Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
37 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Speaking as a Catholic (Original Post) anamnua Aug 2020 OP
For me was the derision of Establishment Democrats. LakeArenal Aug 2020 #1
Speaking as a Catholic, Bullshit! Maybe if this came from another news source, but from KPN Aug 2020 #2
Sorry anamnua Aug 2020 #3
Speaking as an Ex-Catholic maxsolomon Aug 2020 #4
Incidentally Damien-bashing has a long vintage anamnua Aug 2020 #5
Speaking as one raised a Catholic she's right. He went there as a missionary to convert the natives. Autumn Aug 2020 #6
Lol! demmiblue Aug 2020 #7
Cool. Now do this: ok_cpu Aug 2020 #8
The majority of Catholic voters cast their ballots for Trump in 2016. Mariana Aug 2020 #11
She answered that. hunter Aug 2020 #9
I have to say my blood boiled on reading her diatribe. anamnua Aug 2020 #10
Thank you for quoting President Obama. When I was growing up in Hawai'i, every schoolchild... Hekate Aug 2020 #29
Primary is over. whttevrr Aug 2020 #12
It doesn't matter who the politician is or at what stage of the electoral cycle they are at. anamnua Aug 2020 #13
You are actively disparaging a Democratic Representative in an election whttevrr Aug 2020 #14
I am actually sticking up for progressive Democratic principles. anamnua Aug 2020 #15
What kind of Bullshittery is this? whttevrr Aug 2020 #16
As you will see from my second post anamnua Aug 2020 #17
Bull Fucking Shit - AOC: "At no point did I say Fr. Damien was a bad figure" whttevrr Aug 2020 #22
This has been pointed out several times FreeState Aug 2020 #30
Didn't you know? Bettie Aug 2020 #19
I am bashing her for misinformed comments on Fr. Damien. anamnua Aug 2020 #20
So, everyone must say certain things about certain Catholics? Bettie Aug 2020 #21
Post removed Post removed Aug 2020 #25
AOC is a particular target Bettie Aug 2020 #28
Don't you know? AOC is above criticism when she blunders. And this time she blundered. Perhaps... Hekate Aug 2020 #31
This guy nails it anamnua Aug 2020 #18
Speaking as an American whttevrr Aug 2020 #23
Amen. yortsed snacilbuper Aug 2020 #27
The oldest trick in the book. anamnua Aug 2020 #37
. Iggo Aug 2020 #32
EWTN is right wing theocratic propaganda. Dawson Leery Aug 2020 #24
Source aside whttevrr Aug 2020 #26
Nice shit-stir! Iggo Aug 2020 #33
Decided to consolidate my replies here. When I was growing up in Hawai'i, every schoolchild... Hekate Aug 2020 #34
Many thanks for your kind and informed comments. anamnua Aug 2020 #35
Here was a man anamnua Aug 2020 #36

KPN

(15,638 posts)
2. Speaking as a Catholic, Bullshit! Maybe if this came from another news source, but from
Thu Aug 6, 2020, 02:09 PM
Aug 2020

a source that lobs softballs for tRump to hit out of the park in interviews without absolutley no follow questions -- pure, unadulterated bullshit.

anamnua

(1,103 posts)
3. Sorry
Thu Aug 6, 2020, 02:18 PM
Aug 2020

Last edited Thu Aug 6, 2020, 03:01 PM - Edit history (1)

Being on the other side of the pond (Ireland) i am not overly familiar with the political inclinations/nuances of various American media operations. I just picked one at random that seemed to cover the issue. What's important here is the message issue raised by AOC rather than the outlet that highlights it. Incidentally it's in quite a few media sources many of which I presume don't pose a problem for you.
Anyway here is a detailed link from the UK Catholic Herald -- an organisation with which, I presume, you don't have an issue:
https://catholicherald.co.uk/a-roundup-of-reaction-to-ocasio-cortezs-st-damien-memorial-critique/

maxsolomon

(33,252 posts)
4. Speaking as an Ex-Catholic
Thu Aug 6, 2020, 02:21 PM
Aug 2020

AOC (who was likely at least raised Catholic as she's Latina) said the saint was indicative of Colonialism. The author doesn't dispute that assertion, just says that Damien was selfless.

