"How Old Is Too Old?" Someone else who thinks McCain is too old to be President

Stinky The Clown

(1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore

Thu Mar-06-08 11:59 PM
Original message

"How Old Is Too Old?" Someone else who thinks McCain is too old to be President

THE LAST WORD
Anna Quindlen
How Old Is Too Old?

Race, gender�they're both up for grabs in this presidential election. It's age that has become the new taboo in a vitality culture.
Feb 4, 2008 Issue

Here's my unscientific theory about the presidency: it ages a person in dog years. Each year in office is roughly equivalent to seven years in the life of an ordinary citizen. I base this on before-and-after photographs of the occupants of the Oval Office, who frequently look as though they've spent their time in captivity, being beaten with sticks. Which may help explain why 71-year-old John McCain, who actually has been beaten in captivity, may think that the fact that he would be the oldest person ever to enter the job is immaterial. In this, alas, he is mistaken.

~snip~

But the senator is not your average man of his age. He takes stairs slowly and cannot lift his arms to comb his hair. One reason few people want to address his age, or his infirmity, is the valor of his Vietnam service. It's humbling to consider that he broke both arms and a leg when his fighter jet was shot down, then suffered fractured shoulders and broken ribs when he was tortured during five and a half years as a POW. You can tell he thinks it should be humbling, too: when a boy at one event asked him respectfully if he was too old for the job, he responded with his trademark acerbic humor, "Thanks for the question, you little jerk."

~snip~

Please, please�don't feel the need to let me know that you're 82, swim every morning and finish the New York Times crossword, in ink, even on Saturday. I'm aware that there are women and men who perform brilliantly at arduous jobs far past the time the rest of us would be phoning it in or tuning it out. But the job McCain seeks is like no other, in its demands and its import. It's significant that while the old mandatory retirement age of 65 has been largely junked, there are still age limits for jobs like airline pilot or police officer, the kinds of jobs that require some of the same skills as the presidency�unwavering mental acuity and physical energy.

Political operatives say that his age makes McCain's choice of a running mate particularly critical. But if you enter the process stressing a hedge against mortality or incapacity, shouldn't that suggest something about suitability for the job in the first place? The senator's pursuit of the presidency reminds me a bit of those women who decide to have a baby in their late 50s. The impulse is understandable, the goal possible. But, looking at all the facts, and the actuarial tables, is it really sensible?

Please, before you comment, read the entire column at this link: http://www.newsweek.com/id/105554

You can call 'Ageism' and "Bigotry" if you like, but this matters. You can, and probably should, praise his military service and laud him for his incredibly honorable performance while captive in North Viet Nam. But the fact is, today, in 2008, he could well be unfit to be president for little more than his age and the impact of the totality of his life.

I think Ms. Quindlen makes the case much better than I attempted with humor some thought to be in poor taste in another thread. That caused the essential point to be overlooked or parsed out for the sake of making silly arguments.