Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

DonViejo

(60,536 posts)
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 10:13 AM Mar 2018

Hillary Clinton was right: The parts of America that support Trump are stuck in the past

Last edited Thu Mar 15, 2018, 10:43 AM - Edit history (1)


CHAUNCEY DEVEGA
03.15.2018•5:00 AM

Hillary Clinton has a problem. She tells impolitic truths at inopportune times. During the 2016 presidential campaign she described a large subset of Donald Trump's supporters as being "a basket of deplorables." She was correct. Donald Trump is an authoritarian petit-fascist who is also racist, ignorant, greedy and corrupt. He may be a traitor in cahoots with Russia, and is certainly a misogynist and serial liar who brags about sexually assaulting women. Anyone who would vote for such a person is in fact deplorable. Moreover, anyone who continues to support Donald Trump after witnessing his behavior as president is deplorable in the extreme.

Over the weekend while at a conference in India, Clinton let slip another truth about Trump's voters and the 2016 presidential election. Democrats, she said, "do not do well with white men, and we don’t do well with married white women. And part of that is an identification with the Republican Party, and a sort of ongoing pressure to vote the way that your husband, your boss, your son, whoever, believes you should."

Republicans attacked Clinton's latest comments, of course, as an example of how the Democrats are supposedly "isolated," "elitist" and "out of touch." Some of her fellow Democrats piled on with complaints that Clinton is being "unhelpful" by "re-litigating" the 2016 presidential election instead of looking to the future.

These voices of protest have provided little if any evidence to disprove Hillary Clinton's central thesis. Why? Because the facts are on her side.