Both things can be true.

BTW, King Kamehameha "united" the islands in a brutal war of conquest. He gets a statue in DC, as well.
https://warfarehistorynetwork.com/2016/11/07/king-kamehamehas-conquest-of-hawaii/



Autumn

(44,986 posts)
6. Speaking as one raised a Catholic she's right. He went there as a missionary to convert the natives.
Thu Aug 6, 2020, 02:29 PM
Aug 2020

Mariana

(14,854 posts)
11. The majority of Catholic voters cast their ballots for Trump in 2016.
Thu Aug 6, 2020, 06:45 PM
Aug 2020

It seems Daniel Dale and EWTN would like that to happen again.

hunter

(38,304 posts)
9. She answered that.
Thu Aug 6, 2020, 03:15 PM
Aug 2020



Yep.

At no point did I say Fr. Damien was a bad figure - in fact, I explicitly stated that my observations weren’t about litigating his or any individual statue.

It’s about the fact that a huge supermajority of statues in the Capitol are white men. Barely any women or BIPOC.


"Conservative" Catholics are hypocrites. Quite a few of them are fascists and misogynists as well.

The cultural contributions of Hawaiian women, like all women, are largely erased from history.

(I'm a left wing Catholic heretic, radical environmentalist, and social justice warrior, it that matters...)

anamnua

(1,103 posts)
10. I have to say my blood boiled on reading her diatribe.
Thu Aug 6, 2020, 06:38 PM
Aug 2020

Make no mistake about it: this will remain a serious stain on her record unless and until she apologises.
She picked the wrong statue to tilt at -- to put it at its mildest.
After Damien was canonized in 2009, President Obama wrote the following words to Pope Benedict XVI:

Fr. Damien has also earned a special place in the hearts of Hawaiians. I recall many stories from my youth about his tireless work there to care for those suffering from leprosy who had been cast out. Following in the steps of Jesus' ministry to the lepers, Fr. Damien challenged the stigmatizing effects of disease, giving voice to the voiceless and ultimately sacrificing his own life to bring dignity to so many.


Obama was born in, and spent his formative years in, Hawaii.

Mahatma Gandhi:
The political and journalistic world can boast of very few heroes who compare with Father Damien of Molokai

Let's get real here: this guy was no Nathan Bedford Forrest or Jefferson Davis. He stepped into the breach when nobody else would. And he stuck to his healing ministry to the bitter end even when he knew he was facing into a prolonged and agonising death from leprosy.
He was essentially a penniless immigrant social worker who lived a life of vowed poverty and hardship: Ms Ocasio-Cortez is on 174,000 PA!

Hekate

(90,565 posts)
29. Thank you for quoting President Obama. When I was growing up in Hawai'i, every schoolchild...
Sun Aug 9, 2020, 09:37 PM
Aug 2020

...knew of the work of Father Damien De Veuster (as we knew him then). Leprosy was a devastating, contagious, disfiguring, and fatal disease. There was no treatment whatsoever for leprosy, and as it was highly contagious, especially among native Hawai’ians, the afflicted were simply taken to the remotest part of a remote island and let go into the surf. The remainder of their days was Hell on Earth, as their bodies decayed to the bone, pieces fell off, and maggots took residence.

Father Damien went to them, lived with them, gave them hope, helped build a place to live in with some measure of dignity, not just die in. And he himself contracted this terrible disease and died of it.

