General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsSlandering Populism article from Counterpunch
Trump was exposed long ago as anything but a Populist but our lazy media stays on message.
http://www.counterpunch.org/2017/04/28/slandering-populism-a-chilling-media-habit/
I imagine Im not the only political and media observer sickened by the dominant (mainstream) corporate medias habitual reference to xenophobic, right-wing, white-nationalist, and neo-fascist politicians like Donald Trump, Geert Wilders, Nigel Farage, and Marine Le Pen as populists. Populism properly understood is about popular and democratic opposition to the rule of the money power to the reign of concentrated wealth. It emerged from radical farmers fight for social and economic justice and democracy against the plutocracy of the nations Robber Baron capitalists during the late 19th century. It was a movement of the left. As the left author and journalist Harvey Wasserman notes:
The Morgans, Rockefellers and their ilk had captured the industrial revolution that dominated the U.S. after the Civil War. The farmers of the South and West fought back with a grass-roots social movement
They formed the Peoples Party. Its socialistic platforms demanded public ownership of the major financial institutions, including banks, railways, power utilities and other private monopolies that were crushing the public well-being.
..........
Contemporary populists worthy of the label are leftists. They back human rights, social democracy, peace and ecological sanity (Wasserman). They support racial and ethnic equality and unity in the interest of working class solidarity and struggle from the bottom up. They want government to serve the broad working class majority of the populace and the common good, not the wealthy corporate and financial Few.
.........
Trump is no populist. His tax plan released last Wednesday by Goldman Sachs veterans and White House officials Gary Cohn and Steven Mnuchin would slash tax rates for businesses from (a seldom paid) 35 percent to 15 percent. The Trump scheme includes a pass-through tax cut on business income that is currently taxed at the business owners individual income tax rates rather than the corporate rate.
Calling Trumps proposal as a very big step in precisely the wrong direction, the Economic Policy Institutes Josh Bivens and Hunter Blair say that the pass-through tax cut will help private equity managers and people like President Trump: wealthy people who will now be able to reconfigure their taxes by reclassifying themselves as independent contractors.
..........
Meanwhile the mainstream media writes off politicians closer to real populism left leaders like Corbin and Melenchon as the extreme left.
Its too much, I suppose, to expect the U.S. corporate media to acknowledge that a neofascist sits in the White House as the representative of one of the nations leading two capitalist parties. One might at least hope they could use the F word (fascism) to describe the quite more openly fascistic white-nationalist militia groups that have seen chilling membership gains under Obama and Trump. So far, those groups too have avoided accurate description as fascist by mainstream U.S. news authorities (see this from PBS, for example) a disturbing fact. It does not bode well.
denverbill
(11,489 posts)To say Trump campaigned as a populist is probably true. He told people he was going to give them better health care, more good jobs, tax cuts, etc, but he was just telling them what they wanted to hear to get their votes. He doesn't give a shit about little people any more than Paul Ryan or 90% of other Republicans do and way too many Democrats as well.
The media uses the word populism as a smear against liberals most of the time when they are running against moderate Democrats, and did so against Sanders regularly in 2016. The difference is Sanders is continually pushing populist laws and Trump is doing the exact opposite. Trump campaigned as a populist and governs as a fascist.
struggle4progress
(118,268 posts)FSogol
(45,464 posts)leftynyc
(26,060 posts)stevenleser
(32,886 posts)Expecting Rain
(811 posts)Populism (right-wing and left-wing variants alike) has only lead to misery and human suffering when such movements come to power.
geek tragedy
(68,868 posts)the politics of "us vs them, they are to blame for all of your problems" is very powerful, but also very dangerous
stevenleser
(32,886 posts)as you noted, very powerful but also very dangerous.