Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

JackRiddler

(24,979 posts)
Tue Aug 6, 2013, 07:25 PM Aug 2013

Did Clapper commit perjury? Yes. Is the "chatter" real? Maybe.

Last edited Wed Aug 7, 2013, 07:12 AM - Edit history (2)

Clapper lied to the Senate and he's even admitted it, but no move will be ever made to hold him accountable.

Is the NSA lying when they still claim they aren't collecting phone calls of millions of Americans? Yes! They've redefined the language so that even though they are doing this, it's only counts as "collecting" once they use a secret-court blanket warrant to conduct official searches within the collected material. (And it's not even a "search" long as it's just analysts having a casual look-see with XKeyscore; maybe sharing the info informally with their private clients or spook networks on the side.) But of course they have collected this data to store it in the first place. If language still has any meaning, that is.

Is the NSA in a crisis of sorts, the greatest in its history, as a result of revelations of its constitutional violations? Certainly. It's so serious that a vote to defund NSA mass surveillance programs fell short in the House by just 7 votes. Sadly, this crisis is highly unlikely to be fatal to the spook agency that is about to activate the world's largest data storage facility in Utah.

So, what does the above establish?

The NSA lies. Intelligence agencies lie (and see this as their duty, the fuckers). They are engaged in criminal activity that is being exposed. (They have engaged in far greater crimes in the various imperialist wars of the last seven decades, of course.) They have ambitions to expand this total surveillance industry encompassing all forms of data produced int the world, make it even more comprehensive, deeper, omnipresent and, of course, profitable to the real beneficiaries, the private corporate contractors.

At the moment, they have a lot of incentive to lie! They have motive to create distractions from the ongoing revelations.

Now. Will politicians in Congress and White House nod "yes" like bobble-heads to any bullshit about "chatter" that currently comes out of the NSA and its cousin agencies? Absolutely.

This was always true, and it's worse than ever after 13 years of terror-war fearmongering and after, most recently, the total hysteria over "Benghazi." In some sense, they have no choice -- not if they don't have the courage to call bullshit on the entire terror-intel-homeland-military-industrial complex that's been paying their bills and getting their votes all these years.

Does the NSA's "chatter" about potential terror attacks come at a very convenient time? Sure, just like all those times earlier this century, back when Democrats were often ready to claim the Bush regime's terror warnings were only issued whenever Bush's approval ratings were falling:


Note: There was a time when this chart was posted on DU about once a week. Very few DUers decried it as "conspiracy theory."

Does this mean the chatter is bullshit this time? Possibly.

Of course it's also possible real people in Yemen et al. have a strong motive to blow up Americans, whether or not this is the right thing to do, or wise of them. It is neither, but of course a deniable and illegal global war has been waged on their people by the USG for many years. As was already the case back in 2001. These policies effectively recruit for "the enemy" and invite violent and criminal retaliation in the form of what the USG then terms "terrorism."

And of course, thousands of men were just broken out of various Middle Eastern prisons. Some of them might be genuinely criminal minded, or looking for revenge on their former captors. It's not implausible.

Over in Guantanamo, your USG is still torturing dozens of prisoners every day with force-feedings. Same USG has acknowledged half those men were never guilty of anything, yet they are still held and held and held for years, tortured in the hell-prison. The world remains acutely aware of this crime against humanity, even if Americans generally manage to ignore, deny and trivialize it. It's a constant source of anger for many people in the Arab and Muslim worlds.

There's always "chatter" of course. Let's say the NSA or other agencies are picking and choosing "chatter" to exaggerate, so as to create a distraction from the ongoing exposure of the routine and massive unconstitutional surveillance and other criminal behavior at NSA, DEA, CIA, FBI, ETC. Does that require a "conspiracy" between, say, Obama and Graham?

