Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

The DU Lounge

Showing Original Post only (View all)

fNord

(1,756 posts)
Sun Feb 26, 2017, 02:10 AM Feb 2017

Epic *American* Rock guitarists..... [View all]

Last edited Sun Feb 26, 2017, 04:04 AM - Edit history (1)

My boyfriend and I have been discussing this for a few months, and we're having trouble thinking of the great American rock guitarists. Most of what we come up with are Brits, with the occasional Canadian, and of corse, the legendary Irishman, Rory Gallagher.

--reporter to Jimi Hendrix: "How's it feel to be the greatest guitarist in history?"
--Jimi: "I don't know man, you should go ask Rory Gallagher."

In the states, we've got Jimi. (Mic drops................................."boom!&quot
We have Eddie Van Halen.
Also Joe Perry, I guess.........before that whole "Break" thing

......That can't be it, right?
We invented Rock N' Roll, but we're getting spanked by the overwhelming British Invasion.

So I'm asking you, the Lounge Lizards, to prove me wrong.
Show me some American Rock badasses. Not Blues, we own that (mostly.). Not metal, the Sweeds own that (mostly.). I just mean Rock N' F'n Roll



Criteria:

No three chord wonders, or fret tapping hair band leads, I'm looking for Guitarists.

Check your choices (Slash from G N' R is British, for example)

Finally, please no newbies or one hit wonders, I'm looking for heavyweights! Folk who can stand with the likes of Brian May, Tony Iommi, Jimmy Page, Eric Clapton, and Kieth Richards.

I know there out there, help me find them:



