Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

steve2470

(37,457 posts)
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 03:18 PM Sep 2021

How can you be a doctor or nurse in this country and be anti-vaccine ? I do not get it...

Background: I went to a nurse yesterday to get one of my required (for international travel) vaccines for Hepatitis A and B. During the procedure, I asked him if he encountered any anti-vaxxers.

He replied that yes, he did. Both the "hesitant-need-good-info" as well as the hard-core-over-my-dead-body (literally) anti-vaxxers. He said he had gotten some doctors and nurses who were anti-COVID-19 vaccine.

How does this happen ? Doesn't the training to be ANY kind of physician or nurse include training on the necessity and effectiveness of vaccines ? Or was this training all some nefarious Bill Gates-run conspiracy ? /sarcasm off

Thanks in advance.

Steve

29 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
How can you be a doctor or nurse in this country and be anti-vaccine ? I do not get it... (Original Post) steve2470 Sep 2021 OP
I think alot of nurses who are opposed think they, "know it all" LeftInTX Sep 2021 #1
Most people do not have any medical training at all - but harumph Sep 2021 #8
A couple of crtical care nurses on Nextdoor using technical jargon to support their anti-vax stance LeftInTX Sep 2021 #14
There is a long precedence with HIV/AIDS denial (and before)--also championed by conservatives hlthe2b Sep 2021 #2
thanks for this ! nt steve2470 Sep 2021 #4
There's a fairly large "alternative medicine" contigent in American nursing unfortunately Silent3 Sep 2021 #3
I was a nurse for 23 years and can tell you that most all nurses are pro vax. flying_wahini Sep 2021 #5
This is anecdotal of course. But, I work with 3 RNs and 1 APN mucifer Sep 2021 #6
One thing that I'd love to see some data on is that I'd bet that veterinarians stand alone in hlthe2b Sep 2021 #10
keep a list of any people you see exhibiting that thinking, it will be worth $$$ soon cadoman Sep 2021 #7
I think it's that they worship trumpism and right wing media more than science. Some are new agers mucifer Sep 2021 #9
This message was self-deleted by its author Chin music Sep 2021 #19
The Facebook effect. Dream Girl Sep 2021 #11
I think some nurses are not at all committed marybourg Sep 2021 #12
Bingo! That's very true. I left nursing for computer science in the 90s because I could not Ziggysmom Sep 2021 #15
This message was self-deleted by its author Chin music Sep 2021 #20
I forgot about that. Used to be very common. marybourg Sep 2021 #21
This message was self-deleted by its author Chin music Sep 2021 #23
I'll be going back to work soon lambchopp59 Sep 2021 #13
Just "SS" . "SSI" is a welfare program, for which I don't imagine marybourg Sep 2021 #22
I stand corrected. Turning 62 I'm just now learning about social security. Pension. LOL... lambchopp59 Sep 2021 #26
Social Security runs a very good website, where you marybourg Sep 2021 #29
I am confused by this also LetMyPeopleVote Sep 2021 #16
How can you be a nurse and see how people suffer doc03 Sep 2021 #17
Another thing I've noticed - Many nurses I've had contact with are overweight. kskiska Sep 2021 #18
Hah! - many years ago my primary doctor sent me to a cardiologist UTUSN Sep 2021 #24
And a surprising number smoke. cinematicdiversions Sep 2021 #25
Doctors are too Tree Lady Sep 2021 #27
Religion, Politics, or just plain "I don't have time to have a bad reaction" haele Sep 2021 #28

LeftInTX

(25,202 posts)
1. I think alot of nurses who are opposed think they, "know it all"
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 03:22 PM
Sep 2021

It's easy to start reading all sorts of scientific journals and come up with all sorts of conclusions. Nurses really don't have the medical training. They are not MD's. It's a case of a bit of knowledge is dangerous type thing. Maybe they are MD "wanna be" types.

I can't speak for doctors.

harumph

(1,896 posts)
8. Most people do not have any medical training at all - but
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 03:45 PM
Sep 2021

amazingly enough still believe in the science and get vaccinated. My wife is nationally certified
practices at a major hospital and also certified for air transport i.e., med flight. There are nurses and there
are "nurses." She's as dumbfounded as everyone else at nurses who don't want to be
vaccinated.