AOC speaks from a place of profound ignorance if she thinks he was a “white colonist,” and nothing else. In Hawai’i there were and are many religions. No one else came. Only Damien.

whttevrr

(2,345 posts)
12. Primary is over.
Thu Aug 6, 2020, 07:07 PM
Aug 2020

How does this post support a Democratic Representative who is currently campaigning for office?

anamnua

(1,103 posts)
13. It doesn't matter who the politician is or at what stage of the electoral cycle they are at.
Thu Aug 6, 2020, 07:39 PM
Aug 2020

If they make an asinine statement like this they deserve to be taken to task for it. Besides not a few Catholics; and not a few informed, fair-minded non-Catholics; who would consider voting for AOC will be unimpressed by her assault on a great humanitarian icon. And will remain unimpressed until she makes an effort to repair the damage.

whttevrr

(2,345 posts)
14. You are actively disparaging a Democratic Representative in an election
Thu Aug 6, 2020, 09:04 PM
Aug 2020

Primary is over.

Find something supportive to say or share it on Facebook. Not here.

anamnua

(1,103 posts)
15. I am actually sticking up for progressive Democratic principles.
Fri Aug 7, 2020, 02:19 PM
Aug 2020

Last edited Mon Aug 10, 2020, 08:22 PM - Edit history (8)

You expect certain standards from someone presenting himself/herself for election as a Democrat. If they fail to measure up to those standards you are entitled to pull them up on it. AOC, along with all Democratic representatives, is a standard-bearer for the party; therefore her comments here reflect negatively on us all.
In his advocacy for, and general support of, this marginalised and stigmatised fringe group (literally to the death) Fr. Damien actually epitomised modern, progressive, Democratic values. In traducing him she traduced the vaues she claims to uphold. The only excuse I can think of is ignorance on her part of the facts in relation to this great martyr/humanitarian. Hopefully this deficit has been corrected.
Let's paint a relatively modern analogy:
You have a geographically isolated community of impoverished, mainly non-Caucasion and of both genders, HIV sufferers in the 80s at a time when the disease was shrouded in much misinformation and stigmatisation.
A doctor decides to take care of them -- for a pittance, and working in substandard conditions -- when nobody else will.
He does so in the full understanding that he will in all probability contract HIV in so doing.
He does contract HIV.
He keeps looking after them to the bitter end -- until his own disease becomes terminal.
Decades later a statue erected to his memory is dismissed as a monument to 'patriarchy and white supremacy'!!
Let's face it, if Trump said something like this there would now be millions of google searches for 'Fr. Damien' and 500+ posts on DU rightly tearing him to shreds. But you wouldn't expect anything better from the Donald.
I would suspect that quite a few of her Puerto Rican Catholic support base have given her an earful over this. And I wouldn't be surprised if Obama, who actually knows something about Hawaii and Fr. Damien, rang her up to express some blunt opinions.
She has actually stepped into the shoes of Reverend CM Hyde in her misinformed criticisms (see my fourth post). I am doing what I can to figuratively channel Robert Louis Stevenson.
All AOC has to do to wipe the slate clean is to issue a brief apology/clarification.

whttevrr

(2,345 posts)
16. What kind of Bullshittery is this?
Fri Aug 7, 2020, 02:54 PM
Aug 2020

Do you support the Democratic candidate currently running for office?

Are you voting for anyone running on the Democratic ticket this election?



anamnua

(1,103 posts)
17. As you will see from my second post
Sat Aug 8, 2020, 01:35 PM
Aug 2020

Last edited Sat Aug 8, 2020, 07:27 PM - Edit history (1)

I am non-American and based abroad. Nevertheless I do what I can to advocate for the US Democratic Party and anywhere I've had a vote I've voted for parties whose political philosophy approximates to theirs. I hope AOC retains her seat. However the point must be made that there is a large Catholic demographic in New York (Irish, Italian, Hispanic...) for whom this saga will go down like a lead balloon.

whttevrr

(2,345 posts)
22. Bull Fucking Shit - AOC: "At no point did I say Fr. Damien was a bad figure"
Sun Aug 9, 2020, 01:48 PM
Aug 2020

"At no point did I say Fr. Damien was a bad figure - in fact, I explicitly stated that my observations weren’t about litigating his or any individual statue.