more
https://www.salon.com/2018/03/15/hillary-clinton-was-right-the-parts-of-america-that-support-trump-are-stuck-in-the-past/
90 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Hillary Clinton was right: The parts of America that support Trump are stuck in the past (Original Post) DonViejo Mar 2018 OP
Of course. Without question. Truth to power. Nt Ninga Mar 2018 #1
She has been right about the majority of things she has ever spoken about. MrsCoffee Mar 2018 #2
Rolling Stone talked about the issues with Bill Clinton not being the liberal they thought Eliot Rosewater Mar 2018 #30
Part of the problem with Bill Clinton is the he was too in love with .. Bill Clinton. Caliman73 Mar 2018 #54
If you want to see someone drunk on power and in love with himself look at Trump. MrsCoffee Mar 2018 #64
+1 lunamagica Mar 2018 #67
Well, the only president my life got markedly better under was Bill Clinton. LisaM Mar 2018 #68
I agree...and I am sick of the attacks on him. Demsrule86 Mar 2018 #74
You are so right, MrsCoffee. Ohiogal Mar 2018 #76
i'm still cheering Hillary Hermit-The-Prog Mar 2018 #3
thank you for these golden kernels of TRUTH northoftheborder Mar 2018 #42
What a great post! Thank you, Hermit lunamagica Mar 2018 #70
+1 dalton99a Mar 2018 #71
K & R & +a million Wwcd Mar 2018 #79
you folks make me feel less alone Hermit-The-Prog Mar 2018 #86
Hey Hermit, I must say that I look for your posts because of how & what you write. Wwcd Mar 2018 #87
wow. thanks! Hermit-The-Prog Mar 2018 #88
She's correct... Mike Nelson Mar 2018 #4
agree, the truth hurts but it is the truth onetexan Mar 2018 #13
Yup, we are just a bunch of unedumacated baboons out here in Wisconsin Cuthbert Allgood Mar 2018 #19
As someone who lives in Wisconsin Cuthbert Allgood Mar 2018 #5
Well said. question everything Mar 2018 #16
So we want to tell bigots its ok to be bigots? ismnotwasm Mar 2018 #32
Yes, 500 in PA met the "off chance" and voted Dem question everything Mar 2018 #55
Are you fucking kidding me? ismnotwasm Mar 2018 #65
Correct...and any switch votes occurred because of Trump's toxic Presidency BoneyardDem Mar 2018 #84
No one wants you to get "hoarse". NCTraveler Mar 2018 #35
I think it's simply adorable you believe had she not said what she did, LanternWaste Mar 2018 #49
Can you point to the quote where she told Wisconsin they are backwards? NCTraveler Mar 2018 #33
Sure Cuthbert Allgood Mar 2018 #75
Truth and education is the way to win minds. NCTraveler Mar 2018 #80
That's the whole problem right there. alarimer Mar 2018 #62
She is totally correct. MoonRiver Mar 2018 #6
K&R stonecutter357 Mar 2018 #7
Hillary's problem was/is the noise machine that dramatically overanalyzed her every comment Freethinker65 Mar 2018 #8
Her Actual Quote erpowers Mar 2018 #9
Obama said much the same thing with the guns and religion comment...and it is true. Demsrule86 Mar 2018 #10
It is patently and abundantly true. dalton99a Mar 2018 #20
It is true. Demsrule86 Mar 2018 #73
I thought of that too when I saw this. Eliot Rosewater Mar 2018 #34
I don't think some get how much trouble we are in... I hope we can hang on until we take the house Demsrule86 Mar 2018 #72
Lying gets us nowhere. We need to call out their lies. Initech Mar 2018 #11
There's a poll up now on DU that last time I checked showed Tom Rinaldo Mar 2018 #12
Her comments Nasruddin Mar 2018 #56
Such a simple concept missed on almost everyone on this thread BoneyardDem Mar 2018 #85
Excellent analysis! question everything Mar 2018 #58
It's worse than that -- "Things ain't what they used to be, and probably never was." eppur_se_muova Mar 2018 #14
Could anyone answer me how we are going to win in 2020.... ollie10 Mar 2018 #15
HRC lost the EC in some states by only a few thousand votes Proud Liberal Dem Mar 2018 #22
It's not horse shoes....close doesn't count ollie10 Mar 2018 #25
The problem was russian hack and Comey. JI7 Mar 2018 #26
There were many problems ollie10 Mar 2018 #31
Obama didn't rant and rave either and lost there JI7 Mar 2018 #41
her deplorables comment hurt her ollie10 Mar 2018 #45
Obama lost that district before deplorable comment. JI7 Mar 2018 #50
didn't say that ollie10 Mar 2018 #52
But HRC isn't running in 2020 Proud Liberal Dem Mar 2018 #28
Hillary is a great fund raiser ollie10 Mar 2018 #39
And yet Obama still lost that district. And there is a reason Biden and not Obama JI7 Mar 2018 #44
But Lamb won. Seems to me Lamb did something right ollie10 Mar 2018 #47
Yes, lamb did what he had to in that district which is not reprrsentative of the country as a whol JI7 Mar 2018 #51
Very True and Very Pragmatic hueymahl Mar 2018 #29
Good question BeyondGeography Mar 2018 #36
I can. Caliman73 Mar 2018 #59
Knowing Nasruddin Mar 2018 #63
Meanwhile their precious Shithole is spewing lies and insults 24/7 dalton99a Mar 2018 #17
Criticizing Hillary is a popular thing around here. Eliot Rosewater Mar 2018 #37
George Lakoff said as much, before the election. Patriarchy is deeply, subtly embedded. nt wiggs Mar 2018 #18
I say it's time to get Hillary out of the White House dalton99a Mar 2018 #21
Yeah, Fox keeps putting her in dhol82 Mar 2018 #60
Dems should listen to Lakoff. Funtatlaguy Mar 2018 #40
What good politically does this accomplish? SHRED Mar 2018 #23
Would Trump voters somehow vote for Democrats if she simply did not say it? LanternWaste Mar 2018 #27
There were Obama to Trump voters Cuthbert Allgood Mar 2018 #77
Deplorables Are Deplorables For A Reason PaulX2 Mar 2018 #24
She was right about a LOT of things NastyRiffraff Mar 2018 #38
+1. "She's a private citizen not running for anything, she can say what she wants" dalton99a Mar 2018 #43
She knows what she is talking about pandr32 Mar 2018 #46
Tough balancing act Awsi Dooger Mar 2018 #48
What past? malthaussen Mar 2018 #53
Good article Gothmog Mar 2018 #57
Republicans are right... and so is Hillary zaj Mar 2018 #61
She is honest, and tells the truth. I admire her for that. Too bad that those lunamagica Mar 2018 #66
Hillary's Comments Tend to Get to the Heart of the Matter - Thus the Endless Criticism dlk Mar 2018 #69
Thank you Wwcd Mar 2018 #78
Telling the truth MichMary Mar 2018 #81
This Egnever Mar 2018 #83
She was correct, and the Republicans got what they had been yapping about all through Obama's Admin BoneyardDem Mar 2018 #82
Never have understood why the term "elitist" is supposed to be an insult. I suppose those patricia92243 Mar 2018 #89
Some fact checking Gothmog Mar 2018 #90

MrsCoffee

(5,801 posts)
2. She has been right about the majority of things she has ever spoken about.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 10:18 AM
Mar 2018

Too bad so many useful idiots haven't figured that out. We could have had great things.

