Sarah Palin loses special election for Alaska House seat
Source: CNN Politics
(CNN) Democrat Mary Peltola won the special election to fill Alaska's House seat for the remainder of 2022, according to unofficial results released by the Alaska Division of Elections, thwarting former Gov. Sarah Palin's bid at a political comeback -- at least for a few months. Peltola emerged as the victor Wednesday when Alaska's Division of Elections tabulated ranked-choice ballots in the state's first use of the system.
With her victory, the former state lawmaker will fill the remainder of the term of the late Rep. Don Young, who died in March after holding the state's House seat for 49 years, and is set to become the first Alaska Native to represent the state in Congress. The race for Young's seat had been viewed nationally through the lens of the attempted political comeback of Palin, who in 2008 became the Republican vice presidential nominee and, after losing, in 2009 resigned midway through her lone term in the governor's office. She has not run for office since.
But she'll get another chance at the House race -- Palin and Peltola are also among those vying to fill the full term in a separate election in November. The special election process began when a field of 48 candidates -- including Santa Claus, a North Pole councilman and Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders supporter -- was whittled down to a final four in a June primary in which candidates of all parties ran together on one ballot.
Palin; Peltola; Nick Begich III, a Republican businessman from the state's most famous Democratic political family; and independent Al Gross were the four that advanced. But shortly after the primary, Gross dropped out of the race, a move that consolidated Democratic support behind Peltola. Peltola, meanwhile, sought to seize on the Supreme Court's decision ending federal abortion rights protections, campaigning as a pro-abortion rights, pro-labor union candidate with a deep connection to issues like fishing that are closely tied to Alaska's identity and economy.
Read more: https://www.cnn.com/2022/08/31/politics/alaska-house-seat-ranked-choice-ballots/index.html
(this would at least balance Crist's resigning of his seat in FL)
skylucy
(3,739 posts)elleng
(130,865 posts)Rebl2
(13,494 posts)LetMyPeopleVote
(145,130 posts)peppertree
(21,624 posts)Three Cheers!!
Rhiannon12866
(205,237 posts)For the people of Alaska!
peppertree
(21,624 posts)After 50 years of a philandering kleptocrat (Young), the good people of Alaska invested in themselves this time.
MOMFUDSKI
(5,515 posts)Who?
peppertree
(21,624 posts)empedocles
(15,751 posts)LetMyPeopleVote
(145,130 posts)ismnotwasm
(41,976 posts)I dont have the energy for Palin
BOSSHOG
(37,046 posts)Makes the election VERY special.
Any claims of voter fraud?
peppertree
(21,624 posts)The last one, of course, was Nick Begich, who disappeared under very suspicious circumstances that year.
He'd be proud.
DBoon
(22,356 posts)On October 16, 1972, he and House Majority Leader Hale Boggs, of Louisiana, were two of the four men on board a twin engine Cessna 310 when the airplane disappeared during a flight from Anchorage to Juneau. Also on board were Begich's aide, Russell Brown, and the pilot, Don Jonz.[11] The four were heading to a campaign fundraiser for Begich.
In an enormous search effort, search and rescue aircraft of the United States Coast Guard, Navy, Army, Air Force, Civil Air Patrol and civilians were deployed to look for the four men and the missing Cessna 310. On November 24, 1972, after proceeding for 39 days, the air search was suspended.[12] Neither the airplane nor any of its four occupants were ever found. All were declared dead on December 29, 1972.
