General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsUkraine is giving the world and especially Russia a hell of a show....
https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1568319528232181761.htmlAchtung Panzer!, Kharkiv Front 🧵
This is what successful armored warfare looks like. There are many aspects to what appears to have made this operation work & I'd like to briefly go over a few of them. We'll start from the top & work our way down.
1/
The UAF have pulled off a remarkable strategic deception. By initiating, even telegraphing, an offensive in OpComSouth as their main effort they have successfully induced the Russian command to transfer a considerable number of troops south. Including some higher quality
2/
formations. This seems to have denuded the Russians opposite OpComEast of ready reserves & robust combat units in general. Furthermore the UAF was able to mass combat power in excess of what many analysts (including myself, I must admit) thought was possible.
3/
The UAF have now effectively launched two assaults in two seperate operational areas. A fixing attack at Kherson that the Russians cannot ignore, & an armored/mech deep penetration strike into the rear of Russian forces in the east. This will force Russian commanders to make
4/
hard choices with scarce reserves of combat formations capable of standing up to heavy UAF formations, many of whom are currently out of position to immediately engage thanks to the aforementioned deception in the South. Any redeployment will take time Russia doesn't have.
5/
This appears to have been a coordinated plan. Now to the tactical/operational side. UAF assault units, composed primarily of armored & mechanized formations acting in concert (quantity unknown), overran and shattered Russian front line units - reportedly composed heavily of
6/
DPR/LPR units. UAF formations then maintained the momentum of their advance, continuing deep into the Russian rear areas & preventing Russian lines from reforming & solidifying. The breach was then widened & exploited by follow on units, to a point that it appears to be
7/
destabilizing the entire front north & west of Izium. Russian units in the area of advance have not yet been able to reform coherently enough to mount an effective defense. Those areas (primarily urban) where Russian troops have held together have, correctly, been bypassed
8/
by UAF spearhead units. Pocketed &isolated, these Russians are/will likely be surrounded & compelled to surrender in short order. The UAF has placed primacy on speed & violence of action so as not to slow down their assault units & allow the Russians time to recover.
9/
Currently the Russians are scrambling to reinforce their lines. Lead UAF elements appear to be driving on Kupyansk as their primary objective - a major railway nexus supplying Russian formations. Taking it would have strategic implications for the entire eastern front.
10/
There are already reports of UAF units in or near the outskirts of the city, given the condition of Russian resistance - they are highly plausible IMO. Further information indicates UAF units are expanding their breach south, with an eastern boundary along the Oskol river.
11/
If the Russians cannot swiftly bring additional forces to bear, this could conceivably put the city of Izium into play from the north. Even if they can, this assault has effectively reordered the situation in OpComEast already.
12/
Going forward: the butchers bill for Russian forces from this operation is unlikely to be low in either man or materiel, neither of which they can afford. UAF losses are likely to be substantial, but less than would be expected given the swift collapse of RU forward units.
13/
If the UAF can keep them on their heels until their own planned halt points are reached, it will climb higher. The danger for the UAF will be overextension. They will be tempted to continue on once reaching their own pre-planned stop lines, given RU performance.
14/
This must be resisted. The UAF will need time to reorganize, refit, consolidate its lines of supply & communication, deal with rear-area holdouts, & then ready itself for a fresh offensive. Given its performance to date, I am optimistic this concern will be heeded.
15/
In the back of every good analyst's mind for 7 months has been at least one question: "What will Ukraine look like on offense?"
We're finding out. They're giving us all a hell of a show on their 1st time out.
16/16
Addition: This is almost moving faster than I can write it. There are now (thank you to those who directed me to them) reports that UAF units are hitting Izium from the south with heavy fighting within the city limits. The entire tenor of the war in the east has changed.
questionseverything
(9,651 posts)ret5hd
(20,491 posts)mopinko
(70,087 posts)blue-wave
(4,352 posts)keep the supply lines moving forward right behind the front line troops. Kick those ruscists in the ass all the way back to Moscow and beyond.
Slava Ukraini!!
GregariousGroundhog
(7,520 posts)It sounds like Ukranian is raising some hell in Kharkiv Oblast. The Russian high command must be shitting bricks right now.
There are ways to ensure that the Russian people see this. Tens of thousands of Russian families have sons who are not coming home or are coming home maimed. It should become increasingly difficult to conceal this.
Deuxcents
(16,190 posts)Their love for country, democracy, traditions n their fierce determination to keep all of Ukraine in tact. They are inspiring and will never take anything for granted again. A lesson for all democracies.
Irish_Dem
(46,946 posts)DFW
(54,358 posts)Essentially, it is the same enemy, but the Ukrainians' enemies are openly foreign. With us, Putin has cleverly given discreet backing to elements within the USA that were looking for a moral and financial nudge to get started on some evil they always wanted to do in the first place. "Moscow Mitch" McConnell bristled in anger at the nickname because it struck so close to home. Had there been nothing to it, he would have just laughed it off.