Eliot Rosewater

(31,106 posts)
30. Rolling Stone talked about the issues with Bill Clinton not being the liberal they thought
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:19 PM
Mar 2018

he would be, Hunter S. Thompson and Jann both were somewhat disappointed.

But compared to any repub he is a great president and very liberal.

Problem is Hillary is FAR more liberal than Bill, always has been or certainly since her late 20's. She would have been one of the 3 best presidents of ALL TIME.

But many people who claim to also be liberal constantly BASHED her to the point the other guy won.

Caliman73

(11,726 posts)
54. Part of the problem with Bill Clinton is the he was too in love with .. Bill Clinton.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:40 PM
Mar 2018

He seemed to like the power and attention and while he had some good policies and did decent things, his overarching goal was to be remembered as a good, powerful president.


Hillary on the other hand, seemed always to be thinking about what was right for the most people. Sometimes that isn't popular. I think a lot of people projected a lot of Bill's identity onto her. She was power hungry, she was not trustworthy. The fact is that she has been the same person since she came up through the ranks, after she ditched the "Goldwater Girl" phase, she has been a moderate to left leaning progressive with a special emphasis on the needs of women and children. That is not a bad thing, unless you are a wealthy person or someone who wants to keep women in a subservient role in society.

Those are the people who have really gone after Hillary. They are the ones who have smeared her with every bad thing that you could heap onto a politician. Hillary played the men's game of politics and succeeded and for that she was branded with so much hate.

MrsCoffee

(5,801 posts)
64. If you want to see someone drunk on power and in love with himself look at Trump.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 01:02 PM
Mar 2018

Trying to trash Bill or Hillary is not a good strategy for Democrats. No need to carry right wingers water for them.

LisaM

(27,794 posts)
68. Well, the only president my life got markedly better under was Bill Clinton.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 01:13 PM
Mar 2018

My circumstances improved enormously and have plateaued ever since.

I find him to have a lot of empathy (even though he was mocked for it), and no more of a narcissist than any other president, and that includes Barack Obama (note: I am not calling either one of them narcissists, but if you think Bill Clinton is, than it stands to reason that you'd think Obama is, too).

Hermit-The-Prog

(33,259 posts)
3. i'm still cheering Hillary
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 10:22 AM
Mar 2018

I don't like the piling on.

She won more voters in spite of 3 decades of hate propaganda.

She won more voters in spite of a measurable, later confessed, bias in the media.

She won more voters in spite of Charlie Rose's obsession with emails and Matt Lauer's rude interruptions and attacks.

She won more voters in spite of Comey's possible violation of the Hatch act.

She won more voters in spite of 28 months of "insvestigation" right up through election day.

She won more voters in spite of rallies of demented mob hysteria highlighted by screams of, "Lock her up!".

She won more voters in spite of election "irregularities".

She won more voters in spite of a sophisticated, extensive, covert Russian 'psyops' operation.

She's a hero.

Hermit-The-Prog

(33,259 posts)
86. you folks make me feel less alone
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 05:05 PM
Mar 2018

Sometimes it seems the Hillary correctors and bashers get most of the press. We need to remind them from time to time what she withstood and still got the most votes.

Oh, yeah, and she remained civil through the whole ordeal.

 

Wwcd

(6,288 posts)
87. Hey Hermit, I must say that I look for your posts because of how & what you write.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 05:14 PM
Mar 2018

Always interesting, to the point & wise, true & fair.

Thanks for your contribution my friend 🍃🕊✌🌎

Mike Nelson

(9,944 posts)
4. She's correct...
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 10:29 AM
Mar 2018

...I am happy she's still saying this... the "media" wants to hide the fact that we have what she called the deplorables. They are a minority, but they are there and should be called out.

onetexan

(13,023 posts)
13. agree, the truth hurts but it is the truth
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 11:14 AM
Mar 2018

Hillary had the gumption to call it what it is, whether the deplorables like it or not. Just goes to show the need for an educated masses.

Cuthbert Allgood

(4,907 posts)
5. As someone who lives in Wisconsin
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 10:30 AM
Mar 2018

telling Wisconsin that they are backwards is not going to help the Dems to win the state in 2020. But, sure, rah rah Clinton.

question everything

(47,437 posts)
16. Well said.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 11:54 AM
Mar 2018

The question for the rest of the year, and until 2020 is do we do everything to take over Congress, including appealing to Trump voters, or do stick by "principles?"

