Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

elleng

(130,865 posts)
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 03:44 PM Jul 2014

Federal Judge Rules California's Death Penalty System Unconstitutional.

Source: nyt/reuters

California's system for imposing and carrying out the death penalty is so long and drawn-out that it amounts to cruel and unusual punishment and is unconstitutional, a federal judge ruled on Wednesday.

Ruling in the case of Ernest Dewayne Jones, who was condemned to death in 1995 and has yet to be executed, Judge Cormac J. Carney of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California said that to take "nearly a generation" to decide on Jones' appeals is unconstitutional.

Read more: http://www.nytimes.com/reuters/2014/07/16/us/16reuters-usa-deathpenalty-california.html?hp&action=click&pgtype=Homepage&version=WireFeed&module=pocket-region&region=pocket-region&WT.nav=pocket-region

30 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Federal Judge Rules California's Death Penalty System Unconstitutional. (Original Post) elleng Jul 2014 OP
+1. I would like to see it gone in its entirety. pinto Jul 2014 #1
Can't we just join the rest of the civilized nations that abolish this? Swede Atlanta Jul 2014 #2
Sitting in a cell 23 hours a day is a hell much worse than death - bullsht leftyohiolib Jul 2014 #3
You did, however, see a guy begging to be extradited from New York to Oklahoma KamaAina Jul 2014 #4
Oh please.... Swede Atlanta Jul 2014 #8
then why arent all the lifers trying to get the d.p.why do the ones on death row leftyohiolib Jul 2014 #9
Because they aren't in a cell for 23 hours a day. jeff47 Jul 2014 #12
Sorry... that's nonsense. FBaggins Jul 2014 #11
That's because upfront, LwP seems like the better choice. Chan790 Jul 2014 #15
As an anti-CP activist, I can tell you you're wrong. Chan790 Jul 2014 #14
a lwp sounds like torture, like cruel and unusual punishment - while we're telling stories leftyohiolib Jul 2014 #19
Stalin thought so, the Max sentence under Stalin was 10 years OR execution happyslug Jul 2014 #21
Wait, weren't you "pro-life"??? LeftyMom Jul 2014 #23
How did that one make it through review? tenderfoot Jul 2014 #30
Kind of hard to justify saying sitting in a cell is worse than death... lexx21 Jul 2014 #5
of course it is. thaT bs about lifers would rather die than live is , well ,,, b.s. leftyohiolib Jul 2014 #10
...and you know this from decades of experience with the incarcerated? n/t Chan790 Jul 2014 #16
and you know differently from decades of experience leftyohiolib Jul 2014 #17
(e) Life without parole is still a death sentence jeff47 Jul 2014 #13
because it's cruel and unusual punishment to have them locked up for years leftyohiolib Jul 2014 #18
So give the prisoner the choice. jeff47 Jul 2014 #20
I do agree with you on most everything you said, with the exception of the last one davidpdx Jul 2014 #25
Good. Iggo Jul 2014 #6
Huzzuh sakabatou Jul 2014 #7
Best thing I've heard in a long time. defacto7 Jul 2014 #22
It all seems a little academic at this point Sen. Walter Sobchak Jul 2014 #24
How can it be cruel and unusual if the penalty Calista241 Jul 2014 #26
The length of time it takes to effectuate it is cruel and unusual. elleng Jul 2014 #29
Judge is a Gray Davis (D) nominee to CA state court & George W. Bush (R) nom to fed court. nt alp227 Jul 2014 #27
And Rose Bird chuckles in her grave. bemildred Jul 2014 #28
 

Swede Atlanta

(3,596 posts)
2. Can't we just join the rest of the civilized nations that abolish this?
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 03:55 PM
Jul 2014

It causes so much churn in our legal system and has advocates on both sides engaged in cross-purpose activities.

We should agree that
(a) We get it wrong (probably more times than not given police and DA malfeasance) or at all
(b) It costs us much more money for legal challenges, etc.
(c) CP is a form of revenge and our system should not be revenge but punishment
(d) Sitting in a cell 23 hours a day is a hell much worse than death

 

leftyohiolib

(5,917 posts)
3. Sitting in a cell 23 hours a day is a hell much worse than death - bullsht
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 03:58 PM
Jul 2014

you dont see inmates trying to get on death row to get out of a life term-jeez. what they do is sit there waiting for a chance to kill a guard or guards and escape.

 

KamaAina

(78,249 posts)
4. You did, however, see a guy begging to be extradited from New York to Oklahoma
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 04:06 PM
Jul 2014

because OK has the death penalty and NY did not at the time. (Yes, they reinstated it. )

 

Swede Atlanta

(3,596 posts)
8. Oh please....
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 04:11 PM
Jul 2014

If you knew you would be confined to a cell no larger than a closet for the rest of your life versus the option to go someplace and be put to sleep like we do pets, which would you choose?