LeftInTX

(25,202 posts)
14. A couple of crtical care nurses on Nextdoor using technical jargon to support their anti-vax stance
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 04:31 PM
Sep 2021

It goes over everyone's head and that's the point...

hlthe2b

(102,192 posts)
2. There is a long precedence with HIV/AIDS denial (and before)--also championed by conservatives
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 03:25 PM
Sep 2021

Some of them are well educated yet determined to be "contrarian." Others obviously never fully understood the subjects they studied. Others were merely grifters capitalizing on the fears and ignorance of the masses... Unfortunately for those who caused immeasurable suffering with their denialist lies re: HIV as the cause of AIDS-- leading to some horrendous policies and persecution across the globe, the risk to these charlatans from contracting the disease itself was in their own hands and limited. So, they went on to do their damage throughout their careers, sans any real karmic intervention.

From the Wiki page on HIV/AIDS denial:


Several scientists have been associated with HIV/AIDS denialism, although they have not themselves studied AIDS or HIV.[9] One of the most famous and influential is Duesberg, professor of molecular and cell biology at the University of California, Berkeley, who since 1987 has disputed that the scientific evidence shows that HIV causes AIDS.[23] Other scientists associated with HIV/AIDS denialism include biochemists David Rasnick and Harvey Bialy. Biologist Lynn Margulis argued that "there's no evidence that HIV is an infectious virus" and that AIDS symptoms "overlap...completely" with those of syphilis.[71] Pathologist Étienne de Harven also expressed sympathy for HIV/AIDS denial.[72][73] AIDS researcher Seth Kalichman lists biochemist Kary Mullis "among the who's who of AIDS pseudoscientists" despite Mullis winning the 1993 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for his role in the development of the polymerase chain reaction.[74] Mullis, who did not do any HIV research, expressed skepticism about the relationship between HIV and AIDS in his 1998 autobiography.[72]: 124 

Additional notable HIV/AIDS denialists include Australian academic ethicist Hiram Caton, the late mathematician Serge Lang,[75] former college administrator Henry Bauer, journalist Celia Farber, American talk radio host and author on alternative and complementary medicine and nutrition Gary Null, and the late activist Christine Maggiore, who encouraged HIV-positive mothers to forgo anti-HIV treatment and whose 3-year-old daughter died of complications of untreated AIDS.[76] Nate Mendel, bassist with the rock band Foo Fighters, expressed support for HIV/AIDS denialist ideas and organized a benefit concert in January 2000 for Maggiore's organization Alive & Well AIDS Alternatives.[77] Organizations of HIV/AIDS denialists include the Perth Group, composed of several Australian hospital workers, and the Immunity Resource Foundation.[78]

HIV/AIDS denialism has received some support from political conservatives in the United States. Duesberg's work has been published in Policy Review, a journal once published by The Heritage Foundation but later acquired by the Hoover Institution,[79][80][81] and by Regnery Publishing. Regnery published Duesberg's Inventing the AIDS Virus in 1996,[82] and journalist Tom Bethell's The Politically Incorrect Guide to Science, in which he endorses HIV/AIDS denialism, in 2005.[83] Law professor Phillip E. Johnson has accused the Centers for Disease Control of "fraud" in relation to HIV/AIDS.[84] Describing the political aspects of the HIV/AIDS denialism movement, Sociology professor Steven Epstein wrote in Impure Science that "... the appeal of Duesberg's views to conservatives—certainly including those with little sympathy for the gay movement—cannot be denied."[85] The blog LewRockwell.com has also published articles supportive of HIV/AIDS denialism.[86]

Silent3

(15,178 posts)
3. There's a fairly large "alternative medicine" contigent in American nursing unfortunately
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 03:26 PM
Sep 2021

The same kind of thinking that makes people embrace acupuncture, reiki, crystals, unproven forms of herbalism, etc., leaves them open to anti-vax propaganda too.

flying_wahini

(6,588 posts)
5. I was a nurse for 23 years and can tell you that most all nurses are pro vax.
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 03:27 PM
Sep 2021

Most of the anti vaxers are brainwashed and that includes some dumbbells in all professions.

mucifer

(23,521 posts)
6. This is anecdotal of course. But, I work with 3 RNs and 1 APN
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 03:39 PM
Sep 2021

The APN and I are the only pro vax nurses. I am an RN. Things might not be the same now as when you were a nurse.