But I am getting hoarse just trying to keep telling this

https://www.democraticunderground.com/100210358115

question everything

(47,437 posts)
55. Yes, 500 in PA met the "off chance" and voted Dem
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:44 PM
Mar 2018

Every vote counts, at least until we remove that enemy - really he is an enemy - from the White House. Or, at least, clip his wings.

I suspect that many who voted for Lamb would be viewed by us as bigots. We don't need to tell them it is OK, but we do not need to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. This is politics, not a court of law.

ismnotwasm

(41,967 posts)
65. Are you fucking kidding me?
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 01:05 PM
Mar 2018

Pandering to bigots is not a winning strategy and it’s not what Lamb did. You “suspecting” these bigots implies they need to be code talked that racism is ok. How will that play in areas with say, large numbers of Black voters? You can’t have it both ways, and I can’t believe we are having this conversation

 

BoneyardDem

(1,202 posts)
84. Correct...and any switch votes occurred because of Trump's toxic Presidency
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 02:09 PM
Mar 2018

We Dems do not have to woo bigots...they are un-woo-able. Those Reps that are not lying, bigoted, misogynistic assholes will separate themselves from that crowd. But that cannot be counted on.

I'd say take the time and make the effort not to woo Republicans, but woo those that need a little push to understand politics, the huge role it plays in our lives, to educate those that don't live on BB's or watch MNSBC.

 

NCTraveler

(30,481 posts)
35. No one wants you to get "hoarse".
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:25 PM
Mar 2018

You can simply back of of the hyperbole being employed attacking Clinton.

 

LanternWaste

(37,748 posts)
49. I think it's simply adorable you believe had she not said what she did,
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:32 PM
Mar 2018

I think it's simply adorable you believe had she not said what she did, we'd have more Trump voters.

But I'm getting hoarse asking why objective evidence is never presented supporting the claim.

 

NCTraveler

(30,481 posts)
33. Can you point to the quote where she told Wisconsin they are backwards?
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:20 PM
Mar 2018

Not that it matter. A lot about Wisconsin's voters is backwards.

Who is the governor that forward thinking state?

Cuthbert Allgood

(4,907 posts)
75. Sure
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 01:26 PM
Mar 2018
"If you look at the map of the United States, there is all that red in the middle, places where Trump won," she said. "What that map doesn’t show you is that I won the places that own two thirds of America’s Gross Domestic product. I won the places that are optimistic, diverse, dynamic, moving forward. And his whole campaign, Make America Great Again, was looking backwards. You don’t like black people getting rights, you don’t like women getting jobs, you don’t want to see that Indian American succeeding more than you are, whatever that problem is, I am going to solve it."


Wisconsin went to Trump. We are a place that is "moving backward." We "don't like black people getting rights" or "don't like women getting jobs" or seeing "Indian Americans succeeding."

That's the way to win hearts in Wisconsin.
 

NCTraveler

(30,481 posts)
80. Truth and education is the way to win minds.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 01:54 PM
Mar 2018

Those who voted for Walker and Trump fit the bill.

Deplorables. Racist bigoted deplorables. I seem to know something about Wisconsin. We are much better off going for non-voters than bringing racists and bigots into the fold.

alarimer

(16,245 posts)
62. That's the whole problem right there.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:57 PM
Mar 2018

And many of the locations we are talking about are truly suffering. They've shed jobs due in part to policies enacted by both parties, but mostly to endless corporate greed.

Actually denigrating these places and people is not something politicians should ever do. It's good that she isn't running for anything and I hope she never does again, but I would say the same thing about anyone.

Freethinker65

(10,001 posts)
8. Hillary's problem was/is the noise machine that dramatically overanalyzed her every comment
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 10:35 AM
Mar 2018

Overanalyzed her every comment to twist what she said into disparaging crucial portions of the electorate. Worse comments made by her opponents about equally crucial voters seldom made the news cycle for more than a few days, then were forgotten about.

Romney's inopportune caught on tape "47%" comment comes close, as does Obama's "clinging to guns and bibles" comment.

The media has been demonizing Clinton's words since her "at home baking cookies" days, if not before. It was pretty obvious she was not against those women that chose to not have professional careers, but instead was tired of defending her choice to have a career. We know how that twisting of words and overanalyzing turned out.

