General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsTIME on Black Lives Matter: "Save the Whales" doesn't mean "Screw the Eagles"
The choice isn't binary.
http://time.com/4400811/all-lives-matter/?xid=homepage
Lets stipulate first that it would be hard to imagine a movement with a more heart-breakingly modest purpose than one making the case that the lives of the people its trying to look after arent better or more worthy than anyone elses, but merely that they count.
That, however, hasnt stopped the critics from pouncing. The go-to criticismand were looking at you Rudy Giuliani, though youve had plenty of companyis the disingenuous question: Hey! What about other lives? On CBSs Face the Nation, Giuliani went through the usual riff: Black lives matter. White lives matter. Asian lives matter. Hispanic lives matter, the idea being that all lives matter just the same, and that there must be something terribly elitist and wrong with you if you care only about black ones.
But nobody said those other lives dont matter; no one even said that black lives matter a tiny bit more. Pretending that the choice is binaryand then acting as if its the other side that framed it that wayis a handy dodge but a dishonest one. If I say Save the whales, it does not mean, Screw the eagles.
SNIP
Unfortunately, we live in a binary world. That needs to change.
IcyPeas
(21,842 posts)Rex
(65,616 posts)Also, the white live matter movement has been a strawman since day one. People that keep repeating it make me go HMMM...
napkinz
(17,199 posts)zz-la
(224 posts)only goes to strengthen the movements position that Black Lives don't matter. So many white people are suddenly thrown into a tizzy at the mere mention of idea that Black Lives Matter, especially when there is a long enduring history of just the opposite in this country.