Mocked and forgotten: who will speak for the American white working class?
When you listen to poor people who work with their hands, you hear a uniform frustration and a constant anxiety but its not just about economic issues.
'The National Review, a conservative magazine for the Republican elite, recently unleashed an attack on the white working class, who they see as the core of Trumps support.
The first essay, Father Führer, was written by the National Reviews Kevin Williamson, who used his past reporting from places such as Appalachia and the Rust Belt to dissect what he calls downscale communities.
He describes them as filled with welfare dependency, drug and alcohol addiction, and family anarchy and then proclaims:
Nothing happened to them. There wasnt some awful disaster, There wasnt a war or a famine or a plague or a foreign occupation. ... The truth about these dysfunctional, downscale communities is that they deserve to die. Economically, they are negative assets. Morally, they are indefensible. The white American underclass is in thrall to a vicious, selfish culture whose main products are misery and used heroin needles.
A few days later, another columnist, David French, added:
Simply put, [white working class] Americans are killing themselves and destroying their families at an alarming rate. No one is making them do it. The economy isnt putting a bottle in their hand. Immigrants arent making them cheat on their wives or snort OxyContin.
Both suggested the answer to their problems is they need to move. They need real opportunity, which means that they need real change, which means that they need U-Haul.
Downscale communities are everywhere in America, not just limited to Appalachia and the Rust Belt its where I have spent much of the past five years documenting poverty and addiction.
To say that nothing happened to them is stunningly wrong. Over the past 35 years the working class has been devalued, the result of an economic version of the Hunger Games. It has pitted everyone against each other, regardless of where they started. Some contestants, such as business owners, were equipped with the fanciest weapons. The working class only had their hands. They lost and have been left to deal on their own.
The consequences can be seen in nearly every town and rural county and arent confined to the industrial north or the hills of Kentucky either. My home town in Florida, a small town built around two orange juice factories, lost its first factory in 1985 and its last in 2005.
In the South Buffalo neighborhood of Lackawanna, homes have yet to recover from the closing of an old steel mill that looms over them. The plant, once one of many, provided the community with jobs and stability. The parts that havent been torn down are now used mainly for storage.
In Utica, New York, a boarded-up GE plant thats been closed for more than 20 years sits behind Mr Nostalgias, a boarded-up bar where workers once spent nights. Jobs moved out of state and out of the country. The new jobs dont pay as well and dont offer the same benefits, so folks now go to the casino outside of town to try to supplement their income.
When you go into these communities and leave the small bubbles of success Manhattan, Los Angeles, northern Virginia, Cambridge and listen to people who work with their hands, you hear a uniform frustration and a constant anxiety. In a country of such amazing wealth, a large percentage of people are trying not to sink.
The frustration isnt just misplaced nostalgia the economic statistics show the same thing.
Over the past 35 years, except for the very wealthy, incomes have stagnated, with more people looking for fewer jobs. Jobs for those who work with their hands, manufacturing employment, has been the hardest hit, falling from 18m in the late 1980s to 12m now. . .
At almost every juncture over the past 35 years, Republicans have supported and passed policies that have empowered businesses while supporting the removal of policies that protect workers.
They have supported the shift towards an aggressive free market that rewards the winners, regardless of where they started, and does little to protect the losers.
They supported, and got, massive tax cuts for the wealthiest.
They supported, and got, the deregulation of Wall Street.
They supported every effort to dismantle the social safety net: food stamps, welfare, social security and Medicaid.
Some of the polices they have supported, such as free trade, have also been supported by the Democrats. These policies were justified by the notion that the entire country would win, because the winners will win more than the losers lose.
Yet this is contingent on the winners sharing, and the Republicans have no interest in making the winners share.'
http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/mar/24/white-working-class-issues-free-trade-american-south
2 candidates may appear to address these issues,from different apparent directions. What will happen? It's up to We the People to decide, and it would be useful if the media played the role it was intended to play. Too bad they don't.
"An educated citizenry is a vital requisite for our survival as a free people."
This quotation seems to have originated in an article of the same title on PicktheBusiness.com.1 It is an accurate paraphrase of Jefferson's views on education, but the exact phrasing seems to belong to the author of the article, and not Jefferson. The article title appears to have been mistaken by others as a direct quotation from Jefferson's 1816 letter to Charles Yancey, which is mentioned in the article, but the exact quotation does not appear in that letter or in any other known Jefferson writings.
https://www.monticello.org/site/jefferson/educated-citizenry-vital-requisite-our-survival-free-people-quotation
Depaysement
(1,835 posts)Except a relentless, savage 35 year class war.
elleng
(130,875 posts)And the economy's 'improving' for whom, exactly?
http://www.democraticunderground.com/111677178
http://www.democraticunderground.com/111677126
http://www.democraticunderground.com/111677194
Baobab
(4,667 posts)See tradeinservices dot net
cprise
(8,445 posts)Less than 9 years ago they were still gushing effusively about him and what his presidency represented. Even looking at the aging loons who support Trump today, one has to think that Trump's early career during the Reagan years is what attracts them.
Android3.14
(5,402 posts)More Newspeak.
meow2u3
(24,761 posts)http://xnerg.blogspot.com/2009/08/people-who-bite-hand-that-feeds-them.html
I think too many working-class white males are licking the corporate boots that are kicking them.
Downwinder
(12,869 posts)by zip code you can see that much of the country is living on OASDI.
https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/statcomps/oasdi_zip/2014/index.html
Locally, industrialization has moved employment opportunities from companies like Johnson & Johnson and TI to companies like Tyson and Ruiz with fewer employees and less pay. It is hard to expect people in their 50s to relocate for employment. Their mortgages are paid off or almost paid off unless they got sucked into refinancing, in which case they are most likely underwater. They are hanging on doing things like driving for the paratransport service which closed its doors two months ago.
The Mom & Pop stores and locally owned business that once recycled profits through the community have been replaced by Corporate chains who suck the profits out as fast as they come in.
Downtown has a 50% vacancy, moderated by a stream of Secondhand Rose stores opened by people who have become redundant elsewhere that last six months to a year competing with non-profits selling the same or better goods.
At any given time, thee are a dozen vacant restaurants where people can setup cheaply until they realize how hard it is to make it in a low income area.
Social Security and Medicare are the largest sources of income in the County with more than one in five in town receiving OASDI. That OASDI is keeping the businesses that are left going.