Unfortunately, the alternative to all of this is to silence her, and all women who speak up. That is NOT going to happen, nor should it.

erpowers

(9,350 posts)
9. Her Actual Quote
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 10:37 AM
Mar 2018

Her actual quote does not seem as bad as what was discussed in the media. I watched a little bit of Egberto Willie yesterday and he gave the main quote. It seemed like she was talking about the economic direction of the states and not the people of the state. She may have mentioned something about the way people thought, but it seemed like the main point was that Trump supporters want to take the country backwards economically. His supporters wanted to stick with oil and gas; her supporters wanted to move forward to renewable energy.

Demsrule86

(68,469 posts)
10. Obama said much the same thing with the guns and religion comment...and it is true.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 10:41 AM
Mar 2018

"And it's not surprising then that they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren't like them or anti-immigrant sentiment or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations," Obama said.

Eliot Rosewater

(31,106 posts)
34. I thought of that too when I saw this.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:21 PM
Mar 2018

I wish I had a different rule, by the way, some Clinton hating democratic party hating posters on this board, in this thread, boy would I like to give them a piece of my mind

The one who says Hillary "ranted and railed", boy would I like to say something there, but I wont betray my rule.

Demsrule86

(68,469 posts)
72. I don't think some get how much trouble we are in... I hope we can hang on until we take the house
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 01:23 PM
Mar 2018

and hopefully Senate which shuts down judges...we are in real danger right now from Trump and the GOP enablers.

Initech

(100,041 posts)
11. Lying gets us nowhere. We need to call out their lies.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 10:45 AM
Mar 2018

Trump lies so much that his lies have their own unique layers to them. If we start telling the truth we will win. It's worked so far in 43 elections, it can work for more!

Tom Rinaldo

(22,911 posts)
12. There's a poll up now on DU that last time I checked showed
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 10:48 AM
Mar 2018

100% of us happy that Lamb just won the special election in PA. Right now it appears he won by less than 700 votes, less than a third of one percent of votes cast. Statistics also reveal that a much lower percentage of registered Republicans bothered to vote in the special election than did Democrats. A lot of Democrats were motivated by anger at Trump, Republicans it seems had much less motivating them. So a Democrat won the district.

Hillary made her comments in India over the weekend and it took a little while for reporting on them to spread. They did not seem to make the list of closing arguments made by the candidates in that race. They weren't known when Trump showed up to hold his rally in that district.

The question is, had Hillary made those comments a week earlier, would the Republicans have been able to weaponize them against Lamb directly? The outcome of his race was razor thin. Less than 700 votes, but actually it only would have taken 350 people switching their votes to make the results dead even. And while most Lamb voters were solidly in his camp, some who had voted for Trump before were conflicted until the end.

There are choices beyond saying the truth about something that is highly charged unprompted and having to lie about it. Winning an election is a lot more significant than winning a football game. In sports sometimes it is better to forfeit a game than not kneel down on principle. Lives, however, literally rest in the valence during elections. Skilled politicians are usually very careful about what they say in public for good reasons. Hillary is a skilled politician but no one plays politics perfectly. In this case I believe she didn't.

Nasruddin

(750 posts)
56. Her comments
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:44 PM
Mar 2018

I agree with your argument here, but I can't help but note the ironical situation we are in.
The president is about as impolitic as anyone can get, but he was quite successful with it, and continues to be so with his base (one can certainly see changes at the margin).

 

BoneyardDem

(1,202 posts)
85. Such a simple concept missed on almost everyone on this thread
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 02:23 PM
Mar 2018

Hillary won more votes. Is NOT Pres and is overly analyzed with every word, even while NOT running for a new office.
MEANWHILE
Trump; liar, racist, misogynistic womanizer, illiterate, juvenile name calling, crass and insulting gets to be POTUS with less votes.

Facts to be considered, Trump's base is dwindling...as evidenced by the PA18 election. Evangelicals are starting to realize the duplicity of Trump. The world consistently rolls their eyes at the failing world status of the USA. Trump has horrid PR issues. Why Dems can't seem to focus on this rather than bash Hillary making any 1st A statement is rather odd.

eppur_se_muova

(36,247 posts)
14. It's worse than that -- "Things ain't what they used to be, and probably never was."
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 11:19 AM
Mar 2018

The redhat utopia is from an imagined past. The reality wasn't good for most people.