*edit for

196 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
say what? Dyedinthewoolliberal Feb 2017 #1
Zappa. fNord Feb 2017 #3
SRV, lightweight? Charles Bukowski Feb 2017 #9
Allman is more folk? Dyedinthewoolliberal Feb 2017 #10
Another Allmans Dyedinthewoolliberal Feb 2017 #135
Stevie Ray Vaughn is no lightweight!! lastlib Feb 2017 #57
This imo, is best guitar/song writer out there.. Doyle Bramhall 11 busterbrown Feb 2017 #78
Good choice Mendocino Feb 2017 #109
if srv is a "lightweight", then forget eddie van halen. so he's fast, big deal. unblock Feb 2017 #79
Duane Allman was the famous one; Dickie Betts was the good one fishwax Feb 2017 #8
As much as I love Dickie, he was Bluegrass.... fNord Feb 2017 #12
no, definitely not bluegrass fishwax Feb 2017 #15
What was it said about checking...... fNord Feb 2017 #19
yeah, I've been there ;) fishwax Feb 2017 #20
UM... Rock? Simon_Moon Feb 2017 #24
I'm not sure Frusciante ever filled a stadium, and certainly not in his early years fishwax Feb 2017 #28
Many Thanx Simon_Moon Feb 2017 #34
Ok, one more "my bad" fNord Feb 2017 #98
Clarence White. Hoyt Feb 2017 #2
RIP Mendocino Feb 2017 #110
I have seen the Andy Griffth tapes, and the Byrds. My favorite muscian ever was Gene Clark, Hoyt Feb 2017 #112
This message was self-deleted by its author Mendocino Feb 2017 #115
I'm quite fond of this one Mendocino Feb 2017 #116
More of a influential Country picker redstateblues Feb 2017 #129
This ain't country . . . . . . Hoyt Feb 2017 #130
Definitely not. Tho he is a much revered guitar player in Country music. redstateblues Feb 2017 #143
Randy Rhoads, Tom Morello, Prince fishwax Feb 2017 #4
Tom Petty lastlib Feb 2017 #60
Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers GUITARIST... dchill Mar 2017 #155
Love him... lame54 Mar 2017 #166
Prince. The Velveteen Ocelot Feb 2017 #5
I was going to say Prince if someone hadn't already. montana_hazeleyes Feb 2017 #27
Definitely Prince. LNM Feb 2017 #124
Yep. dchill Mar 2017 #156
Carlos Santana, Jerry Garcia, Joe Walsh fishwax Feb 2017 #6
Santana, not American. Jerry, not rock..... fNord Feb 2017 #13
Yeah, Santana was (and is) American fishwax Feb 2017 #17
Slash is an American citizen, but I still count him as British..... fNord Feb 2017 #21
I guess I don't get why Jerry's influences should DQ him anymore than Clapton's blues fishwax Feb 2017 #25
Not so sure Simon_Moon Feb 2017 #32
Ok, the perimeters may have been too tight.... fNord Feb 2017 #35
This message was self-deleted by its author Warren DeMontague Feb 2017 #39
um.....Robert Hunter wrote all those songs Simon_Moon Feb 2017 #41
Lol....... fNord Feb 2017 #42
This message was self-deleted by its author Warren DeMontague Feb 2017 #45
This message was self-deleted by its author Warren DeMontague Feb 2017 #44
Don't kid yourself..... fNord Feb 2017 #47
This message was self-deleted by its author Warren DeMontague Feb 2017 #48
This message was self-deleted by its author Warren DeMontague Feb 2017 #50
The lyrics, yes Beaverhausen Feb 2017 #67
This message was self-deleted by its author Warren DeMontague Feb 2017 #75
Somewhere I have a print of that framed (8x11 size) Hassin Bin Sober Mar 2017 #145
This message was self-deleted by its author Warren DeMontague Mar 2017 #146
+ 1 red dog 1 Mar 2017 #190
Carlos Santana was here by the time he hit middle school Warpy Feb 2017 #26
another vote for Sister Rosetta Tharpe, a pioneer of the electric guitar. kwassa Feb 2017 #102
Thanks, too many people don't know who she is. Without her, no Chuck Berry Warpy Feb 2017 #117
and I must post her in performance. kwassa Feb 2017 #132
I guess Bill Grahm was wrong when he called Jerry "the godfather of rock and roll" hexola Feb 2017 #100
+ 1 red dog 1 Mar 2017 #191
Duane Allman... Docreed2003 Feb 2017 #7
Johnny Winter Sedona Feb 2017 #11
Randy Rhoades, Todd Rundgren Beaverhausen Feb 2017 #14
Neil Schon from Journey VMA131Marine Feb 2017 #16
I See A Couple I Can't Buy ProfessorGAC Mar 2017 #162
Santana, and Chuck Berry from early rock and roll brush Feb 2017 #18
Some new ones... hurple Feb 2017 #22
