Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Amaryllis

(9,523 posts)
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 07:12 PM Jul 2017

Liberals Have Turned Trump Into a Gay Villain Because Our Worst Villains Must Be Gay (Slate)

"Now that Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin have met in the flesh, our obsession with imagining the president as a gay man has reached a climax. Frank Bruni used his Thursday column in the New York Times to publish a work of fan fiction, “Donnie and Vlad: A Love Story,” about the “irrepressible,” unrequited, and ultimately “gross” affection of the commander in chief for the leader of Russia. As the men talked behind closed doors for over two hours at the G-20 summit, Twitter got to work:

The joke is not that old, but it feels ancient. The Lithuanian mural atop Bruni’s piece of Trump and Putin kissing went viral over a year ago; Trump smooched a shirtless Putin on Saturday Night Live in November; and Stephen Colbert was assailed for calling Trump Putin’s “cock holster” in May. In the press, where it’s generally untoward to tease a president in explicitly sexual terms, Trump is said to have many “bromances”—attempted, “budding,” ongoing, and failed: with Tom Brady, with James Comey, with Rodrigo Duterte, with Andrew Jackson (d. 1845), with Morning Joe, with Kim Jong-un, with Narendra Modi (actually a romance, no b), with Rupert Murdoch, with Elon Musk, with Benjamin Netanyahu, with Abdel-Fattah al-Sisi, with Xi Jinping. And with Qatar Airways CEO Akbar El-Baker. And, of course, with Putin. (Trump has not, according to the press, had a ro- or bromance with Peter Thiel, who is gay and just his “tech pal.”) These references occur regularly in straight news coverage as ostensibly neutral descriptions. They’re also very, very popular with political cartoonists.
Advertisement

The trope is deployed not because it is novel but because it is not. It is hammered like a schoolyard taunt, with a smug assurance that Trump has been duly “trolled.” Like a lot of liberal comedy right now, it serves a fantasy of resistance through snark. (Think of Seth Rogen’s dumb Twitter messages to Donald Jr., recently glorified on Colbert’s show, or the news—ecstatically received in February and then chronicled as legend only three months later—that Melissa McCarthy had humiliated Sean Spicer.) Sexual politics aside, our glee in calling Trump gay says more about us than it does about him.

As for the sexual politics: The joke is a caricature of homoeroticism, descended from century-old stereotypes about gay men and power. Yes, most of the participants are angry liberals, idly imagining how cool it would be to make Trump sad—but Trump is not in the audience (most of the time), and he doesn’t seem to care a whole lot about homosexuality anyway. So why is this particular image the weapon of choice?

American homophobia has gone through multiple stages, each leaving a lasting mark on the culture. When we encounter homophobia today, it’s often in the form of undisguised, visceral disgust: at anal sex, at promiscuity, at disease, at gender nonconformity in general and effeminacy in particular. Sometimes, that disgust is swaddled in religion, as warnings against deviancy from nature and the breakdown of the family unit. In the political sphere, these religious ideas are—usually—defended without reference to their content, on the abstract basis of religious freedom or “tradition.”

More:
http://www.slate.com/blogs/outward/2017/07/10/jokes_about_trump_being_gay_draw_on_deep_rooted_stereotypes_about_gay_men.html?wpsrc=newsletter_tis&sid=589dfd6ebcb59c58118b45d5

2 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Liberals Have Turned Trump Into a Gay Villain Because Our Worst Villains Must Be Gay (Slate) (Original Post) Amaryllis Jul 2017 OP
The outrage is misdirected. The images get posted at JoeMyGod. mahatmakanejeeves Jul 2017 #1
THanks for the link to that site. I didn't know about it. Amaryllis Jul 2017 #2

mahatmakanejeeves

(56,896 posts)
1. The outrage is misdirected. The images get posted at JoeMyGod.
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 07:47 PM
Jul 2017
Joe.My.God

Don't worry about us. We can take it. I've been through lots worse than this.

I'm not at work now, so I can say this:

I'm sixty-six years old. I've dealt with total assholes every day of my life. On a one-to-one basis, up close and personal, in your face.

I've been kept out of the career I should have had. I've had to pack up and move. I've been fired by evangelicals. On the way out the door, I was handed a Jack Chick bible tract. I love those Jack Chick comics. I think they're a hoot.
they're not so funny when you're handed one as you've been fired.

***** thinks he's tough, but he's just another blowhard. He's something you step in and have to scrape off the sole of your shoe. He's just another in a long line of assholes.

If he wants a fight, we'll give him one.
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Editorials & Other Articles»Liberals Have Turned Trum...