 

ollie10

(2,091 posts)
15. Could anyone answer me how we are going to win in 2020....
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 11:38 AM
Mar 2018

....without getting some votes from voters who voted for Trump in 2016? without winning some states that voted for Trump in 2016?

You don't get someone to vote for you by calling them a deplorable. You don't get someone to vote for you if you call them a racist, a misogynist, an idiot.

The voters that we CAN reach are those who are scared....they were scared about the economy and their future in 2016. The true Trumpers are unreachable....but there were some who didn't like Hillary for some reason and wanted to give Trump a chance. Now these folks may be wavering......

If we hammer home on the issues of the economy, the tax cut that helped the rich and only gave them a few crumbs and health care...we can pull some of them to vote for us. If we call them an idiot, or a deplorable, or a racist....they will recoil and they won't be as likely to join us. Why would anyone expect them to?

We already have a lot of enthusiasm on our side. But it is not enough to just have the same folks vote in 2020 as in 2016....or we get the same result. We need to peel off people who didn't vote for us last time. The positively WORST way to do this is by attacking Trump and calling them deplorables.

But if it makes you feel good, and are willing to risk four more years of Trump to make you feel good, then join Hillary and rant and rave about the deplorables. It just won't win elections, that's all. Your choice.

Proud Liberal Dem

(24,396 posts)
22. HRC lost the EC in some states by only a few thousand votes
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:09 PM
Mar 2018

and the vote was split in four ways between her and Trump and Johnson and Stein. It's doable. Trump's popularity has been in the toilet pretty much since he started. I'm sure that he's lost a few voters and I find it hard to believe that a decent Democratic Presidential candidate with a decent agenda and lack of serious Democratic Party infighting wouldn't be enough to topple Trump in 2020 (assuming he's still in office). Hopefully, people will have learned their lessons from 2016. Maybe?


Oh, and Hillary won't be running in 2020, so why does it matter so much what she said (and people will likely have forgotten these comments by 2020, if not in a few days)?

 

ollie10

(2,091 posts)
25. It's not horse shoes....close doesn't count
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:14 PM
Mar 2018

Which solidifies my contention that we have to be running on all of our cylinders going into 2020.

You don't get someone to vote for you by insulting them.

If we haven't learned from that mistake, heaven help us

 

ollie10

(2,091 posts)
31. There were many problems
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:19 PM
Mar 2018

And we would be wise to correct as many as we can instead of trying to sweep them under the rug or pretend they do not exist.

Lamb won Tuesday. He didn't win by attacking Trump. That would have been counter-productive and/or a waste of time. He did it by showing voters why they should vote for him, stressing core D values of the economy, attacking the tax cuts and the attacks on health care.

I guarantee if he had ranted and railed and said just what Hillary just said, he would have lost in a landslide, just like Hillary did in that district in 2016

JI7

(89,241 posts)
41. Obama didn't rant and rave either and lost there
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:27 PM
Mar 2018

Not every district is like that one.

Lamb did what he had to in that type of district.

Lamb also didn't support as much gun control as most democrats want.

What hurt Hillary wad russia and Comey. Not failing to run like lamb which nationally would not work because of a more diverse and liberal constituency than that one district.

 

ollie10

(2,091 posts)
45. her deplorables comment hurt her
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:29 PM
Mar 2018

that's why she backed off it. but it was too late.

and here she is saying similar stuff, no lesson learned.

The only people that liked what hillary said were people who were going to vote D anyway.

JI7

(89,241 posts)
50. Obama lost that district before deplorable comment.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:33 PM
Mar 2018

These people hate seeing black people protest unfair targeting by cops also so maybe poc should just accept bigotry against them.

 

ollie10

(2,091 posts)
52. didn't say that
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:35 PM
Mar 2018

what I said was hillary said the deplorable comment during the campaign, she realized it was a mistake and had to stop....but now she is up to similar comments which are not going to help Ds and probably will hurt us.

Proud Liberal Dem

(24,396 posts)
28. But HRC isn't running in 2020
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:18 PM
Mar 2018

And if Democrats (for some reason) need to disavow her comments, then so be it. I just don't think most people are going to remember these comments by 2020 (they may not even remember them by the end of the day given Trump's constant shenanigans) and/or hold Democrats accountable for them. The people likely to be upset about them and/or not understand the context of them aren't likely to vote for Democrats anyway.

 

ollie10

(2,091 posts)
39. Hillary is a great fund raiser
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:26 PM
Mar 2018

She should continue doing that. Send her to California and the coasts. And someone tell her that you don't see Obama saying stupid stuff like she did last week.

