Congress has let the Supreme Court run amok
MSNBC
The Supreme Court ended its term Thursday having produced a string of decisions that with casual brutality threatened Americans privacy, health and well-being. Democrats, in the face of this assault on the rights and privileges of their constituents, havent responded with the necessary anger or urgency.
The framers intended Congress to be the most powerful of the three branches of government, consisting of representatives of the people and the states. The executive was to be feared and constrained; the judiciary was, in comparison, an afterthought mostly left to future Congresses to craft. In drafting the Federalist Papers, Alexander Hamilton considered the courts the least dangerous to the political rights of the Constitution.
What weve seen this term is a court determined to prove Hamilton wrong. While Congress has the ability to curtail the authority that the unbalanced, undemocratic courts have accumulated, there seems to be almost no drive among Democrats to even challenge the third branch.
Let me clarify that I do not propose invalidating the principle of judicial review, whereby the courts have the authority to block and overturn legislative and executive actions. The Supreme Courts function as arbiter of the Constitution is an important and needed one, given the possible abuses from the other branches.
Its a power that is more easily used to strike down than to build. As Voxs Ian Milhiser has noted, while the court cant establish an agency to protect the rights of citizens, it can absolutely erase one out of existence.
But too often the role of Congress in limiting the power of the courts is reduced to the Senates advise and consent function in confirming judges and justices. That should be more properly seen as a check on the executives power to name members to the court rather than a check on the judiciary. As for checking the judiciary itself, the Constitution grants Congress wide leeway to address how the federal courts function and to respond to Supreme Court rulings.