I really like Jack White. LuvLoogie Mar 2017 #174
I've been growing to appreciate him more and more lately cemaphonic Mar 2017 #183
Billy Zoom and East Bay Ray...and the late Jeffrey Lee Pierce.. Tikki Feb 2017 #23
I sooooo want to give you East Bay Ray..... fNord Feb 2017 #30
There is no law that says you have to have 3 minute guitar solos to be a great guitarist.... Tikki Feb 2017 #126
I love East Bay Ray...... fNord Feb 2017 #141
The Johnny's C_U_L8R Feb 2017 #59
Yes, yes, yes... Tikki Feb 2017 #66
Thank you! The "Johnnys" and Poison Ivy don't get enough love. Coventina Feb 2017 #72
So many great new bands... Tikki Feb 2017 #81
John Mayer is one hellava player Jack Bone Feb 2017 #29
............ fNord Feb 2017 #31
This message was self-deleted by its author Warren DeMontague Feb 2017 #38
Nothing like a killer Jimi cover... Jack Bone Mar 2017 #158
Steve Lukather sweetloukillbot Feb 2017 #33
Steve Morse LunaSea Feb 2017 #36
This message was self-deleted by its author Warren DeMontague Feb 2017 #37
Stevie Ray Vaughan JDC Feb 2017 #40
YES!! lastlib Feb 2017 #55
Did you somehow forget Chuck "invented rock guitar" Berry? cemaphonic Feb 2017 #43
This message was self-deleted by its author Warren DeMontague Feb 2017 #46
He's like the American Johnny Marr cemaphonic Feb 2017 #69
If you like Chuck Berry, you should rent or buy the movie "Cadillac Records" red dog 1 Mar 2017 #192
Jimi Hendrix Trailrider1951 Feb 2017 #49
This message was self-deleted by its author jcboon Feb 2017 #51
Roger McGuinn, Steve Cropper, Ry Cooder, Steven Stills jcboon Feb 2017 #52
Walter Becker, Larry Carlton and Dean Parks come to mind. NNadir Feb 2017 #53
Since You Brought Up Walter Becker ProfessorGAC Mar 2017 #163
Well, the first album wasn't my favorite, perhaps because I met Denny Diaz. NNadir Mar 2017 #171
Leslie West -Mountain independentpiney Feb 2017 #54
John Weldon "J. J." Cale! lastlib Feb 2017 #56
+ 1 red dog 1 Mar 2017 #194
Phil Upchurch JustABozoOnThisBus Feb 2017 #58
Roy Buchanan. Dr Hobbitstein Feb 2017 #61
Awesome choice, totally forgot about him. Charles Bukowski Feb 2017 #68
One of my absolute favorites. nt Dr Hobbitstein Feb 2017 #85
Dick Dale DBoon Feb 2017 #62
Also, Slash was born in Britain to an American mother. Dr Hobbitstein Feb 2017 #63
Jorma Kaukonen Mendocino Feb 2017 #64
Good list! red dog 1 Mar 2017 #193
I should have included Mendocino Mar 2017 #196
Oyster Boy Buck Dharma doesn't get enough love. Dave Starsky Feb 2017 #65
True enough. dchill Mar 2017 #154
I Met Him When In High School ProfessorGAC Mar 2017 #164
Don Roeser, I should say. Dave Starsky Mar 2017 #172
I don't think you can just discount metal like that. cemaphonic Feb 2017 #70
Brian Setzer??!?!?!? Hello?!?!?!? Coventina Feb 2017 #71
good one! never paid much attention to the stray cats, but he's amazing in brian setzer orchestra. unblock Feb 2017 #80
I was lucky enough to catch the BSO a few months ago. Coventina Feb 2017 #82
caught him live years ago in austin. amazing, indeed! unblock Feb 2017 #83
I saw the Stray Cats open for the Stones in the 80's. progressoid Mar 2017 #177
BO DIDDLEY - you said no blues, but you didnt say no r&b, which is an antecedent and Kashkakat v.2.0 Feb 2017 #73
I'm gonna put down Steve Kimock, too, since no one else has. Warren DeMontague Feb 2017 #74
Link Wray OneBlueDotBama Feb 2017 #76
jerry garcia, chuck berry, les paul, buddy holly, mike campbell, stephen stills, billy gibbons unblock Feb 2017 #77
Randy California DFW Feb 2017 #84
Amen to that! blue neen Feb 2017 #91
I loved Spirit too. PufPuf23 Feb 2017 #97
I never got to see them live DFW Feb 2017 #113
Neal Schon is very underrated. Charles Bukowski Feb 2017 #86
Burton, Ray, Eddy and also Hula Popper Feb 2017 #87
The answer must start with... jmowreader Feb 2017 #88
Bonnie Raitt OilemFirchen Feb 2017 #89
Rick Nielsen OilemFirchen Feb 2017 #90
Trey Azagthoth OriginalGeek Feb 2017 #92
They were my neighbors in Charlotte NC when they were just getting started... Rhythm Feb 2017 #138
Elliott Easton blue neen Feb 2017 #93
Oh come on ghostsinthemachine Feb 2017 #94