The Cessna was required to carry an emergency locator transmitter (ELT) per Alaska state statutes section 02.35.115, Downed Aircraft Transmitting Devices, which took effect on September 6, 1972,[13] five weeks before the plane disappeared. The Alaska statute made reference to Federal Aviation Regulation 91.52, published on September 21, 1971, which mandated ELTs in aircraft such as this, but had an effective date of December 30, 1973, for existing aircraft.[14][15][16]
No ELT signal determined to be from the plane was heard during the search. In its report on the incident, the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) stated that the pilot's portable ELT, permissible in lieu of a fixed ELT on the plane, was found in an aircraft at Fairbanks, Alaska. The report also notes that a witness saw an unidentified object in the pilot's briefcase that resembled, except for color, the portable ELT. The NTSB concluded that neither the pilot nor aircraft had an ELT.[17]
In 1972, the tallest building in Whittier, Alaska, was renamed to Begich Towers in memory of Nick Begich. Begich Peak which is three miles north of the Begich, Boggs Visitor Center at Portage Lake is also named for him.[18]
In November 2015, a Seattle Weekly story detailed the work of journalist Jonathan Walczak, who since 2012 has investigated the plane crash and subsequent events in an effort to determine the fate of the flight that carried Begich and Boggs.[19] Walczak created a podcast about Begich's disappearance, which was released by iHeartMedia in the summer of 2020. The podcast, called Missing in Alaska, explored the conspiratorial ideas that FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover or Detroit mobsters operating in Tucson had assassinated Hale Boggs.[20]
from Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nick_Begich
peppertree
(21,624 posts)The target in this case did in fact appear to be Hale Boggs, who as House Majority Leader was, at the time, the highest-ranking congressman to openly voice doubts as to the Warren Commission report.
We'll never know if that had anything to do with it of course - but it certainly gives pause.
Claustrum
(4,845 posts)and claim voter fraud the whole way.
rpannier
(24,329 posts)Il douche went to Alaska on April 4 to endorse Palin and Tshibaka for senate
Murkowski must be laughing herself sick
2naSalit
(86,565 posts)Thanks Alaska!
SheltieLover
(57,073 posts)electric_blue68
(14,887 posts)badhair77
(4,216 posts)We need something positive. Just great.
ificandream
(9,370 posts)ancianita
(36,030 posts)But given the targeted attacks by Republicans on 57 Democratic seats, it would be a shame to have us win a solid majority in the Senate and lose the House.
Crist is running for FL governor again, against DeSantis, with a smaller campaign war chest, though Reuters says that DeSantis is saving the bulk of his money for his presidential run. The Republican statehouse won't let Crist be successful, either.
I must be missing something about party priorities. I keep seeing that, except for this Alaska win, the party's still being more reactive than not in campaign choices. We lost 13 House seats last year. All Rethugs need are 7 more House wins in November. We've got House Dems resigning to take on state fights, the end result will leave us crippled at both state and federal levels. Perhaps I'm mistaken and need to read up more on this.
I'm just not feeling the fight as anything but uphill for us. We're up against dark money, not rethugs.
BumRushDaShow
(128,877 posts)ancianita
(36,030 posts)Ballotpedia says the 13th district's outcome will determine the makeup of the 118th Congress.
Lynn is up against Anna Luna (R) and four other vote siphoning candidates.
The new district map.
BumRushDaShow
(128,877 posts)OP - https://www.democraticunderground.com/10142963120
That map is supposedly still being litigated (I think the FL Supreme Court still has to rule on it but that is obviously a crap shoot )
ancianita
(36,030 posts)Thanks for your links. I've now sent out more battleground donations than I spent as a full donor to Obama.
BumRushDaShow
(128,877 posts)although have focused mostly here in PA so that we get a (D) governor and (D) Senator. I want to see how the House predictions shift to get some more there because if we lose the House, the next 2 years will mean a manufactured impeachment and all kinds of nightmarish clown shows.
ancianita
(36,030 posts)My worry exactly. I've donated to Demings in FL; outside that, Marcus Flowers (v. MTG), Warnock and Abrams in GA, O'Rourke, Beasley in NC, duhneece out in NM.
If we don't keep the House, my donations will have been a net zero. Then the Jan 6 Committee will be disbanded (good lord, you had to mention their time wasting impeachmentS! )
For the DOJ to carry on will be a bright spot. But its current decision to hold indictments until after Nov 8 is total rule of law enforcement cowardice. When the case is this tight, it should proceed.
Not to mention the fallout charges on congressional aiders and abetters, and the accessories after the fact of each of Trump's indictment counts. Hell, most, if not all of them, will be sitting there in the 118th Congress.
