General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsEveryone Would Stand for the National Anthem, if This was the Song
Link:
gratuitous
(82,849 posts)Well, except that it was written by an immigrant Jew, so . . . no, obviously.
MineralMan
(146,287 posts)It is a hymn.
I'm an atheist. I would not stand for that song.
It is entirely unsuitable to be any sort of anthem for the United States.
See the First Amendment, please.
Brainstormy
(2,380 posts)louis c
(8,652 posts)and can't you just see those red necks standing with their hands over their hearts as the words "as He died to make men holy, let us die to make men free" appear on the jumbothron.
MineralMan
(146,287 posts)Anyone who would recommend a hymn as the National Anthem is not even bothering to think, in my opinion.
louis c
(8,652 posts)Why is that?
Spider Jerusalem
(21,786 posts)the law mandating that to appear on US currency was passed in 1957. Same reason they added "under god" to the pledge of allegiance.
louis c
(8,652 posts)it is clearly constitutional. That's the point
Spider Jerusalem
(21,786 posts)elehhhhna
(32,076 posts)This land is your land, maybe
Hekate
(90,653 posts)LisaM
(27,803 posts)I like the song and I enjoy singing it, but I don't think it's anthem material, plus it seems unnecessarily divisive. But, I don't know if you were being ironic or not, so I'll defer on that.
The Wielding Truth
(11,415 posts)vlyons
(10,252 posts)or this song
The Wielding Truth
(11,415 posts)We would have to add another verse to include Hawaii, Alaska and Puerto Rico and the US territories.
http://scienceblogs.com/effectmeasure/2009/01/21/this-land-is-your-land-the-for/
If all you know of This Land is Your Land are versions made popular by Peter, Paul and Mary, Bob Dylan or the Kingston Trio or the song you sang in the third grade in school, you wont know any of them. They were considered too dangerous and subversive. One of the three was slightly altered for the Mall concert, in a very significant way. The last of them is an expression of hope and determination:
Nobody living can ever stop me,
As I go walking that freedom highway;
Nobody living can ever make me turn back
This land was made for you and me.
Its preceded by two other verses, one of which is still incendiary. Actually hearing it on TV was a mind boggling experience for many of us:
There was a big high wall there that tried to stop me;
The sign was painted, it said private property;
But on the back side it didn't say nothing;
That side was made for you and me.
Stunning. But more interesting is what Pete and company did to this seldom heard verse:
In the squares of the city, In the shadow of a steeple;
By the Relief Office, Id seen my people.
As they stood there hungry, I stood there asking,
Is this land made for you and me?
For the Mall concert, the despairing query of the last line changed to one of optimism and affirmation:
As they stood hungry, I stood there whistling,
This land was made for you and me.
I raise my glass to you, Pete. You got to sing it at last. And Im so very, very glad.
ProudLib72
(17,984 posts)to Warrant's Cherry Pie.
Response to louis c (Original post)
Name removed Message auto-removed
Cattledog
(5,914 posts)LexVegas
(6,059 posts)woodsprite
(11,911 posts)Love it, and so does the audience. Most of the audience is made up of Veterans and their wives. I would love it if some of them would "take a knee" when we perform the Star Spangled Banner, but I doubt anyone would/could.
WhiskeyGrinder
(22,327 posts)k8conant
(3,030 posts)k8conant
(3,030 posts)Journeyman
(15,031 posts)moda253
(615 posts)nah just kidding.
GoCubsGo
(32,080 posts)TlalocW
(15,381 posts)Instructive and if we all learned it, it would be fun to hear how loud certain states got as residents called out their states.
TlalocW
MontanaMama
(23,308 posts)Although I quarrel with the "brotherhood" part. Screw that.
surrealAmerican
(11,360 posts)They are protesting their treatment by government forces in this country.
The content of the song is irrelevant.
johnp3907
(3,730 posts)And it SHOULD be!
aka-chmeee
(1,132 posts)be a better anthem. The title invokes the flag, it is optimistic and exuberant and does not require singing.
Ms. Toad
(34,066 posts)greyl
(22,990 posts)Your construction
Smells of corruption
I manipulate to recreate
This air to ground saga
Gotta launder my karma
I said hallelujah to the sixteen loyal fans
You'll get down on your mothafuckin' knees
And it's time for your sickness again
Come on and tell me what you need
Tell me what is making you bleed
We got two more minutes and
We gonna cut to what you need
So one of six so tell me
One do you want to live
And one of seven tell me
Is it time for your mothafuckin' ass to give
Tell me is it time to get down on your mothafuckin' knees
Tell me is it time to get down
I'm blown to the maxim
Two hemispheres battlin'
I'm blown to the maxim
Two hemispheres battlin'
Suckin' up, one last breath
Take a drag off of death
Hey Mr. Policeman
Is it time for getting away
Is it time for driving down the mother fuckin' road
And running from your ass today
Now tell me if do you agree
Or tell me if I'm makin' you bleed
I got a few more minutes and
I'm gonna cut to what you need
So one of six so tell me
One do you want to live
And one of seven tell me
Is it time for your mothafuckin' ass to give
Tell me is it time to get down on your mothafuckin' knees
Tell me is it time to get down
Got a revolution behind my eyes
We got to get up and organize
Got a revolution behind my eyes
We got to get up and organize
Got a revolution behind my eyes
We got to get up and organize
You want a revolution behind your eyes
We got to get up and organize
Come on baby tell me
Yes we aim to please