BTW Governor Pritzker mandated the vaccine and our company is very much pro vaccine. All of the nurses are staying . So either they got the vax or they got some sort of exemption.

Thank you Governor Pritzker!

hlthe2b

(102,192 posts)
10. One thing that I'd love to see some data on is that I'd bet that veterinarians stand alone in
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 03:54 PM
Sep 2021

having the most limited opposition to vaccinations--from both the companion animal, livestock, and human point of view. Obviously, the training for veterinarians focuses far more on "herd health," pets to the contrary, than that provided future physicians. In addition, they are the front line for identifying zoonotic diseases that can be spread to humans. There is a reason why so many veterinarians take prominent public health positions--including at CDC and state/local health departments. Their training is often far more appropriate to epidemiology, disease control, and public health.

I have never come across an anti-vaxx veterinarian though there probably may be some. But, I'd bet $$ there are less than among those other professions, including clinical human medicine--who SHOULD know better.

Medical and nursing schools desperately need to bring more immunology, epidemiology, and public health to the curriculums. The programs once did. We suffer for their diminished influence.

mucifer

(23,521 posts)
9. I think it's that they worship trumpism and right wing media more than science. Some are new agers
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 03:46 PM
Sep 2021

influenced by some new age bullcrap.

Response to mucifer (Reply #9)

 

Dream Girl

(5,111 posts)
11. The Facebook effect.
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 03:58 PM
Sep 2021

Facebooks has changed everything in many, many ways. People with less critical thinking skills are susceptible to all manner of bs that comes their way.

marybourg

(12,606 posts)
12. I think some nurses are not at all committed
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 04:16 PM
Sep 2021

to medical science, but became nurses because those were the best-paying jobs in an area without many other job choices.

Ziggysmom

(3,406 posts)
15. Bingo! That's very true. I left nursing for computer science in the 90s because I could not
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 04:36 PM
Sep 2021

tolerate stupid people. Many nurses I knew only cared about a paycheck. Some doctors, too.

Response to marybourg (Reply #12)

marybourg

(12,606 posts)
21. I forgot about that. Used to be very common.
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 05:55 PM
Sep 2021

Now half the doctors are women, and they marry each other!

( how come we don’t have any moneybags smilies?)

Response to marybourg (Reply #21)

lambchopp59

(2,809 posts)
13. I'll be going back to work soon
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 04:29 PM
Sep 2021

Imaging departments have been especially bad with anti-vaxxers, even a few mouth breathers only wearing their masks when the boss appears. There's been rifts in departments about this throughout the pandemic. I've frequently been more afraid of exposure to some Fox News following possible asymptomatic carriers than going into COVID rooms. Pandemic related stress factors in hospitals caused my blood pressure to totally peak. I took the summer off to chill.
Had it not been for the mandates coming down the pike at healthcare facilities, I'd have taken my minimal SSI retirement and prepared to eat a lot of Vienna sausage and macaroni and cheese.
It is anticipated imaging will have lots of openings soon. I'll return to travel gigs soon now far more confident, freshly booster-vaxxed that the danger from Trumpers has been minimized.
How imaging staff can deny this disease is a calamity and see what we see daily? Beats me. In 32 years of imaging I've never seen the number of patients with rapid deterioration COVID hallmark disease progression that prior to COVID even seriously immunocompromised patients with pneumonia very seldom experienced.
Anti-vaxxers DO NOT BELONG in any medical practice.

marybourg

(12,606 posts)
22. Just "SS" . "SSI" is a welfare program, for which I don't imagine
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 05:59 PM
Sep 2021

you qualify. Don’t you also have some sort of pension program?

lambchopp59

(2,809 posts)
26. I stand corrected. Turning 62 I'm just now learning about social security. Pension. LOL...
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 06:48 PM
Sep 2021