OTOH, to see them indicted after having won their next terms is creepy; I picture them voting from jail, since I'm sure they'll refuse to resign.
Rethugs will be laughing that they bullied the DOJ into "not looking political" whenever a Democratic administration sits in the Executive.
BumRushDaShow
(128,877 posts)I don't know if they have explicitly said they would do that despite that OLC "memo". Especially given except for members of Congress who might be under investigation, none of the others are actually "declared candidates" running for office.
I expect something to come of the GA probe and possibly the NY (both Manhattan and NY AG) cases before the election in any case.
ancianita
(36,030 posts)THOSE state indictments will definitely help. Thanks for the hopeful reminder. And yes, I think we've heard from Garland that the OLC doesn't govern him, so I'll keep my fingers crossed.
I'm also hoping that women and Latinos will really turn out for House races.
Imallin4Joe
(758 posts)why is that classic song from The Wizard of Oz resonating in my head right now?
PlanetBev
(4,104 posts)I get a colossal surprise and my hope in America is restored. Made my day.
question everything
(47,470 posts)niyad
(113,274 posts)BumRushDaShow
(128,877 posts)He and Hale Boggs were on a plane that went down somewhere over Alaska and was lost.
He was the (D) grandfather of the (R) Nick Begich, III who was also running in this election.
ETA to add Mark Beigich was (D) Senator for a term.
question everything
(47,470 posts)Let's hope that Palin and Begich will split the R votes in November.
littlemissmartypants
(22,632 posts)question everything
(47,470 posts)littlemissmartypants
(22,632 posts)rpannier
(24,329 posts)The family has had both Democrats and Republicans in it for many years
rpannier
(24,329 posts)question everything
(47,470 posts)LetMyPeopleVote
(145,130 posts)dupagelib
(143 posts)Although she probably could play Peltola as well.
eppur_se_muova
(36,260 posts)purr-rat beauty
(543 posts)Mary Peltola wins!
turtleblossom
(504 posts)RussBLib
(9,006 posts)And I love Pertola's story. More good news for the Dems!!!
Bayard
(22,061 posts)Give us more of the same, please.
Efilroft Sul
(3,579 posts)Cheezoholic
(2,016 posts)like all things fat ass touches. Maybe she can start a Housewives of Alaska show now and get trampled by a moose, live, on TV, please.
lees1975
(3,845 posts)it's a major embarassment for Palin, but beyond that, I am looking at this as an indicator of what's down the line in November.
riversedge
(70,196 posts)Warpy
(111,249 posts)Alaska was willing to vote for a Democrat over Sarah Palin.
Maybe they needed a palate cleanser between right wing idiots.
RussBLib
(9,006 posts)It's a good story
Mary Peltola, a Democrat, Defeats Sarah Palin in Alaskas Special House Election https://www.nytimes.com/2022/08/31/us/politics/mary-peltola-alaska-special-election.html?unlocked_article_code=AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACEIPuonUktbfqYhkQFUYAibIRp8_qRmHmfnE2_s5j2XvaTCYTSpFy-1QCoyJ4ETEILF7atAy1jDeSdtMO6MuQ_o0zvNaOwYlbTiUlaa-ucZPJTQp-8X0V3kq3pnJUPc1_GS0YzS1IaJ2zrHm-k_bYWb1CKDehWl2JgwxoJRjfFqo3XcY1-ySRL4Or9p52fwrAZ57RS5RJ3XZ-qm1VGgtfYmOfRre6QIpWuFGWDm1nNaU6LMIcQs6GkuRBTokoj56sIUATYtRaKXvLBcge978iaESDgFqLISpDp4zQevEhk9jhFVxmXRqHKvx3lWIsuU
Samrob
(4,298 posts)The message should be clear enough that many of them will lose heart and give up by November. I know they are die-hards, but they are also, tired and cowardly. They need to win to keep going and they see now more losses than they could imagine. And just enough of them really understand that Trump is a lying loser and will not be around to keep them going and that he will kick them all under the bus as soon as it is real to him that he might be going to jail.
muriel_volestrangler
(101,307 posts)and the rest didn't give either as their second choice.