Hell no. Those are the civilian bobbleheads. They're way too high up to ever possibly follow all the details and know what's the substance of the chatter. They may not all be equally smart, but they tend to have a good sense of things they are safer not knowing. And as public figures they're way too vulnerable not to kowtow to the "national security" "expert" class.

Again, that's if they don't have the courage to call bullshit on the entire terror-intel-homeland-military-industrial complex that's for all these years has been frightening and bullying Americans and making threats to the world, paying the bills for agencies and contractors, and funding politician campaigns and lobbyists and media ad buys and think-tankers and other shills to corral the votes.

Which, of course, they do not even conceive of doing.

23 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Did Clapper commit perjury? Yes. Is the "chatter" real? Maybe. (Original Post) JackRiddler Aug 2013 OP
K&R MotherPetrie Aug 2013 #1
Wasn't it Jon Steward who pointed out his "tell" GiaGiovanni Aug 2013 #2
His tell, as with all intel chiefs... JackRiddler Aug 2013 #3
It was John Oliver sitting in for Jon Stewart. backscatter712 Aug 2013 #12
So it was! GiaGiovanni Aug 2013 #21
Damn straight! Right to the rotten core of the whole thing! scarletwoman Aug 2013 #4
K&R woo me with science Aug 2013 #5
why didnt the nsa stop this? questionseverything Aug 2013 #6
Right, that's an interesting point... JackRiddler Aug 2013 #10
+1 nashville_brook Aug 2013 #11
Tangent, but it totally blows my mind that the idiot ever had such a high approval rating. nt RedCappedBandit Aug 2013 #7
It's possible... the NSA revelations will be the last straw that starts to bring a change as more KoKo Aug 2013 #8
clearly the timing and "substance" of this new alert is VERY suspect,.. Civilization2 Aug 2013 #9
Then again, you never know, right? JackRiddler Aug 2013 #13
It all sounds so wrong when you say it like that,. . Civilization2 Aug 2013 #17
*kick* This is a good thread. (nt) scarletwoman Aug 2013 #14
*thank you* JackRiddler Aug 2013 #15
"Double Taps" (drones killing those seeking to rescue/help those just attacked by drones) Fire Walk With Me Aug 2013 #16
It's on the way to an exterminationist ideology. JackRiddler Aug 2013 #18
TOM TOMORROW: "The NSA Comes Clean" JackRiddler Aug 2013 #19
Ted Rall's latest on surveillance state... JackRiddler Aug 2013 #20
And now the latest on the extent of domestic surveillance... JackRiddler Aug 2013 #22
Yeah that really was a fuck up for Congress, one of their own going off script. Rex Aug 2013 #23
 

JackRiddler

(24,979 posts)
3. His tell, as with all intel chiefs...
Tue Aug 6, 2013, 08:35 PM
Aug 2013

is that his lips are moving.

As they understand it, as they are indoctrinated, it is their sacred duty to lie.

backscatter712

(26,355 posts)
12. It was John Oliver sitting in for Jon Stewart.
Wed Aug 7, 2013, 12:01 AM
Aug 2013

But yes, he pointed out Clapper's tell and said he should never play poker.

scarletwoman

(31,893 posts)
4. Damn straight! Right to the rotten core of the whole thing!
Tue Aug 6, 2013, 08:37 PM
Aug 2013
Not if they don't have the courage to call bullshit on the entire terror-intel-homeland-military-industrial complex that's been frightening and bullying Americans, paying the bills for politicians and lobbyists and contractors and agencies, and corralling the votes all these years. Which, of course, they do not even conceive of doing.


Exactly! They do not even conceive of calling bullshit on this whole misbegotten enterprise! We, the citizens, are being held hostage, and there's no negotiating team working for our release.

sw

questionseverything

(9,631 posts)
6. why didnt the nsa stop this?
Tue Aug 6, 2013, 09:54 PM
Aug 2013

, thousands of men were just broken out of various Middle Eastern prisons. Some of them might be genuinely criminal minded, or looking for revenge.