Irish_Dem
(46,946 posts)However I doubt whether Americans would fight Russian soldiers landing on their shores.
A big chunk of Americans welcome their Russian overlords.
Yes the Moscow Mitch nickname hit a nerve.
DFW
(54,358 posts)Irish_Dem
(46,946 posts)What a great find.
Mitch is not usually thin skinned, but I would guess it hurts him greatly for others to know
he is not the smartest and most powerful man in the room or world.
DFW
(54,358 posts)I wrote it, and my friends and I made it, so I knew where it was the whole time
Irish_Dem
(46,946 posts)This was a very good video.
DFW
(54,358 posts)I write the lyrics, arrange some of the music, do some of the screenplays, etc. I usually do it in partnership with another gifted musician/videographer whose operation is called the Parody Project (mine is called The Freedom Toast).
Here are a couple of my recent ones:
Vote no (Calypso)
No business like NO business (les républicains votent toujours NON)
Miss Me ("Misty" clima)
Putin told the Russian nation
My Pillow
Ghost Donald in the Sky
Battle of Lake Travis
Mark Meadows (assistant pour Trump)
King of Corona
&t=56s
Trump: Slip Sliding Away
&t=181s
Enjoy the show!
Irish_Dem
(46,946 posts)I had no idea you were so talented writing and producing high quality political videos.
Who did the lyrics and vocals for Miss Me?
DFW
(54,358 posts)Vocals were done by Deborah Bowman, who does most of our female lead vocals. Rubio and Respect for Hillary were done by Chanda Leigh.
Irish_Dem
(46,946 posts)At first I thought they were well known singers and you had somehow adapted the words.
But realized that could not be the case. The lyrics and vocalists were originals.
Have you tried to sell the videos? Perhaps send some to Lincoln Project, etc.?
DFW
(54,358 posts)We have the studio do the legal advisories, but they are protected as parodies. I have never tried to sell any of them. I even offered to do stuff for Democratic campaigns for free, but none of them dared take me up on them. It seems that my lyrics are too biting for them to dare using them (good! that means I wasn't being too mild). Not even the environmental movements dared use something like "Miss Me." I do it for the fun, not for money, so I don't care. Who would pay to see me put on a show of this stuff, anyway?
My brother occasionally takes a stab at writing lyrics, too. A couple of times, his efforts were so good, that after tweaking them a bit, I had the gang in Atlanta record them and got videos made of them.
These are his two:
&t=27s
I have done a few about other Republicans than Moscow Mitch:
&t=68s
&t=83s
The very versatile Deb Bowman sang all the women's parts in the above except Rubio. It's hard to believe the same woman sang them all. She's really talented. Chanda Leigh sang Rubio. She also did "Respect for Hillary," which I did right after the 2016 election. For some reason, that one never caught on You can see Chanda hiding in the middle of the three "backup" singers at the lower left:
I'm really proud of our music team and our vocal talent. Whenever I think something up, even if they aren't familiar with the tune I want to use, they figure it out, and are good enough musicians to do a sound track that is close enough to the original to make the parody effective. Since Atlanta is not exactly around the corner from me, I don't often have a chance to be on the videos, but sometimes, though the miracles of the internet, and studio technology, I do sneak in on occasion, such as this one:
&t=200s
Irish_Dem
(46,946 posts)They like to bite the GOP.
Do you post your work here periodically?
DFW
(54,358 posts)But the posts get buried quickly among all the other new ones. They seem to get accorded no more relevance than the dozens of "Bernie said" posts, and maybe that's all they deserve. Vox populi and all that.
Here was our latest one, in case you missed it:
This was one I did on Roger Stone, sung again by our vocal chameleon, Deb Bowman, this time brilliantly imitating an Irish folk singer:
Irish_Dem
(46,946 posts)Make sure to indicate a DUer made the video when you post it.
DFW
(54,358 posts)Once, I wrote my own piece from start to finish, harmonica and all, after a particularly insulting day at some airport with the TSA, so I did the Talking TSA Blues. A friend did the cartoon animation. One of the women in my Dallas office has a brother who is with the TSA at one of the other Texas airports. She sent it to him, and said they laughed their asses off at it. I was actually in the studio in Atlanta when this was recorded, so I got to do the guitar tracks and the vocal, but that rarely happens.
Irish_Dem
(46,946 posts)I think it would be interesting to see if get more views here if you indicate video created by a DUer....
Other DUers have single theme projects and threads with their work and hobbies....
and they are popular.
PortTack
(32,757 posts)Want to help?
Ukraine24.org has raised well over 3 million since their inception about 4 moths ago.