Tue Feb 7, 2023, 09:36 PM
kimbutgar (19,647 posts)
Today I read to a second grade class about a black boy who experienced being at a bus terminal
In the south that had a whites only and colored only water fountains. The black boy drank the water out of the colored fountain and it tasted terrible. The white boy next to him drank out of the whites only fountain. He started fantasying that the whites fountain water was better tasting. He tricked his grandmother and took the bus a few days later to try to drink from that white fountain. He finally drank from the white fountain and the water was also terrible tasting. At the end he noticed the pipes were connected and the water was the same. As I was reading this I thought The right wingers heads would explode hearing this story and ban the book. More than half the class were white students, 1 Black child, 1 Hispanic and the rest Asian. They really enjoyed the story and I didn’t think any of them felt guilty. They were not upset but curious why they had two water fountains. We had a nice discussion. Then I read them a book about Harriet Tubman and the Underground Railroad. I took great delight that I educated my students about our country’s history and none of the white children were upset or ashamed but enlightened instead.
That is why the right wing hates discussing history like slavery and segregation. They are the ones feeling guilt not those of us who know that those who don’t know history are doomed to repeat the past.
|
7 replies, 1628 views
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
![]() |
Author | Time | Post |
![]() |
kimbutgar | Feb 2023 | OP |
Timeflyer | Feb 2023 | #1 | |
Joinfortmill | Feb 2023 | #2 | |
DemUnleashed | Feb 2023 | #3 | |
soldierant | Feb 2023 | #4 | |
Marcuse | Feb 2023 | #5 | |
uponit7771 | Feb 2023 | #6 | |
Maraya1969 | Feb 2023 | #7 |
Response to kimbutgar (Original post)
Tue Feb 7, 2023, 10:21 PM
Timeflyer (1,627 posts)
1. Teaching true history, kudos. (Be glad you're not in Florida.)
Response to kimbutgar (Original post)
Tue Feb 7, 2023, 10:56 PM
Joinfortmill (12,940 posts)
2. Awesome.
Response to kimbutgar (Original post)
Tue Feb 7, 2023, 11:04 PM
DemUnleashed (633 posts)
3. I...
I don't think it's ever been about guilt. They can't say the quiet part out loud so they had to come up with some excuse as to why they want to ban these books. Someone probably said "I know, I know...we can say we want these books banned because white children will feel guilty and ashamed. Yes, let's go with that!"
The quiet part that they can't say out loud is that white children will get influenced by these books and will probably be kind to and feel sympathy towards the black children (we can't have that now, can we?) and they know that these white kids will probably grow up to be Democrats and probably grow up to vote for Democrats if they become "indoctrinated" with reading these books! |
Response to DemUnleashed (Reply #3)
Wed Feb 8, 2023, 12:01 AM
soldierant (5,960 posts)
4. Would that their suspicions were correct
and probably some kids would be reached. But it's amazing how much ignorance even an eucated white person can retain, especially if their families remain ignorant.
|
Response to kimbutgar (Original post)
Wed Feb 8, 2023, 12:08 AM
Marcuse (7,183 posts)
5. Accurate history is essential because:
![]() |
Response to kimbutgar (Original post)
Wed Feb 8, 2023, 12:17 AM
uponit7771 (89,633 posts)
6. K&R, MAGA sympathize with oppressors and that's what they're guilty about
Response to kimbutgar (Original post)
Wed Feb 8, 2023, 02:31 AM
Maraya1969 (21,616 posts)
7. I think they don't want everyone finding out how horrible their relatives were.
My family has not been in this country long enough for me to have descended from slave owners and I am glad about that. I'm also sure if you go back far enough to any family you will find horrors. But you have to decide you are going to be better people than the ones who came before you. Lying about what happened doesn't cure anything.
|