I am so tired of the CP apologists. Your "arguments" are rooted in some kind of self-denial program.

 

leftyohiolib

(5,917 posts)
9. then why arent all the lifers trying to get the d.p.why do the ones on death row
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 04:17 PM
Jul 2014

exhast all off their appeals trying to get off death row.

FBaggins

(26,728 posts)
11. Sorry... that's nonsense.
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 04:27 PM
Jul 2014

DAs don't offer to plead life sentences down to the death penalty is you cooperate... they plead the death penalty down to life in prison.

 

Chan790

(20,176 posts)
15. That's because upfront, LwP seems like the better choice.
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 04:49 PM
Jul 2014

I know guys serving LwP...a lot of them wish they were dead; the majority are ambivalent about it at best. They don't fear dying, they fear dying in pain or slowly. They have no hope. There is no hope for the terminally-incarcerated--whether you're slogging it out until a natural demise or taking the express train via the gurney with the viewing lobby...it all ends the same way.

Dead in a body bag. Probably buried in Potter's Field.

 

Chan790

(20,176 posts)
14. As an anti-CP activist, I can tell you you're wrong.
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 04:44 PM
Jul 2014

There's a reason why the suicide rate for LwP inmates is so high. It's nothing but a long tunnel of despair with nothing to look forward to except dying. I want to tell you about the life of a LwP inmate.

The first few years, it probably doesn't seem so bad. You're alive, you can make friends, occupy your time. Then you get bored, there aren't that many ways to occupy yourself in prison and they all get tedious after a while. Other inmates get training, education, activities to prepare them for the day they may be released...you're never going to be released, you don't get those. Sometimes your family, friends will come visit...for the first few years. Then they come less and less often as they move on with their lives, grow up, get married, have kids, move away, have lives on the outside that you are no longer part of, will never be part of. Then fewer and fewer come until nobody ever comes to see you and you're alone to deal with the monotony of incarcerated life. After a while, your friends on the inside become friends on the outside; they get paroled and you never will. They don't come back to visit, it's too traumatic. Your friends on the inside die, they get moved away; you don't make new friends as easily because you're divorced from the outside world, the new inmates have cultural touchstones you will never understand. If you're lucky, you might get a penpal on the outside...some of those people are nice, but the majority are honestly f**ked in the head so that's no relief. At that point, it's never going to get better, it's really never going to be different even. Just marking days until the day you don't get up because you've died in your sleep. A lifetime wasted, locked away in a cage like an animal with the other animals.

That's so much more appealing than being euthanized. It's really a question if you prefer to the long road or the short road to the same destination.

 

leftyohiolib

(5,917 posts)
19. a lwp sounds like torture, like cruel and unusual punishment - while we're telling stories
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 05:19 PM
Jul 2014

let me tell about EVERY death row inmate. they spend years desperately trying to get off death row and none try that hard to get on it. they have nothing to lose so the become the prison hit men they kill guards and other inmates b/c they dont have anything to worry about.
life w/o parole enables the murder of others- lwp is unconstitutional since it is cruel punishement (going on what you just told me )

 

happyslug

(14,779 posts)
21. Stalin thought so, the Max sentence under Stalin was 10 years OR execution
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 06:40 PM
Jul 2014

After WWII it was increased (When the Soviet Union Collapsed they still had some WWII war criminals in their prisons).

Even in the 1980s, the max sentence was 15 years, through a death sentence could be commuted to a 20 years sentence.

http://books.google.com/books?id=ccHN7cp-V4EC&pg=PA12&lpg=PA12&dq=Soviet+Union+10+year+max+prison+sentence&source=bl&ots=n1-8xrZoxB&sig=bsWP0WKEVx-wIzPqm41SmRBya-I&hl=en&sa=X&ei=tfrGU7aaHvHLsASAuoBw&ved=0CC8Q6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=Soviet%20Union%2010%20year%20max%20prison%20sentence&f=false

Russia still commutes all life sentences after 17 years, i.e. Life can be no more then 17 years.

http://www.academia.edu/4677726/_and_Aarun_A_Comparative_Look_at_Russian_and_Alaskan_Sentencing_Guidelines_and_Structures




Comparison between Alaska and Russian Sentences for various crimes:

