General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsRiddle Me This: What Happens When a Civilian Kills a Cop in Self Defense?
What Happens When a Civilian Kills a Cop in Self Defense?By Alex Henderson * AlterNet * January 21, 2015
A man is staring down death row after killing a police officer during a no-knock SWAT raid.
The careless use of SWAT teams in no-knock drug raids -- when heavily armed police burst into a home without warning -- has resulted in a long list of innocent people being killed or seriously injured in the United States. 2014 alone found SWAT teams in Georgia senselessly killing businessman David Hooks and maiming toddler Bounkham Baby Boo Boo Phonesavanh. And when those raids victimize people who arent even selling drugs, narcotics officers seldom face criminal charges and are given every benefit of the doubt. But if, on the other hand, Americans shoot narcotics officers during militarized drug raidsperhaps believing that they are being robbed and are acting in self-defensecharges of first-degree murder are likely. The case of Marvin Louis Guy in Texas is a glaring example.
Guy, an African-American man who is now 50, was the target of a no-knock drug raid on May 9, 2014. Narcotics officers, operating on a tip from an informant who claimed that Guy was selling bags of cocaine, carried out a SWAT raid on his home in Killeen, Texas at around 5:30 AMand Guy grabbed his gun and opened fire. Charles Dinwiddie, one of the officers, was hit and died two days later. Guy was charged with capital murder, and prosecutors are seeking the death penalty despite his assertions that he thought he was acting in self-defense. Guys trial is scheduled for June of this year.
No drugs were found during a search of Guys home, only a glass pipe and a grinderwhich indicates that Guy was, at worst, a recreational drug user and not a drug dealer. Journalist Radley Balko, author of the 2013 book Rise of the Warrior Cop: The Militarization of America's Police Forces, has commented on the case in the Washington Post, saying: The fact that the police didnt find any drugs in the house suggests that Marvin Louis Guy didnt know he was shooting at cops. Drug dealer or no, unless he had a death wish, its unlikely that a guy would knowingly fire at police officers when he had nothing in the house that was particularly incriminating.
http://www.alternet.org/news-amp-politics/what-happens-when-civilian-kills-cop-self-defense
2naSalit
(86,572 posts)the white guy who shot the black police officer under similar circumstances is walking free without charge.... although he didn't kill the cop, he would have if the cop wasn't wearing body armor.
Whiskeytide
(4,461 posts)... for a similar notion as the "intersection of open carry and stand your ground". If I am openly carrying, and I reasonably feel threatened by a cop, why could I not defend my shooting of the cop with a stand your ground defense? Some of the "SYG" statutes have exceptions regarding LEOs, but conceptually I can't think of a good reason why.
99th_Monkey
(19,326 posts)Last edited Fri Jan 23, 2015, 12:02 AM - Edit history (1)
that cops are the new Gestapo waiting for their new Fuhrer,
and as such are completely "above the law" i.e. NOT accountable
for their crimes, unless they happen to be black.
Meanwhile the KKKoch Bros. et. al. have already bought nearly every
politician in DC and many state governments.
The 1% has a "plan", like Hitler had a "final solution".
Meaning We the People are fucked, pretty much.