Just keep her out of districts that voted for Trump last time. The Ds running in those districts don't need that kind of help.

JI7

(89,241 posts)
44. And yet Obama still lost that district. And there is a reason Biden and not Obama
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:28 PM
Mar 2018

Was asked to campaign there.

 

ollie10

(2,091 posts)
47. But Lamb won. Seems to me Lamb did something right
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:31 PM
Mar 2018

If hillary had come to Pittsburgh and said that deplorable stuff last week, Lamb would have lost going away.

JI7

(89,241 posts)
51. Yes, lamb did what he had to in that district which is not reprrsentative of the country as a whol
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:34 PM
Mar 2018

hueymahl

(2,449 posts)
29. Very True and Very Pragmatic
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:18 PM
Mar 2018

Hopefully it will start to sink in some that we need to actually practice politics instead of saying just what makes us feel good.

BeyondGeography

(39,351 posts)
36. Good question
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:25 PM
Mar 2018

Much better than the answers you have received so far.

My two cents: Forget the popular vote; HRC won by three million and her margin was 4.5 million in California, which is how we profoundly got our asses kicked in the electoral college. An estimated 8.4 million people who voted for Obama over Romney in 2012 switched to Trump. This strikes me as a major problem. We need to understand who the persuadables are among them and win them back. Questioning their humanity and the quality of their worldview probably isn't the best place to start.

Caliman73

(11,726 posts)
59. I can.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:50 PM
Mar 2018

We do our best to minimize the interference from Russian trolls

We do our best to counteract or overcome the voter suppression tactics that Republicans used to disenfranchise Democratic voters

We focus on local policies that will help the most people (typically, any policy that will help poor working Black women, will benefit everyone in society)

We do NOT stop calling out racism, bigotry, and misogyny for political expedience.

As others have said, Hillary lost within a margin of error and cheating in the last election. Lanny Davis puts together a very compelling case about how Comey's interference and the fake email scandal were the margin of victory for Trump in the last few weeks of the election.

This whole idea that "We need Trump voters" is bullshit. We DO need to bring some of the 46% of the population who are eligible to vote, out from their stupor, but that is not who Hillary Clinton is talking about. She is talking about the people who supported and continue to hold out hope for Trump.

Nasruddin

(750 posts)
63. Knowing
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:59 PM
Mar 2018

"You don't get someone to vote for you by calling them a deplorable."
You are absolutely right about this - that was a "deplorable" mistake to be sure.
As I said elsewhere, though, her opponent buried the whole country in a barrage of stuff like that and worse - and won. I guess it's a matter of charisma, and picking the right enemies. HRC was 0-2 in that instance.

To get back to your argument, it is perfectly possible to do both - we can make alliances with people with whom we have deep disagreements on important subjects, in order to accomplish a goal. HRC at some point last year mentioned Spielberg's Lincoln as a "master class" in how this was done in our past.

We allied ourselves and worked with Stalin in WWII to win that war.

But we can also be 100% clear about what and whom we are working with, what our limits are, and theirs. We didn't do that with Stalin and the Soviet Union, at least not coherently, and it cost us - the whole world - later. How do we separate stating this and discussing it, from name-calling? Is that what Hillary did, or was it made to look that way?

Eliot Rosewater

(31,106 posts)
37. Criticizing Hillary is a popular thing around here.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:25 PM
Mar 2018

It is popular to do it in other places as well.

Assuming she isnt running again, these SAME attacks will start against whoever does.

dhol82

(9,352 posts)
60. Yeah, Fox keeps putting her in
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:50 PM
Mar 2018

Amazing how they keep forgetting what happened during the election.

Funtatlaguy

(10,862 posts)
40. Dems should listen to Lakoff.
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:26 PM
Mar 2018

He is our version of Frank Luntz...the Repub strategist and pollster who does a lot of focus groups.

 

SHRED

(28,136 posts)
23. What good politically does this accomplish?
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:12 PM
Mar 2018

Are the "backwards" residents of tRump States going to hear this and think, "yeah, I'm stuck in the past and need to change".
Are Democrats somehow educated by this that we already know?

 

LanternWaste

(37,748 posts)
27. Would Trump voters somehow vote for Democrats if she simply did not say it?
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:15 PM
Mar 2018

"What good politically does this accomplish?"
Accuracy is always good, regardless of party.

"Are Democrats somehow educated by this that we already know?"
Would Trump voters somehow vote for Democrats if she simply did not say it?

