Fantasia or Diana who do you want as the American Idol?

[WI_DEM]

Poll question: Fantasia or Diana who do you want as the American Idol?

Ok, so I got into it this season--I never watched it in season one or two.

I'm for Fantasia. Who is your choice?

[Misunderestimator]

1. Fantasia... hands down

[MissMillie]

2. She's the real deal

talented, original, classy.

[saracat]

8. Diana

Has the most annoying personality I have ever seen(except for W!). I know she is young, but boy, is she stuck on herself and her perceived "cuteness". She can sing , but that's all. Fantasia isn't the most beautiful girl in the worls either and the nose peircing has got to go, but she is an excellent performer.I actually prefer Diana's voice, but Fantasia is more commercial.Kind of a Diana Ross quality.And it helps you don't want to punch her lights out everytime she speaks! She is genuine.Diana is a phoney.

[Name removed]

3. Deleted message

Message removed by moderator. Click here to review the message board rules.

[Misunderestimator]

4. nice.... n/t

[phillybri]

5. Diana...Fantasia sounds like Eartha Kitt and Carol Channing...

...had a baby and fed it gravel and broken glass...

[AspenRose]

6. Fantasia's my choice....

however, Diana will win. I don't have much faith and confidence America will vote for Fantasia, judging by this year's voting scandals.

I'll be (pleasantly) shocked if Fantasia wins.

And if I hear ONE MORE PERSON b*tching about how a single mom like Fantasia is NOT a good role model for America.....:mad:
I am just so SICK of hearing people diss her for that. It's usally the Morality Patrol. What's that got to do with her singing ability and talent?

[Bertha Venation]

7. can we have a

"those of us who don't give a flip, click here" option? ;)

[WI_DEM]

9. yes

it is called skipping the thread :)

[ronnykmarshall]

10. Fantasia!!!

I love her. She's been my #1 since the start of the show.

[Dedalus]

11. Who Doesn't Give a Shit? (poll)

I have never watched "American Idol," and yet I know all this shit about it, like how someone everybody liked lost to a Hawaiian because all of Hawaii called in or something... Why do I know this? Because shit about fucking "American Idol" is on the goddamn NEWS like it's important. Come to think of it, that's how I know anything about Reality Shows... Never seen "The Apprentice," but I know who won, and I know who Omarrossa is... Why? Because it's on the front page of the fucking paper! Is there anything that can be done to cease the dumbing-down of the News?

[WI_DEM]

12. write the networks or letters to the editor

this is the only "reality" show I watch but it is no different in my mind than the talent shows that used to be on tv years ago. Except for the hype. I actually do enjoy watching these people perform and unlike some of the sillier reality shows you can actually see talent and yes it is a shame when someone who doesn't deserve to be booted off is. But as far as reality shows go I do think this one is one of the milder ones.

[Rhiannon100]

17. I don't give a shit....

The whole show bugs the hell out of me....and you can't get away from it.....good grief

[Spider Jerusalem]

13. What if we want...

the terrible abomination known as "American Idol" removed from the airwaves, the people who came up with the idea sentenced to twenty years' hard labour for crimes against humanity and sterilised so that their evil cannot taint the gene pool, and all the contestants to appear on a NEW elimination-style reality show where the winner is he or she who can withstand the greatest amount of physical torture?

[TrogL]

14. I watched it last episode for the first time

I don't like either one, but I'm rooting for Diana.

Fantasia is just too "commercial". She sounds exactly like half a dozen other performers.

I'd like to see some new blood with a new sound. Diana fits the bill.

[Adenoid_Hynkel]

15. i'll do write-in vote

for johnny rotten

[adriennel]

16. Diana

Fantasia bugs the crap outta me (but she certainly can sing)
Diana just seems more like an entertainer to me
(I never watched AI before this season either...saw an episode at a friend's houseand got hooked on the damn thing