1st round:
Peltola: 75,761
Palin: 58,945
Begich: 53,756
Peltola gained 15,445 of Begich's votes to move to 91,206
Palin gained 27,042 to move to 85,987
https://www.kinyradio.com/news/news-of-the-north/peltola-prevails-in-ranked-choice-us-house-special-general-election/
With 2 nominally Republican candidates, 29% preferring to go to "the other side" is a lot. It shows many Republican Alaskans don't trust Palin (or do particularly trust Peltola).
BumRushDaShow
(128,877 posts)This might also be the reason that you had some cross-over vote as a 2nd choice -
Link to tweet
·
May 4, 2022
@MaryPeltola
·
Follow
Women across the country are scared right now and this election just became even more critical. Who we send to Congress this year will determine the fate of a womans right to choose.
Mary Peltola
@MaryPeltola
·
Follow
Im the only pro-choice woman in this race and as your U.S. Representative I will stand up for women and fight to enshrine abortion protections in federal law.
Vote Pro-choice. Vote Mary Peltola. 🗳
Image
5:49 PM · May 4, 2022
Palin and Beigich want to restrict or eliminate women's reproductive rights.
ETA - from the above link (that article had a good explanation of ranked choice AND how that is factoring in on both the special election and the primary for the full term -
By James Brooks Alaska Beacon Aug 9, 2022 Updated Aug 10, 2022
(snip)
In a June candidate forum hosted by the Anchorage Chamber of Commerce, Peltola said, I am in strong support of pro-choice and Roe v. Wade. Reproductive rights are as personal of an issue as you can possibly get, she said. This is one area I do not believe the federal government or for that matter the state government has say-so: in your personal body. Peltola and Palin reiterated their positions in questionnaires submitted to the Alaska Beacon in late July.
Begich did not answer a questionnaire, but in a Wednesday appearance on a radio show hosted by Alaskan Independence Party chairman Bob Bird, Begich said he no longer supports the current version of the federal Hyde Amendment, which allows federal funding for Medicaid to pay for abortion services in cases of rape, incest, or if a womans life is endangered by pregnancy. More than one in three Alaskans receive health care through Medicaid.
In Alaska, the state government pays for other abortions that providers have determined are medically necessary. Rulings from the Alaska Supreme Court have guaranteed those payments and abortion rights in general. Begichs campaign manager, Truman Reed, said Begich supports allowing abortions in those cases but opposes federal funding for them. Nicks position has been consistent from the start, Reed said. He is pro-life with allowance for the life of the mother, incest and rape. He steadfastly opposes the use of federal funds for abortion services.
Palin has said she opposes federal funding for abortion services but has not explicitly stated whether she supports laws allowing abortions for life-endangerment reasons, rape or incest. Her campaign website states, There is never an acceptable excuse for deliberately taking a human life, and we must not allow our society to become complicit in such crimes. Palins youngest child, Trig, was born with Down syndrome and diagnosed before his birth. I have a son with special needs. I was given that option, of course, to end his life before it really began. I was scared to death. It was the biggest challenge Ive ever faced, Palin said in June at the Anchorage chamber forum.
(snip)
https://www.anchoragepress.com/news/here-s-where-alaska-s-u-s-house-candidates-stand-on-access-to-abortion/article_b13a7e68-1830-11ed-a09b-f7d7dcc76301.html
onetexan
(13,036 posts)I hope they w consider for Peltola but w be tougher then.
myohmy2
(3,162 posts)...is going on in Alaska?
...are we witnessing the weakening effects of inbreeding?
...you never know...
msfiddlestix
(7,278 posts)Response to BumRushDaShow (Original post)
Name removed Message auto-removed
BumRushDaShow
(128,877 posts)I haven't done a deep dive into whether ranked choice is used for the general election too, which might make a difference (along with how many end up running in the general as they apparently do allow and get "write-ins" - which was how someone like Lisa Murkowski originally got in when she lost her primary back in the day).