It’s about the fact that a huge supermajority of statues in the Capitol are white men. Barely any women or BIPOC."

~Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez @AOC US House candidate, NY-14




As an American I say Fuck Religious tests.

I don't care if she pissed on the pope. If my representative pissed on a fucking pope Statue and helped degenerates tear it down. I would still vote for her.

FreeState

(10,570 posts)
30. This has been pointed out several times
Sun Aug 9, 2020, 09:49 PM
Aug 2020

And the OP hasn’t addressed it. I’d assume it’s because the truth doesn’t fit their narrative.

Bettie

(16,078 posts)
19. Didn't you know?
Sat Aug 8, 2020, 07:21 PM
Aug 2020

"Support Democrats" seems to exclude AOC...I'm not entirely sure why, but a lot of people would bash her if she said the grass is green.

anamnua

(1,103 posts)
20. I am bashing her for misinformed comments on Fr. Damien.
Sat Aug 8, 2020, 07:30 PM
Aug 2020

And I have given detailed explanations why. I am a Catholic of the liberal sort -- like Joe Biden. During his lifetime Fr. Damien stood up for this marginalized and stigmatized group of outcasts. 131 years later I make no apologies for sticking up for him.

Bettie

(16,078 posts)
21. So, everyone must say certain things about certain Catholics?
Sat Aug 8, 2020, 07:36 PM
Aug 2020

The point about white men being the vast majority of statues in the capitol is a valid one.

Response to Bettie (Reply #19)

Bettie

(16,078 posts)
28. AOC is a particular target
Sun Aug 9, 2020, 07:59 PM
Aug 2020

of some really hate filled posters.

They will look for any excuse to bash her. They were very excited about her right wing opponent in the primary.

I don't exactly know why, but it has been constant from the second she won her first primary.

I find her to be a breath of fresh air. I wish we had more like her.

Hekate

(90,565 posts)
31. Don't you know? AOC is above criticism when she blunders. And this time she blundered. Perhaps...
Sun Aug 9, 2020, 10:46 PM
Aug 2020

...as a person born and raised in NYC, perhaps she confused Fr Damien with Fr Junipero Serra of California.

Both my states are very far away from her center of the universe, and both these men were priests of the Roman Catholic Church. They were born centuries apart and operated in different parts of the globe, but no matter. Serra broke apart indigenous tribes with the assistance of the Spanish Conquistadores, while Damien went to a leper colony in a kingdom already devastated, but no matter.

AOC is a rising star in the Democratic Party, and I watch her career with interest. But she is capable of error.

whttevrr

(2,345 posts)
23. Speaking as an American
Sun Aug 9, 2020, 02:01 PM
Aug 2020

As an American I say Fuck Religious tests.

Fuck Statues!

Fuck Religion!

If my representative pissed on a fucking Pope Statue and helped degenerates tear it down, I would still vote for her. I mean real fucking degenerates too. She could drag murders out of a prison to help tear the fucking statue down and I will still vote for her. My rep is not AOC but she is a woman of color and I am amazed at the level of bullshittery that these women have suffered through to become amazing humans.

I do not care if they are Catholics, Jews, Muslims, Protestants, Buddhists, Hindus, Sikhs, Satanist, or fucking Spaghetti Monster Cthulhuists. It does not matter. If there is a statue that is relegated to the dustbin of History, I do not fucking care.

This is about fucking statues. Fuck statues. I care more about the lives and well being of my fellow citizens than I do about some pigeon stained stupid fucking statue.

anamnua

(1,103 posts)
37. The oldest trick in the book.
Tue Aug 18, 2020, 08:32 PM
Aug 2020

Trying to discredit Christianity by focusing on a particularly outlandish expression of Christianity. The fact is that us Catholics were quite high up in the Klan's hate-list: number 3 after African-Americans and Jews. If they thought about Damien at all -- this is not inconceivable: their heydeys coincided -- it would have been with extreme loathing (Catholic and championing largely, but not entirely, non-Caucasians).

whttevrr

(2,345 posts)
26. Source aside
Sun Aug 9, 2020, 02:39 PM
Aug 2020

The whole thing is bullshit. AOC did not say what this post is implying. It is Religious Fuckery to the extreme.