But I get it... acting beholden to simplistic commercial branding and thirty-second attention spans lacking context or nuance is a very high concern. L

Cuthbert Allgood

(4,907 posts)
77. There were Obama to Trump voters
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 01:35 PM
Mar 2018

So we can certainly try to get them back. Do you think this is going to help?

 

PaulX2

(2,032 posts)
24. Deplorables Are Deplorables For A Reason
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:13 PM
Mar 2018

They still don't like being called names, even though they are pathetic scum.

Here's the plan.

Some of us reach out to them. Make them respond to facts.

The rest of us Call them lying racist cult scum to their faces.

Good cop, bad cop.

Won't help.

We will simply outnumber them.

Love, justice, and reality shall triumph over hate.

NastyRiffraff

(12,448 posts)
38. She was right about a LOT of things
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:25 PM
Mar 2018

She warned the country, again and again, about how dangerous Donald Trump was. She was widely criticized for using the word "dangerous," but she was right.

Now that she's a private citizen not running for anything, she can say what she wants. Of course she'll be criticized; she always was and always will be. But she's been right most of the time and likely will continue to be. The people who are JUST OUTRAGED that she implies that some white married Republican women are pressured to vote like men want them to won't look at the facts. I don't like those facts either, but I'm a member of the Reality Based Community. (remember us)?

pandr32

(11,560 posts)
46. She knows what she is talking about
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:30 PM
Mar 2018

It is time we trusted her and listened. If we don't understand why Republican women do what they do how can we begin to approach them? The women's movement will not end until it reaches its goals.

 

Awsi Dooger

(14,565 posts)
48. Tough balancing act
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:32 PM
Mar 2018

Decades from now Hillary will soar in popularity and be seen as a truth telling visionary, while Trump will be isolated as the laughingstock president from our history.

But right now that Silent Generation and other fearful groups plus right wing media are still boosting Trump and his party to sufficient level to win elections. Trump is going to own severe benefit of a doubt in 2020. That's what posters here and on other Democratic sites are preferring to deny. I warned about in with Bush in 2004. Incumbents are hellish to remove. We need an ideal candidate and can't afford to bleed any more support via unfortunate comments that will linger. Only in that regard do I wish Hillary would self edit for a while.

Mostly we require independents to remain slanted our way. GOTV means nothing compared to independent preference. That's the unfortunate reality. If independents are sampled on Hillary's remarks and approve of them, then let her keep talking.

malthaussen

(17,175 posts)
53. What past?
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:37 PM
Mar 2018

You mean the one that never existed?

The excerpt makes no reference to "living in the past."

-- Mal

 

zaj

(3,433 posts)
61. Republicans are right... and so is Hillary
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 12:53 PM
Mar 2018

We need a way to embrace change without alienating those who are reluctant to embrace it.

We need to find the right words, that comes from listening.

What made Obama amazing was his ability to do exactly this.

lunamagica

(9,967 posts)
66. She is honest, and tells the truth. I admire her for that. Too bad that those
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 01:09 PM
Mar 2018

qualities are seen by some in such negative light.

dlk

(11,514 posts)
69. Hillary's Comments Tend to Get to the Heart of the Matter - Thus the Endless Criticism
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 01:15 PM
Mar 2018

It's part of the hazard of being an extremely intelligent and competent woman who isn't afraid to tell the truth.

 

Wwcd

(6,288 posts)
78. Thank you
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 01:44 PM
Mar 2018

People keep trying to prove Hillary wrong.
They can't.
Thus attack her with name calling like the immature bullys they are.

The facts are on her side, indeed

MichMary

(1,714 posts)
81. Telling the truth
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 01:59 PM
Mar 2018

When I was two or three, I told the lady next door that she was fat. It was true, but I still got punished for it.

When telling the truth isn't going to change things, sometimes we're better off not telling it.

 

BoneyardDem

(1,202 posts)
82. She was correct, and the Republicans got what they had been yapping about all through Obama's Admin
Thu Mar 15, 2018, 02:01 PM
Mar 2018

"I want my country back"

Of course, the rest of us would like to progress and move forward...but that's a whole other story.

patricia92243

(12,592 posts)
89. Never have understood why the term "elitist" is supposed to be an insult. I suppose those
Fri Mar 16, 2018, 07:09 AM
Mar 2018

people don't like well-educated, smart, or progressive. I guess they think "redneck" is a compliment.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Hillary Clinton was right...