Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

hunter

(38,350 posts)
64. Where did I say Obamacare was socialism?
Thu Oct 27, 2016, 09:18 PM
Oct 2016


Nations have accomplished universal health care in a variety of ways. That's what I said.

Yet for the unemployed and unemployable, and for those who are stricken with budget-busting catastrophic illnesses or accidents, there are elements of socialism in all these plans. So what?

The stink of "we can't do that here" is very strong in this article. Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt.

Why can't we have a single payer here? It seems to work well in Canada, which is a nation very similar to our own.

I must make a confession, as others have above: I'm not a fan of NPR. They are bought and beholden to big money interests, much as U.S. politicians are. They can't afford to alienate their big donors, which is the same fix many politicians are in when it comes to campaign finances.

My favorite part was this:

Are Single-Payer Plans Less Expensive Than Other Health Coverage Systems?

Not necessarily. True, eliminating the profits and duplicative administrative costs associated with hundreds of different private insurance plans would reduce spending, perhaps as much as 10 percent of the nation's $3 trillion annual health care bill, says Anderson. But, he notes, once those savings are achieved, there wouldn't be further reductions afterward.


Well wait a minute, you just said Canada and Taiwan are the only nations with true single payer systems... Are they less expensive?

Here's a chart from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development:



https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_health_expenditure_per_capita

It took me about 12 seconds to find that data. Canada looks like it's doing pretty good to me.

Worse, I followed the link provided to expert Uwe E. Reinhardt, and first thing you see is: Uwe E. Reinhardt is an economics professor at Princeton. He has some financial interests in the health care field.

Exploring further, He is currently a director of Boston Scientific, a medical device company, and a trustee for the Hambrecht & Quist Life Sciences Fund and Health Care Fund, which are closed-end mutual funds.

Dear God, is there anyone who doesn't have a finger in this pie?
Single-payer was always a compromise for me. LWolf Oct 2016 #1
Then this post isn't referencing you. Many others here on DU, yes. ehrnst Oct 2016 #2
+1 NCTraveler Oct 2016 #8
And I would like every house in the country to be fitted with Solar Panels or wind turbines. ehrnst Oct 2016 #13
ok. nt. NCTraveler Oct 2016 #16
It does however, allow us a collective and efficient goal to reach... LanternWaste Oct 2016 #20
Yes, the goal of universal health coverage doesn't need to require single payer ehrnst Oct 2016 #30
No. A single payer system is essential. Anderson agrees. kristopher Oct 2016 #36
Anderson was talking about the "medicare for all" proposals of 2016 ehrnst Oct 2016 #39
I let him speak for himself - in context. kristopher Oct 2016 #40
Again - this is from 2011. ehrnst Oct 2016 #45
"Because, in most other countries they have a single purchaser, which is a very tough negotiator" kristopher Oct 2016 #48
This message was self-deleted by its author ehrnst Oct 2016 #53
You can paste the same thing again and again until you are blue in the face... ehrnst Oct 2016 #54
"Because, in most other countries they have a single purchaser, which is a very tough negotiator" kristopher Oct 2016 #57
What part of that refutes what I said? ehrnst Oct 2016 #58
And just that one thing LWolf Oct 2016 #66
It would be huge. NCTraveler Oct 2016 #67
Me too tazkcmo Oct 2016 #55
What right-wing garbage is this? BlueStreak Oct 2016 #3
Well first off - it's not garbage, and it's not right wing ehrnst Oct 2016 #5
Here is Anderson in an interview saying single payer is how to reduce costs kristopher Oct 2016 #29
That's from five years ago. The OP article discusses "Medicare for All" proposals in this election ehrnst Oct 2016 #31
The point of your article is the same as it always is, to misrepresent the idea and role of SP. kristopher Oct 2016 #33
I guess that's one way to try discredit something that you don't agree with ehrnst Oct 2016 #34
You are misrepresenting the meaning of Anderson's writing. kristopher Oct 2016 #37
What part of "not all nations in Europe have or have had single payer" ehrnst Oct 2016 #41
The posters you are arguing with are arguing for exactly what Anderson endorses. kristopher Oct 2016 #46
That's where you are misunderstanding. ehrnst Oct 2016 #51
"Because, in most other countries they have a single purchaser, which is a very tough negotiator" kristopher Oct 2016 #56
What part of that refutes what I said? ehrnst Oct 2016 #59
Screaming that something is right wing garbage doesn't make you right mythology Oct 2016 #23
There is not a shred of evicence that our private insurance system contributes one iota BlueStreak Oct 2016 #25
You have to be aware of terms: single payer is not necessarily universal health coverage mnhtnbb Oct 2016 #4
Good luck. You're guilty of "sophistry" now, like me. ehrnst Oct 2016 #42
Mere sophistry whatthehey Oct 2016 #6
Not everybody here "knows" And are you accusing me of lying or the NPR reporter?(nt) ehrnst Oct 2016 #7
Please cite the accusation of lying. whatthehey Oct 2016 #9
"Mere Sophistry" ehrnst Oct 2016 #11
Read deeper whatthehey Oct 2016 #18
Why don't you 'splain it to me. ehrnst Oct 2016 #19
Seems accurate. LanternWaste Oct 2016 #21
It may be ignorance from the NPR reporter or those spreading this stuff. Or BlueStreak Oct 2016 #26
Or you may simply think that anything that doesn't validate a particular veiw ehrnst Oct 2016 #32
I consider to be 'single payer'.. sendero Oct 2016 #10
You can make up your own definition for any word. But that doesn't change the reality of it. ehrnst Oct 2016 #12
Well if someone is controlling... sendero Oct 2016 #15
And to a Tea Partier, if something is federally regulated.... ehrnst Oct 2016 #17
Sender's point is correct. The author of the OP snip agrees... kristopher Oct 2016 #44
From 2011, and not addressing the points that the OP made ehrnst Oct 2016 #47
"Because, in most other countries they have a single purchaser, which is a very tough negotiator" kristopher Oct 2016 #49
I guess that means you're done copying and pasting the same thing that doesn't address my post? ehrnst Oct 2016 #52
"We're done" I suppose that's a 'mic' drop... ehrnst Oct 2016 #61
we need accessible, nonprofit, universal health care at little or no direct cost to patients.... mike_c Oct 2016 #14
I think universal healthcare is THE goal ismnotwasm Oct 2016 #22
Apparently to believe this = "sophistry" ehrnst Oct 2016 #38
True. There is not a magic way to universal healthcare ismnotwasm Oct 2016 #62
Tempting to simply declare that there is one simple answer to a complicated issue ehrnst Oct 2016 #63
The USA is the only country in the western hemisphere without a single payer Warpy Oct 2016 #27
Actually no. According to the OP Canada is the only country with true Single Payer ehrnst Oct 2016 #50
Canada is unique in how it set was up. roamer65 Oct 2016 #69
Arguments about language and definitions are a very deliberate distraction. hunter Oct 2016 #28
this ^^^^^^^^^^ Grey Lemercier Oct 2016 #43
Words mean things. Specific things. If you want to discuss them, you should know what they mean. ehrnst Oct 2016 #60
Where did I say Obamacare was socialism? hunter Oct 2016 #64
That was an analogy. ehrnst Oct 2016 #65
The article is FUD. It's not reporting "debate" about Single Payer at all. hunter Oct 2016 #68
To start with - You have made a major mistake in which foundation your are talking about ehrnst Oct 2016 #70
Ooops. Me, off on a wild google chase again... hunter Oct 2016 #71
Good to see that you now have the correct foundation ehrnst Oct 2016 #72
Dec 1969 #
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Which Countries Have Sing...»Reply #64