General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsSuch handwringing over not much, really, in Chicago
Can someone please let me know the body count over what doesn't even rise to the level of a riot?
Heavens to Betsy, you'd think someone won the Stanley Cup.
Was there anything more substantial than some fistfghts?
This is what happens after a hockey game:
This is what happens during a soccer match:
This is what happens after a jury verdict:
Crowds can get into emotional frenzies over all sorts of things. We regularly have sporting events in which the object of the sport is to beat one's opponent into unconsciousness, while the crowd cheers on their favorite contestant. Does that sort of mass event - in which violence is the POINT - inspire a lot of handwringing over whether the promoters are encouraging violence? We have football and baseball games in which fatal conflicts occur with regularity. I must have missed the hours of news coverage focusing on which team's coach is responsible for those sorts of things.
It's no wonder that Americans are so ignorant of world events. A lot of significant things happened today on this planet, but the one and only thing our news media covered all freaking evening long was, as far as I could tell, some shouting and punching at a mass gathering.
Other than some fistfights, can someone help me understand the earth-shattering monumental significance of an unruly crowd at a cancelled political rally, because I'm just not getting it.
JFKDem62
(383 posts)Kip Humphrey
(4,753 posts)Xipe Totec
(43,890 posts)haikugal
(6,476 posts)I don't watch MSM so I haven't been forced to focus on it.
You ask a good question.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)The April 3, 1989 Grateful Dead concert at the Pittsburgh Civic Arena was a fuckload more "tense". A crowd of ticketless jackasses organized in the parking lot and stormed their way in, resulting in a bunch of injuries and property damage.
That was "tense", but still not much of a big deal really. Although the local news reporters were duly lined up on the sidewalks nearby going on about the violent drug-crazed Deadheads having invaded their town.
i have GOT to get me a fainting couch concession somewhere.
haikugal
(6,476 posts)Fainting couches aren't required and I hope we don't have to relive history either.
LittleBlue
(10,362 posts)This is going to be played up big time.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)LittleBlue
(10,362 posts)That looked like Greece during the economic calamity. Most importantly, the racial aspect was really bad for the country.
The previous stuff I thought was a one-off. Now it's becoming the norm and it's more than just a few people.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)The Greece austerity protests looked nothing like this.
The news keeps playing the same loop of about six or seven cuts.
Seriously - how many people have you seen in that looped video actually injured in any way?
brush
(53,764 posts)between Trump's fans who have been goaded to violence by him at other events (several injuries and 31 arrests earlier today in St Louis at a Trump event for instance) and anti-fascist demonstrators in Chicago determined to voice their opposition to that kind of demagogic behavior in their city and you make light of it.
What's up with that?
My hat is off to the Chicago demonstrators.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)Maddow looked like Cronkite at the Kennedy assassination with her somber intonation of how there's never been "violence at a political rally in my lifetime, and I'm old".
In my lifetime, two presidential candidates were SHOT at political rallies, and one of them was killed.
Maddow thinking she's "old" is a hoot.
OMG a rally was canceled and some people punched some other people.
The "disco sucks" rally at Comiskey Park was more consequential.
And if you are too young to remember that, please look it up.
hfojvt
(37,573 posts)She's ancient.
It's been a long, long time since Wallace was shot.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)But I happen to have been around for that.
brush
(53,764 posts)You seem to not understand that there has been unprovoked violence at several other Trump events toward African Americans and the two outbreaks today at St. Louis and Chicago show the scope of the violence at Trump's events is growing, not to mention that it is being encouraged by a presidential candidate.
Do you actually think that it's to be laughed off because no one has been killed yet, that it's not up to what used to happen in your day?
Why don't you just say "get off my lawn", or, "in my day I walked ten miles to school and back in the snow"?
That you don't seem to grasp the demagogic nature of Trump's campaign and it's potential to harm our country is somewhat startling to be coming from someone on a progressive board.
Person 2713
(3,263 posts)now Trump wins for sure and this looks so bad for democrats
Glad all the drama queens and shivering kitties stay where they are
Btw I have been very misunderstood tonight so I will add people were happy about the size of the crowd and the rally being shut down here
Not about the scuffles INSIDE that all took place after they announced Trump isn't coming
Doesn't anyone think that the Trump crowd was angry about coming all the way into the city and waiting for hours and that they were hot headed?
