Reply #97: So corrected, however

[Spirit of 34]

I still find Alexander's claim dubious and overly broad. I'd have to see some stats (and sources w/ methodology) to back up that claim. Also, since WI, IL, and DC are the only non-issue states left (can't believe WI is still in that category), I think shall-issue stats vs. may issue stats would be more telling than concealed carry vs. no concealed carry.

A couple of other points--

1. That map is not entirely accurate. For example, CT is listed as "shall issue", which technically it is, but the statute allows for a pretty big loophole to judge applicants by entirely subjective criteria, so, in practice CT is "may issue". Also, it does not account for municipal laws-- although NY and MD are "may issue" states, in practice NYC and Baltimore are "no issue" cities, and in CA, Frisco has a sweeping handgun ban.

2. The point I particularly took issue with in Alexander's description of CC licence requirements was the "letter of good reference" from your local police department. Although a few supposedly "shall issue" states include this requirement, I can think of no better dividing line between a truly "shall issue" CCW law and a "may issue" one than requiring the subjective opinion of police as to someone's "character" or "fitness" to carry concealed-- such a requirement is open to abuse, discrimination and prejudice.