General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWhy Wars Always End Up Hurting the Most Vulnerable Americans
by PETER BEINART
The impending anniversary of the start of World War I has given historians and pundits the chance to speculate about whether were heading for another era of mass war and redrawing of borders. Put me down as undecided. But as we prepare to dwell on the ghastliness that occurred overseas between 1914 and 1918, its worth pausing to reflect on the ghastliness that occurred over here.
On June 30, 1918, perennial Socialist presidential candidate Eugene Debs was sentenced to 10 years in jail for opposing the draft. (In 1920, he won nearly a million votes while in prison; he was freed in 1921.) During the war, Cincinnati outlawed the sale of pretzels; Iowa made publicly speaking German a crime. On August 1, 1917 in Butte, Montana, a mob seized Frank Little, who was trying to unionize copper miners for the anti-war Industrial Workers of the World (IWW). In Over Here, his wonderful book about Americas wartime home front, the historian David Kennedy recounts what happened next. Pummeled into the street, Little was tied to the rear of an automobile and dragged through the streets until his kneecaps were scraped off, then hanged from the side of a railroad trestle. While calling the lynching was regrettable, the New York Times insisted that, the IWW agitators are in effect, and perhaps in fact, agents of Germany.
Most Americans have forgotten how repressive a period World War I was. You cant even collect your thoughts without getting arrested for unlawful assemblage, quipped the writer Max Eastman. They give you ninety days for quoting the Declaration of Independence, six months for quoting the Bible. Walter Lippmann said Woodrow Wilsons administration had done more to endanger fundamental American liberties than any group of men for a hundred years.
Which makes it all the more remarkable that Lippmann had championed Americas entrance into the war on the grounds that it would further liberal ideals. While fighting for democracy in Europe, he declared, we shall stand committed as never before to the realization of democracy in America ... we shall turn with fresh interest to our own tyranniesto our Colorado mines, our autocratic steel industries, our sweatshops and our slums. The progressive philosopher John Dewey thought the war would unleash a new spirit of public-mindedness in the United States and a more conscious and extensive use of science for communal purposes.
more
http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/07/why-wars-always-enables-abuses-on-the-home-front/373916/
onehandle
(51,122 posts)Emperor Onehandle would make it so.
pinboy3niner
(53,339 posts)Any draft must have medical exemptions, and the elite can always find doctors who can be bought to ascribe disqualifying afflictions for the sons ( and perhaps soon, the daughters) of the privileged.
Don't kid yourself. A draft never applies to the upper class, no matter how "fair" you try to make it.
Brigid
(17,621 posts)Needs to see it. And I think Mr. Beinart is right: The parallels between now and just before the outbreak of WWI are scary.