Sat May 14, 2022, 03:47 AM
Tomconroy (6,697 posts)
Gen. Mick Ryan on how to cross a river. Or not. Brilliant thread!
|
10 replies, 1932 views
![]() |
Author | Time | Post |
![]() |
Tomconroy | May 2022 | OP |
PortTack | May 2022 | #1 | |
Tomconroy | May 2022 | #2 | |
Tomconroy | May 2022 | #3 | |
brush | May 2022 | #4 | |
modrepub | May 2022 | #6 | |
marked50 | May 2022 | #9 | |
modrepub | May 2022 | #10 | |
Irish_Dem | May 2022 | #7 | |
Layzeebeaver | May 2022 | #8 | |
pecosbob | May 2022 | #5 |
Response to Tomconroy (Original post)
Sat May 14, 2022, 03:53 AM
PortTack (29,703 posts)
1. They actually made 3 attempts! 2 pontoon bridges, both blown up. Then they tried just driving
Their tanks into the river. The tanks are now stuck in the muddy river bottom. Estimates are they lost a battalions worth of equipment and possibly 200- 1000 soliders.
|
Response to PortTack (Reply #1)
Sat May 14, 2022, 04:08 AM
Tomconroy (6,697 posts)
2. They suffered the greatest defeat of the war so far
Response to Tomconroy (Original post)
Sat May 14, 2022, 04:21 AM
Tomconroy (6,697 posts)
3. The Guardian reports:
Response to Tomconroy (Original post)
Sat May 14, 2022, 05:44 AM
brush (47,838 posts)
4. They drove tanks into the river after bridges blown up?
WTF is up with these Russians and the ridiculous decision making? Tanks don't float, are heavy as hell and tend to get stuck in mud at the bottom of rivers if anyone is stupid enought to drive one into a river.
Are Russian tank commanders dense? No wonder they're losing. |
Response to brush (Reply #4)
Sat May 14, 2022, 06:48 AM
modrepub (3,248 posts)
6. Death By Combat
or death by firing squad. I'm guessing failure to meet your objectives has really bad consequences, so why not?
Russian/Soviet military casualty figures from WW I and WW II were much higher than other countries. They have always placed a low priority on their soldier's lives. The difference today is Russia is standing alone. It has no real allies that can prop it up economically to maintain their high loss rate in soldiers (who knows if women will be conscripted; they were in combat units during WW II) and material. The longer this conflict drags on, the harder it will be for Russia to sustain. Replacement soldiers and material will become harder to produce under economic strain. Ukraine by contrast, has nearly unlimited resources on the material side if NATO continues to send them weapons and support materials. More Ukraine soldiers will be trained and move to the front as time goes by to replace personnel killed or wounded in combat. The best chance of Russian success probably evaporated in the first days of the conflict. |
Response to modrepub (Reply #6)
Sat May 14, 2022, 09:43 AM
marked50 (1,245 posts)
9. I will add that another reason The Soviets were successful in WW2
was also the Lend Lease program that the US supplied them with- aircraft, food, materials, oil, and all sorts of other equipment.
Ironic isn't it. The Russians are now facing our Lend Lease program given to their adversary- Ukraine. |
Response to marked50 (Reply #9)
Sat May 14, 2022, 10:53 AM
modrepub (3,248 posts)
10. Exactly
All wars are wars of attrition. And I'll add, there are no winners in war, only lesser degrees of losing.
The Soviets were on the winning side of WW II. For that win, it's estimated that the Soviets lost over 26 million people. That's about the current population of Australia. |
Response to brush (Reply #4)
Sat May 14, 2022, 07:20 AM
Irish_Dem (38,473 posts)
7. Apparently all the officers with knowledge and training are being killed.
So the Russian army will make more and more foolish decisions.
Those who are still alive overestimate their abilities, are overly optimistic, and lie to the politicians. |
Response to brush (Reply #4)
Sat May 14, 2022, 08:26 AM
Layzeebeaver (1,316 posts)
8. "deploy snorkles" to a tanker it likely the same as "fix bayonets" to a rifleman
You will either make it thru, or you will suffer a horrible death.
I am curious about the engagement of Russian artillery, air, and missile in this affair. Did they just send in a tank battalion on it's own, without support? If so... This seems to be to be a breakdown in command structure. |
Response to Tomconroy (Original post)
Sat May 14, 2022, 06:02 AM
pecosbob (6,985 posts)
5. "What I did to destroy Russian pantonne bridge over Siverskyi Donets"
https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1524506104192974849.html
What I did to destroy Russian pantonne bridge over Siverskyi Donets - a thread 🧵
|