Crime...........Alaskan Statutes.......................The Criminal Code of the Russian Federation
Murder 1.... Min 20 years, Max 99 years..... Deprivation of liberty for a term of 8 to 20 years or
....................Fine up to $500,000.....................by death penalty, or deprivation of liberty for life
Murder 2......Min 10 years; Max 99 years......Deprivation of liberty for a term of 6 to 15 years
.....................Fine up to $250,000
Assault 1.......Min 5 years; Max 20 years..........Deprivation of liberty for a term of 2 to 8 years
......................Fine up to $250,000
Rape...........Min 5 years; Max 20 years..............Deprivation of liberty for a term of 3 to 6 years
.......................Fine up to $250,000
Kidnapping...Min 5 years; Max 20 years.............Deprivation of liberty for a term of 4 to 8 years
..........................Fine up to $250,000
DUI.................72 hours jail .................................Punishable by a fine of between 5 and 10 Times
........................Fine up to $1,500......................................the daily minimum wage


Yes, Russia, even today and in Stalin's day imprisoned people for shorter times periods then does the US:

Please note, the Death Penalty, while still on the books in the Russian Federation, is suspended and no one is proposing to un-suspend it. Thus the 17 year max sentence is what life amounts to in the Russian Federation.

LeftyMom

(49,212 posts)
23. Wait, weren't you "pro-life"???
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 11:17 PM
Jul 2014

Last week you called women who get abortions murderers, now you're all for the killing of real, live human beings? Are you thoughtlessy inconsistent or do human lives only matter when they're a handy excuse for slut shaming?

lexx21

(321 posts)
5. Kind of hard to justify saying sitting in a cell is worse than death...
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 04:07 PM
Jul 2014

considering that we don't have anyone around that can speak first hand to the alternative..... Just saying.

 

leftyohiolib

(5,917 posts)
17. and you know differently from decades of experience
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 05:09 PM
Jul 2014

you dont see inmates trying to get on death row to get out of a life term- no you dont what you do see is death row inmates exhasting their appeals over years trying to get off death row and into life term.

jeff47

(26,549 posts)
13. (e) Life without parole is still a death sentence
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 04:39 PM
Jul 2014

Prison is not a nice place to be. If you want to punish those evildoers, why on Earth do you want to cut the punishment short by executing them?

 

leftyohiolib

(5,917 posts)
18. because it's cruel and unusual punishment to have them locked up for years
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 05:13 PM
Jul 2014

i dont want to give someone with nothing left to lose a chance to kill guards or other inmates. i dont want someone to get a killer out of jail on some technicality . i dont want to have to pay restitution over a lawsuit an inmate filed for warm pudding, cold oatmeal , raw steaks etc.

jeff47

(26,549 posts)
20. So give the prisoner the choice.
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 06:12 PM
Jul 2014

Sentence them to life, and let them ask to be executed at any time during that sentence.

Also:

i dont want to give someone with nothing left to lose a chance to kill guards or other inmates.

You realize we already do sentence people to life without parole, right? And that prison guards are not constantly being slaughtered by such prisoners.

You also realize that the countries that did away with the death penalty have life sentences, and prison guards and other inmates are not constantly being slaughtered by such prisoners.

Ya know, reality is a pretty fun place to be. You may wanna consider moving.

davidpdx

(22,000 posts)
25. I do agree with you on most everything you said, with the exception of the last one
Thu Jul 17, 2014, 07:26 AM
Jul 2014

I can't speak for other states or other countries besides Oregon, but I can tell you that in Oregon there are inmates that are sentenced to life without parole who don't sit in a cell for 23 hours a day. The worst of the worst who are in a maximum facility probably do, but those at medium facilities they are able to do quite a bit. It depends on their security classification when they go into the prison system.

Ok, I'm done nitpicking.

defacto7

(13,485 posts)
22. Best thing I've heard in a long time.
Wed Jul 16, 2014, 10:52 PM
Jul 2014

A step... keep it rolling. The death penalty is completely irrelevant to civil justice. I say uncivilized. All other possibilities are on the table and that is another discussion/argument whatever, I don't care at this point. The death penalty stands on it's own and must be abolished everywhere.

 

Sen. Walter Sobchak

(8,692 posts)
24. It all seems a little academic at this point
Thu Jul 17, 2014, 12:56 AM
Jul 2014

I seriously doubt there will ever be another execution in California, but there is little point repealing it since there will just be yet another ballot proposition to restore it.

elleng

(130,865 posts)
29. The length of time it takes to effectuate it is cruel and unusual.
Fri Jul 18, 2014, 11:14 AM
Jul 2014

'California's system for imposing and carrying out the death penalty is so long and drawn-out that it amounts to cruel and unusual punishment and is unconstitutional.'

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Federal Judge Rules Calif...