Did I miss the American Idol thread???

[MsKandice01]

Was Melinda Doolittle great last night or what?? I also think Jordin has the potential to be just as great...she's just gotta gain a little bit more control over her voice. Overall, I thought last night's show was really good.

And if Antonella and Sanjaya don't go home tonight, I'm gonna be highly pissed.

[LostinVA]

1. Melinda was fantastic

She is, literally, far beyond the other singers on this show. There's Melinda, then maybe two or three others, then two others, then a huge gap.

As we know, though, who SHOULD go home isn't always who DOES go home.

[AllegroRondo]

2. Antonella may stay

because of the 'vote for the worst' campaign.

[Strawman]

3. She was great

They could release her performance last night as a single. It was flawless. I was pulling for Lakisha Jones because she is from Flint, and she did well too, but Melinda Doolittle was just outstanding.

I like this part of the show much better than the auditions.