It is being used to disparage a woman who is currently running for office in a national election

Hekate

(90,565 posts)
34. Decided to consolidate my replies here. When I was growing up in Hawai'i, every schoolchild...
Sun Aug 9, 2020, 11:36 PM
Aug 2020

...every adult, every Hawai’ian knew of the work of Fr Damien De Veuster.

Leprosy was a devastating, contagious, disfiguring, and fatal disease. It still is, if untreated. There was no treatment whatsoever for leprosy, and as it was highly contagious, especially among native Hawai’ians, the afflicted were simply taken to the remotest part of a remote island and let go into the surf. The remainder of their days was Hell on Earth, as their bodies decayed to the bone, fingers and feet fell off, noses collapsed inward, and maggots took residence.

Father Damien went to them, lived with them, gave them hope, helped build a place to live in with some measure of dignity before death. And he himself contracted this terrible disease and died of it.

AOC speaks from a place of profound ignorance if she thinks he was a “white colonist,” and nothing else. In Hawai’i there were and are many religions. No one else came. Only Damien.

Perhaps as a person born and raised in NYC, perhaps she confused Fr Damien with Fr Junipero Serra of California? Serra has been in the news lately, after all.

Both my states are very far away from her center of the universe, and both these men were priests of the Roman Catholic Church. They were born centuries apart and operated in different parts of the globe, but no matter.

Junipero Serra could rightly be called an agent of European colonialism: in his zeal to convert, he broke apart and virtually enslaved indigenous tribes with the assistance of the Spanish Conquistadores.

Father Damien, on the other hand, went to a leper colony in a kingdom where the native culture was already devastated, but no matter I guess, if you are simply trying to make an important point about race and gender.

After statehood, the sculptress Marisol Escobar was commissioned to create the statue that now resides in Statuary Hall. She chose to work from photos taken in 1889, the final year of his life, and it is no exaggeration to say the result shocked the hell out of people in both Honolulu and Washington DC. Here is no plaster saint. Here is no faux-Roman marble bust in a toga. Here is no conquering hero with a chestful of medals. Here is a man, dying for those he served.

AOC is a rising star in the Democratic Party, and I watch her career with interest. But she is capable of error. I think she tried to take back the implications of what she said, but the fury with which her defenders are attacking even the most on-point corrections is not helping her or anyone else.

For anyone who is interested in the life of this man and his place in the history of Hawai’i, I suggest “Holy Man: Father Damien of Molokai” by Gavan Daws, University of Hawaii Press, 1973. It is an entirely secular work of scholarship, for those to whom it matters.


PS for Anamnua: I am not writing as a Catholic, though my grandparents were of that faith. I write as one who cares about my home state, its history, and the truth, as best I can. Peace. See you around.
~~Hekate




anamnua

(1,103 posts)
35. Many thanks for your kind and informed comments.
Mon Aug 10, 2020, 07:11 PM
Aug 2020

It's a relief to have an ally at long last -- especially one that knows the man and the place and knows what he/she is talking about.

anamnua

(1,103 posts)
36. Here was a man
Sat Aug 15, 2020, 08:16 PM
Aug 2020

whose degree of self-sacrificing humanitarian dedication almost defies comprehension: making the ultimate sacrifice in way that was particularly long and excruciating. He was actually offered a return to Belgium for medical treatment -- but chose to stay with his people. He kept working up to two weeks before his death from leprosy.
He was fearless in his advocacy for his community – standing up to the Hawaiian government and even to the establishment in his own church.

A few clips that sum him up:



&t=1s

No self-respecting leftist/humanitarian/progressive can really argue with a record like that.
This leads to the $64,000 dollar question?
Damien, good guy or not?
And if not why not?; and do you think Messrs Obama and Ghandhi were poor judges of character?
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Speaking as a Catholic