Even the DJs on the radio ride home were talking about the amazing power of it all ( between songs)not "the horror of it all"
There will be more scuffles at various locations after the St Pats parades than went down today if my past experience is any good marker.
hfojvt
(37,573 posts)What would the story be if Bill Clinton's visit to Springfield was shut down because of a large crowd? Would we be talking about the amazing power of it all?
I protested a couple of Bush's visits to Kansas (or one was probably in Missouri) and I was hoping for large crowds, but not to shut down the event.
Person 2713
(3,263 posts)A spokesman for the Chicago Police Department says the agency never recommended that Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump cancel his campaign rally in the city.
CPD spokesman Anthony Guglielmi tells The Associated Press that the department never told the Trump campaign there was a security threat at the University of Illinois at Chicago venue. He said the department had sufficient manpower on the scene to handle any situation.
Guglielmi says the university's police department also did not recommend that Trump call off the event. He says the decision was made "independently" by the campaign.
21st Century Poet
(254 posts)I was going to write a post about how the protest could backfire but I figured I'd be shut down myself for daring to say so. People on here, especially Sanders supporters, were elated last night.
The problems I see are that:
1) Ideally, political rallies should never be shut down, even those of morons like Donald Trump. Even idiots should be allowed to air their views.
2) If a Clinton or Sanders rally were shut down by Republican protesters, everybody would be going on about how uncivil, uneducated and rude Republicans are. Guess what Republicans are saying now about Democrats?
3) The protest makes Sanders's 'revolution' (a problematic term) seem a bit more sinister than it actually is, which puts his excellent policies in a bad light, especially coming in the same week when he seemed to flounder a bit while discussing Cuba's revolution. If centre-left folks were considering switching to Sanders, I'm not sure that last night persuaded them to do so. Keep in mind that people outside Democratic Underground tend to be far less 'radical' and 'progressive'.
4) Protesting is great and it is a sacrosanct right but there is a thin line between airing one's views and disrupting others from doing so. When I see people jumping onto a stage and grabbing someone else's microphone to speak (this, bizarrely, happened during a Sanders rally once as well as last night) and people ripping each other's (political) placards up, I get the uneasy feeling that that line has been breached.
5) Worst of all, last night might actually help Trump in the polls. Once again, he managed to dominate the news cycle on all television networks. How does this help Democrats exactly?
I'm sure that many people here will disagree with my opinion but if one looks outside the Democratic Underground bubble, one might find that there is more truth to it than one would wish.
joshcryer
(62,269 posts)No big. I just hope they wear hilarious uniforms and give each other salutes.
WiffenPoof
(2,404 posts)No one is saying that this is a huge riot. The fear is that it represents a precursor to even more violence. This phenomenon is growing... We are only witnessing the beginning.
How you could marginalize this event is baffling to me.
P
eShirl
(18,490 posts)DCBob
(24,689 posts)This incident confirmed what many Republicans have been fearing about Trump. I think this will affect the Tues vote and might be enough to stop Trump from clinching the nomination and cause a contested convention... then who knows what will happen.
ladjf
(17,320 posts)did not.
Bluenorthwest
(45,319 posts)Not exactly 'what happens after a verdict' in that it was what happened after a verdict. Once. With extraordinary motivation.
Also Russia and Canada being presented as 'how the US is'.
I can't believe you are content to see what Trump is doing, it is horrifying.
Bluenorthwest
(45,319 posts)presented by our esteemed OP as 'what happens after hockey games'...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Vancouver_Stanley_Cup_riot
logosoco
(3,208 posts)evidence that the 99% are fighting each other. This pleases the 1% greatly, because it means more time that they are not rising up against them.
HereSince1628
(36,063 posts)As these things go, it seems unlikely to be the last confrontation over Trump's Know-Nothing approach.
And it's likely that the rationale of 'getting even' for this will create a cycle of escalation.
This may have been much adieu over pushing and shoving, but Brunhilde has yet to sing.
CanonRay
(14,101 posts)however; 1) we haven't seen this kind of thing in decades and 2) it is just starting and 3) Nobody knows where this is headed. I know I don't want to be in Cleveland this summer.