General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsPortland Press Herald, Maine's largest paper: Kavanaugh doesn't belong on the Supreme Court
https://www.pressherald.com/2018/09/28/our-view-brett-kavanaugh-has-shown-he-doesnt-belong-on-the-supreme-court/In his widely watched appearance, Kavanaugh revealed that he has an explosive temper and resorts to bullying when he feels threatened. He was understandably under stress and fighting a high-stakes battle for his reputation, but his temperament was tested during the hearing, and he failed the test.
Kavanaugh also showed himself to be impermissibly political for a job that is supposed to be above politics. Were not naive. We understand that federal judges are nominated by presidents and confirmed by senators, and that electoral politics influences their decisions about who gets to serve.
But we have never had a Supreme Court nominee who ripped off the nonpartisan mask the way Kavanaugh did Thursday and identified himself as an enemy of a political party that represents the policy preferences of millions of Americans. He blamed his predicament on bizarre conspiracy theories, claiming that his troubles stemmed from pent-up anger about President Trump and opponents seeking revenge on behalf of the Clintons and were not the result of allegations that emerged while he was being evaluated for an important job. After his partisan rant, Kavanaugh will never be able to judge a case without the animus he expressed being considered a factor in his decision. This is not the road we want to take.
And when he was talking about his high school years, he said things that, frankly, could not be believed. The self-proclaimed treasurer of the 100 Kegs or Bust club says he was not much of a drinker.
His comment about ralphing was an innocent reference to his sensitive stomach and not related to heavy drinking. And, most incredibly, a group of football players posing for a picture calling themselves the Renate Alumni a stunt that reeked of sexual boasting about a girl named Renate were clumsily trying to show affection for a friend. The attempt was so clumsy that they never shared it with their friend, who learned about the joke only recently. She told The New York Times: The insinuation is horrible, hurtful and simply untrue. I pray their daughters are never treated this way.
These are small things, but they matter. Many adults are embarrassed about what they did when they were young, and it is human nature to minimize some of the details. But when you have taken an oath to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth, its not time to fudge the facts. If confirmed, Kavanaugh would bring this same lack of credibility with him to the place in the country where credibility matters more than anything.
If there were nothing else on his record, the Senate would have solid grounds not to confirm Kavanaugh. But its not the only thing. Not by a long shot.
Kavanaugh is the subject of credible allegations of sexual misconduct. It is incredible that any senator would want to vote to confirm him until the allegations have been thoroughly investigated.
-snip-
lillypaddle
(9,580 posts)or, if you will, no shit.
MyOwnPeace
(16,919 posts)When the links are posted I often go to them to read the full article, and, as in this case, the "responses" from the local citizenry.
We already know that the great citizens of the great state of Maine have issues with their governor, but, oh-my-GAWD, they've got some others there that have been given computers and are sending out messages!
It serves as a reminder: WE MUST GET OUT THE VOTE!!!!!
REMEMBER, "THEY" VOTE TOO!!!!!!
dalton99a
(81,404 posts)TheBlackAdder
(28,167 posts)CrispyQ
(36,424 posts)Collins (R-ME) (202) 224-2523
Here's what I said.
Women are going to remember how you and Senator Murkowski vote on this nominee. Next time you run for re-election, and for you Senator Collins, that's in 2020, we are going to post that video of Kavanaugh screeching & going ballistic at the hearing, all over social media, with your names attached. [State your name & zip code here.]
Bernardo de La Paz
(48,964 posts)DFW
(54,302 posts)She may not be the brightest star in the constellation, but she HAS to know what will be coming her way if she votes to confirm, ESPECIALLY since, if confirmed, Kavanawful will have had the time to cast some dreadful votes on the SC already.
But I'm hoping she decides to retire even if she DOES vote to reject. Maine deserves newer blood. Well, better blood, anyway. Angus King is over 70, but he's sharp as a tack, where Collins is sharp as a mushroom.
Cha
(296,859 posts)ooky
(8,908 posts)Clintons in his little off the rails partisan rant. Its really unbelievable a judge would say such a dumb thing. I was shocked.