//////////////////

i mean that would be a legit use

 

JackRiddler

(24,979 posts)
10. Right, that's an interesting point...
Tue Aug 6, 2013, 10:58 PM
Aug 2013

These must have been awfully big operations with a lot of planning beforehand. This supposedly comprehensive intel system that stopped 54 or 154 or 2,054 terror plots (or 1 sort-of, as per the most recent admission) had no idea the breakouts were going to happen... but they know about Al Qaeda's new magic liquid that turns into undetectable explosive when dry.

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
8. It's possible... the NSA revelations will be the last straw that starts to bring a change as more
Tue Aug 6, 2013, 10:01 PM
Aug 2013

It's possible...

the NSA revelations will be the last straw that starts to bring a change as more Americans wake up to what is being done "in their name..to themselves" with their own tax money.

They seem so "unhinged" about NSA and other Spying being revealed that they had to resort to doing a Dick Cheney/Tom Ridge Alert. So desperate that "dusting off" the code word "chatter" seems to show panic. Aren't they aware that informed Americans realize that these days sophisticated terrorists (of the ability to do "massive attacks" like they are warning us of) aren't likely to be holding high level planning sessions on SKYPE, Facebook, Twitter or with any kind of Cellphone that they know can be monitored. Even the unsophisticated ones know that we are monitoring everything and have found other ways of managing. The Administration has had to deal with recent prison breaks in Yemen and elsewhere (that have been downplayed in MSM)...How come their "chatter" didn't warn them about those actions coming...or even going back to Benghazi?

I think they went too far with this one.

 

Civilization2

(649 posts)
9. clearly the timing and "substance" of this new alert is VERY suspect,..
Tue Aug 6, 2013, 10:20 PM
Aug 2013

Money is the motive, as usual,. there is massive cash flow to big Intel!
Cover for the leaks and current focus on the rampant spying will eventually uncover the MONEY trail,... They do not want that!


 

JackRiddler

(24,979 posts)
13. Then again, you never know, right?
Wed Aug 7, 2013, 06:23 AM
Aug 2013

Because there's nothing very implausible about the idea that random Arabs or Muslims might want to indiscriminately (and wrongly!) murder Americans, given the USG's high-profile international policy of global war, universal jurisdiction, remote-control assassination on executive whim, arbitrary targeting, killing civilians, arming the same "bad guys" who are later called enemies, supporting the absolute worst regimes in the world (starting with the Oil Kingdoms), backing Israeli occupation, maintaining the world's best known site for sadistic torture of randomly arrested brown men, etc. etc.

They've worked so hard to make real enemies!

 

Civilization2

(649 posts)
17. It all sounds so wrong when you say it like that,. .
Wed Aug 7, 2013, 07:46 AM
Aug 2013

Yeah sure the warmongers have pushed so very hard, however the 'chatter' is likely always there due to all you list, so the embassy closures does seem timed for effect more than anything. If the 1% want an attack to further their program of wealth extraction they will just pull one anyway,. now that they have so many to blame it on. It just goes on and on, as long as we keep feeding them.

 

Fire Walk With Me

(38,893 posts)
16. "Double Taps" (drones killing those seeking to rescue/help those just attacked by drones)
Wed Aug 7, 2013, 07:18 AM
Aug 2013

appears to be a move to purposely infuriate people into hating America, perhaps enough to do something about it. Considering the lies and the size of the annual budgets for the military industrial complex and the surveillance state, I wouldn't put it past those in charge to seek to create new terrorists to justify their pig's trough budgets. Cynical but just look around.

 

Rex

(65,616 posts)
23. Yeah that really was a fuck up for Congress, one of their own going off script.
Fri Aug 9, 2013, 03:12 PM
Aug 2013

Making that poor general lie under oath...because we all know how worthless the U.S. Constitution has become for the average politician. Reagan set the standard for crapping on the Constitution.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Did Clapper commit perjur...