Which film DESERVED to win Best Picture?

[Yollam]

Poll question: Which film DESERVED to win Best Picture?

Based solely on its cinematic merits, which film most DESERVED to win Best Picture?

[Skittles]

1. if you haven't seen all five films, how could you vote?

I saw all five

[tuvor]

2. Where's "none of the above"?

[Katherine Brengle]

3. I didn't choose bc I haven't seen them all --

Crash was a great film, so I was glad it won, but I haven't seen the others, so I can't make an informed choice...

[last_texas_dem]

4. I haven't seen them all, but...

... of Good Night and Good Luck, Capote, and Munich (the three I've seen) I would give the edge to Good Night and Good Luck. I thought all three were great films, though.

[Inland]

5. Bill Murray's skit on SNL

His oscar wrapup would be, "didn't see it, didn't see it, didn't see it, this one I saw it's my pick".

[LSK]

6. can I vote in 10 years? by then I might have seen them...

[pamela]

7. I picked Capote just because no one else had picked it yet.

Plus, I thought it was a fantastic movie, but then I'm a huge (hugh) fan of "In Cold Blood." PSH was absolutely amazing in this role. You could have heard a pin drop in the theatre whenever he was on screen.