It's the gig economy, has been ever since I started my career. For those lucky few who have been working 30 plus years in the same place (unusual and becoming increasingly rare) even their own retirements got shredded, diced, sliced to the point that a nurse I know who recently retired because of the stress of the pandemic, let me know exactly what happened to the amount she expected. Let's just say "Fidelity" ended up with most of it. She's 2 years ahead of me and will be living on her SS.
Turnover rates in hospitals have become astonishingly, increasingly rap for patient care personnel. No one without nepotism related connections retains their job, and I've worked at more facilities that have more travelers and contractors than those with mostly permanent employees. Hospitals are hotbeds of drama, and it's easy to do everything exactly right in healthcare settings and still get fired, laid off, screwed or just contract ended because they've hired a "permanent"-- what a joke-- in the average of 2 months they're listing for another traveler.
Twice now I've had to cash in my retirement savings to survive the job market fluctuations between gigs. 2010 nearly totally broke me... again. Each time, the investment companies ended up with most of those savings plans. This has been the first period of unemployment of my choosing. Recovery from COVID hasn't been cheap nor done my usual energy any favors.
I've given up that sort of hope. That only exists for the well connected, the well inherited. I can only hope my health holds out long enough to collect survivable SS amount. That's in 4 years, and I'll be boondocking winters off grid in a motorhome on BLM land to do that. Hopefully someone discovers I've passed on in there before my dog runs out of corpse to consume.
I inherited nothing of value. My parents were of the Reagan-esque ilk that squandered everything, spared only off color jokes about their "gay" son.
I imagine most of the patients I've ever cared for have no idea I was doing so after sleeping quite often in my car. I have no family my age that aren't idiotic Trumpers. None of the older generation ever wrote, emailed, displayed even the slightest curiosity if I'm dead or alive. I'm either, below their university-educational strata, or of the sexual minority deserving of no consideration. I'll never know, a attempts at contacting or rekindling ties any of them have always, for 40 years, been "ghosted".
Frustrating? You bet. Although I earn an above-average income, it costs so much to maintain a living, healthcare, ridiculous rents and basic costs to keep working even without many of the luxuries my "boomer" family were accustomed to (entertainment, world travel, RV's, boats, homes) I'll never know. It took me nearly a decade just to pay off my student debt and get out of the total upside-down for vehicles until I'd earned "credit". I've spent so damn much money that went straight to enormous corporations it's sickening.
Sorry, I'm really fed up today. So fed up with living in what my older boomer relatives took lake vacations in. So worried that all my hard work earned so little to show for it. So upset that much of the future generation has it even worse.

marybourg

(12,606 posts)
29. Social Security runs a very good website, where you
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 09:44 PM
Sep 2021

can find out what you’d be entitled to at different ages.

Sorry that you had such a hard time of it.

doc03

(35,321 posts)
17. How can you be a nurse and see how people suffer
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 04:42 PM
Sep 2021

from lung cancer and still smoke? I think more of them smoke than the general public.

UTUSN

(70,671 posts)
24. Hah! - many years ago my primary doctor sent me to a cardiologist
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 06:30 PM
Sep 2021

and in our next appointment asked what the cardio had said. I said, "He said I need to lose weight, but standing next to him his nurse was 300 pounds or more."

And my doctor said, "Well, there are some things we can't control."

I might have said, "Well, that goes for ME, too!1"






 

cinematicdiversions

(1,969 posts)
25. And a surprising number smoke.
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 06:34 PM
Sep 2021

I would bet nurses probably smoke at higher rates than the general population at large.

Tree Lady

(11,443 posts)
27. Doctors are too
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 06:53 PM
Sep 2021

I find I do best with doctors that are not overweight and exercise or do activities like hiking, skiing and such.

haele

(12,645 posts)
28. Religion, Politics, or just plain "I don't have time to have a bad reaction"
Sat Sep 18, 2021, 08:56 PM
Sep 2021

Some people can't bear to think they're mortal, and getting a vaccine for Covid is a sign of weakness to them.
Some people's social affiliations mean more to them than their health or their family's health. I'm thinking that's what a lot of vaccine adverse medical personnel fall prey to.
And then, some people just don't care. They ran their own risk assessment and figured their personal risk wasn't enough to warrant taking the time to get the shot and maybe have a bad couple days if they get a reaction.

Haele

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»How can you be a doctor o...