SheltieLover
(57,073 posts)BumRushDaShow
(128,877 posts)Was just looking at this 538 piece -
By Nathaniel Rakich
Sep. 1, 2022, at 7:31 AM
For the second time in as many weeks, Democrats have won a competitive special election. And by the numbers, this win was even more impressive than last weeks victory in New Yorks 19th District. On Wednesday, the Alaska Division of Elections announced that former state Rep. Mary Peltola had defeated former Gov. Sarah Palin in the special election for the states vacant U.S. House seat, becoming the first Alaska Native ever elected to Congress and the first Democrat to win a statewide election since 2008.
(snip)
Unsurprisingly, most of Begichs votes (50 percent) went to his fellow Republican, Palin. But an impressive 29 percent went to Peltola, and 21 percent were exhausted, meaning there was no second-choice pick, and the votes were essentially thrown out. That combination was enough for Peltola to win. While Palin gained more votes from the redistribution than Peltola did, Peltola was starting from a higher total, and receiving 29 percent of Begichs votes was enough to keep her ahead of Palin. In the end, Peltola received 51 percent of the votes counted in the final round, while Palin received 49 percent.
(snip)
Democrats have clearly overperformed in special elections since the Supreme Court overturned the constitutional right to abortion in Dobbs v. Jackson in June, but the reasons for Peltolas win may have been more local than national. Namely, Palin was a very flawed candidate. After her 2008 vice-presidential campaign flopped, Palin resigned the governorship (reportedly amid ethics investigations), bought a house in Arizona and went on to appear on reality TV giving many Alaskans the sense that she had abandoned them. According to a July poll from Alaska Survey Research, 61 percent of Alaska registered voters had a negative opinion of her. Its hard to win with those kinds of numbers. It seems likely then, that had a different Republican advanced to the final round, Peltola would have lost. According to that same poll which almost exactly nailed the final margin between Peltola and Palin Begich would have defeated Peltola 55 percent to 45 percent if he had made it to the final round instead of her. That would still have been bluer than Alaskas R+15 partisan lean, but it mostly demonstrates how much of Republicans underperformance here may have been due to simple candidate quality (or lack thereof).
(snip)
So its not clear what, if any, national lessons we can take away from the Alaska election. But thats OK because you should never generalize based on a single special election. They are simply too prone to idiosyncrasies such as, for example, a uniquely flawed candidate. Instead, you have to average several special elections together before they become predictive of the midterms. And when we do that, its clear that, no matter how you count Alaska, Democrats are punching above their weight in special elections since Dobbs. Other than Alaska, there have been four federal special elections since that June 24 decision, and Democrats did at least 6 points better than the partisan lean of the districts they ran in each election. If you plug in Alaskas first-round numbers (the ones that are good for Republicans), the average Democratic overperformance in special elections since Dobbs is 7 points. If you use the final-round numbers (i.e., Peltolas 3-point defeat of Palin), its 11 points. In other words, while Peltolas victory is a nice morale boost for Democrats, an extra vote for House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, an important milestone for Alaska Natives and, of course, undoubtedly a thrill for Peltola herself, its also kind of beside the point for purposes of predicting the midterms.
(snip)
https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/what-democrats-win-in-alaska-tells-us-about-november/
My answer to the above "analysis" -
They have "The Narrative®" and are determined to stick with it!!!
SheltieLover
(57,073 posts)Thx for sbaring.
I guess the bottom line is that polling is useless.
BumRushDaShow
(128,877 posts)but generally help to establish trends. But how how you formulate the questions and who you consider as a "likely voter", is going to make a difference for how close the poll matches what the reality ends up being.
SheltieLover
(57,073 posts)"How to lie with statistics" comes to mind.
BumRushDaShow
(128,877 posts)"Lies, damn lies, and statistics".
Rhiannon12866
(205,237 posts)So it's over, she's the congressperson now.
BumRushDaShow
(128,877 posts)it was also a parallel "primary" that will be for the full 2-year term, and Sarah Palin, Mark Begich, and Mary Peltola will be running this November (Peltola will be the "incumbent" at this point).
I did see Peltola on Alex Wagner's show last night!