don't know where I stand on this, but I do think it's odd how dismissive people here are of the
DanTex
Apr 2015
#132
Not getting how putting a telescope on a mountain is like "tearing the Mona Lisa apart". (nt)
Nye Bevan
Apr 2015
#137
Are there any mountains, anywhere, where you would be happy to erect a telescope? (nt)
Nye Bevan
Apr 2015
#140
I'd suggest replacing all the smaller telescopes with one big one. And I'm not unsympathetic
KittyWampus
Apr 2015
#142
On the other hand, are there any mountains where you would object to a telescope being built?
DanTex
Apr 2015
#144
I think DU is being pretty tolerant of a lot of "science is overrated" mumbo jumbo
ProudToBeBlueInRhody
Apr 2015
#169
West Virginia? So the Hawai'ian people should wait till their land is strip mined before speaking?
Hekate
Apr 2015
#174
That's gotta be the most non-violent, respectful, peaceful arresting of protestors
DanTex
Apr 2015
#160
Yes it most certainly is. I wish that the posters here would think hard about why. nt
Hekate
Apr 2015
#178
As much as I am pro-science, I am even more troubled by the arrogance and dismissiveness ...
Hekate
Apr 2015
#176
If this was a bunch of Christians or Muslims protesting some science project...
MicaelS
Apr 2015
#199
Christians and Muslims comprise a large percentage of the world's population. Hawaiians...
Hekate
Apr 2015
#202
If the Hawaiian gods don't like it, can't they do something about it, being gods and all?
stevenleser
Apr 2015
#186
Malala was shot, but same t'ing as acid. They tried to silence her. By the way, Ellison...
Hekate
Apr 2015
#195
Just as I thought GWB was dead wrong with his banning of stem cell research on religious grounds
Egnever
Apr 2015
#197