Johnny Winter, Jorma Kaukonen, Tim Reynolds, Jerry Douglas ghostsinthemachine Feb 2017 #108
Gary Rossington and Allen Collins. blue neen Feb 2017 #95
Eric Johnson hasnt been listed I dont think. miyazaki Feb 2017 #96
A bunch of the names here aren't American, either DFW Feb 2017 #99
Yes. Also in reference to what you posted above miyazaki Feb 2017 #111
meh OriginalGeek Feb 2017 #120
Disagree, but at least they got their day in court. miyazaki Feb 2017 #121
Yeah, Zeppelin shamelessly stole songs left and right, cemaphonic Feb 2017 #122
But did they really do anything different than any other electric blues bands of the time? OriginalGeek Feb 2017 #125
I go back and forth on this myself cemaphonic Feb 2017 #133
Elvis' entire body of work, for example, was stolen from the black street performers..... fNord Feb 2017 #142
Some thieves were around at the same time and the same place as the source material that was stolen Charlie Thompson Feb 2017 #144
KIRK HAMMETT! Still In Wisconsin Feb 2017 #101
As much as I don't care fore Metallica..... fNord Feb 2017 #103
I love Metallica but I know several who agree with you. Still In Wisconsin Feb 2017 #104
Have to go with Dave Mustane, then. LuvLoogie Mar 2017 #157
He's also excellent! Still In Wisconsin Mar 2017 #161
Walter Trout kwassa Feb 2017 #105
Stevie Ray Vaughn, Steve Vai. OregonBlue Feb 2017 #106
Terry Kath of Chicago Transit Authority LanternWaste Feb 2017 #107
You all forgot: Ronnie Montrose, Mike Ness HeartachesNhangovers Feb 2017 #114
Shot Jackson, more of steel guitar genius, a whole host of early blues players jack69 Feb 2017 #118
Roy Clark was an absolute perfectionist on any instrument. jack69 Feb 2017 #119
Let's see there's Chuck Berry, Scotty Moore, Carl Perkins, Johnny Burnette, Paul Burleson, mulsh Feb 2017 #123
I like your list but would add Mickey Baker, Grady Martin, Danny Cedrone and Cliff Gallup Charlie Thompson Feb 2017 #134
welcome to DU gopiscrap Feb 2017 #139
Joe Satriani? Randy Rhoades? d_r Feb 2017 #127
This message was self-deleted by its author redstateblues Feb 2017 #128
srv was pretty good juxtaposed Feb 2017 #131
This is why I love the Lizards........ fNord Feb 2017 #136
One of the all-time greats... dchill Mar 2017 #151
Still my favorite ... John Christ Rhythm Feb 2017 #137
Tommy Tedesco, Al Casey, and Bill Pitman Brother Buzz Feb 2017 #140
Leo Kottke Metsie Casey Mar 2017 #147
Joe Walsh Metsie Casey Mar 2017 #148
Steve Miller Metsie Casey Mar 2017 #149
Adrian Belew Metsie Casey Mar 2017 #150
BELEW!! progressoid Mar 2017 #178
Great stuff from him over the years Metsie Casey Mar 2017 #180
Bob Fripp is also great Metsie Casey Mar 2017 #181
I have about half dozen Fripp albums. progressoid Mar 2017 #182
Epic yes, American no cemaphonic Mar 2017 #184
JOE BONAMASSA! dchill Mar 2017 #152
And Donald Trump Metsie Casey Mar 2017 #153
Not meaning to be snarky but you left me cold when you said Stevie Ray Vaughn was... Upthevibe Mar 2017 #159
I didn't say Steve was a light weight Metsie Casey Mar 2017 #160
I think Upthevibe mistakenly responded to you instead of the OP. progressoid Mar 2017 #179
So sorry Metsie Casey.I didn't mean to respond to you. It was meant for the OP.(About Stevie Ray)n/t Upthevibe Mar 2017 #185
I Have 2 Nobody Mentioned ProfessorGAC Mar 2017 #165
Don't know his name... lame54 Mar 2017 #169
Warren Cuccarullo ProfessorGAC Mar 2017 #170
The criminally under-rated... lame54 Mar 2017 #167
His Buddy Pat Thrall Was Awfully Good Too! ProfessorGAC Mar 2017 #187
I saw them 2 nights in a row once... lame54 Mar 2017 #189
I'm going to be utterly predictable, but Billy Corgan. Tommy_Carcetti Mar 2017 #168
Has Kim Thayil made this list yet? fNord Mar 2017 #173
Have to give Larry Carlton and Ronnie Montrose a shout. LuvLoogie Mar 2017 #175
Duane Denison LuvLoogie Mar 2017 #176
Joan Jett!! missingthebigdog Mar 2017 #186
The Endless Well of Killer Riffs Matt Pike. HughBeaumont Mar 2017 #188
John Fogerty, Jerry Garcia, Joe Walsh, Lindsey Buckingham, J J Cale, Chris Isaak, Carlos Santana red dog 1 Mar 2017 #195
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Epic *American* Rock guit...