Take a deal for the dreamers. Build the wall. - Washington Post Editorial Board
By Editorial Board January 10 at 7:21 PM
PRESIDENT TRUMP says he is optimistic a deal can be struck to shield dreamers, the young undocumented immigrants whose lives he put in jeopardy by stripping them of work permits and deportation protection, beginning March 5. His price, and that of many Republicans, is up to $33 billion in border-security measures, including Mr. Trumps beautiful wall. If thats the deal not one freighted with a laundry list of other items on the GOP wish list Democrats should take it.
Granted, Mr. Trump once told Americans that a border wall, paid for by Mexico, would cost $4 billion. After that, he said $6 billion or $7 billion, and later $10 billion. Now his administration says its really $18 billion for 722 miles of wall, of which just 316 miles would be a brand-new structure along the 2,000-mile southwest frontier. Oh, and Mexicos credit card seems to be missing.
The wall is a dumb idea. It wont do much to suppress illegal border crossings, which in any event have been falling for decades. And the additional border-security spending proposed by the administration, including thousands of new Border Patrol agents, is largely a waste. Rather than seriously addressing the opioid epidemic, or mounting cyberwarfare threats, or Americas crumbling infrastructure, the president wants to fortify a border where illegal crossings, as measured by Border Patrol apprehensions, are already at their lowest point since the Nixon administration. But consider how rare it is that a dumb idea in Congress actually buys something smart in return. In this case, the return on that dumb idea would be huge. (And betting that the courts will save the dreamers is too risky, notwithstanding a federal judges ruling Tuesday freezing dreamers protections for now.)
The walls $18 billion price tag would be spread over a decade. If a few billion dollars annually is the trade-off that provides certainty a pathway to citizenship or permanent legal status for nearly 700,000 young immigrants brought to this country as children by their parents, its worth it. Because the alternative all those lives ruined, all those jobs lost, all that education and promise cut short is much worse.
Democrats who choke on the wall, loath to hand Mr. Trump a political triumph, might ask themselves what other deals they might strike that would do so much tangible good, for so many people, so immediately and at such a relatively modest price. The likely answer is: very few.
more
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/take-a-deal-for-the-dreamers-build-the-wall/2018/01/10/d02a5c06-f640-11e7-beb6-c8d48830c54d_story.html
Freethinker65
(9,998 posts)Ohiogal
(31,897 posts)"A few billion dollars" could be so much more well spent in areas that actually help Americans! And if this is allowed, it's like sanctioning and normalizing the insanity of building his stupid wall in the first place!
And, the biggest fraud .... Trump said MEXICO WOULD PAY FOR IT! NOT the U.S.!!!!!!
Downtown Hound
(12,618 posts)Va Lefty
(6,252 posts)Phoenix61
(16,992 posts)We do not want to do this. It's giving in to evil.
yallerdawg
(16,104 posts)We don't hurt people just for 'shits and giggles.'
They need a handful of Democrats to pass most anything now - and there are Democratic opportunities ahead.
They would never give 'immigration reform' to a Democratic president.
But that idiot in the White House? Yeah, they'll happily hang it on him!
If they can get one more 'talking point' out of it. "Border security first!"
dubyadiprecession
(5,676 posts)People come here to stay illegally and may or may not get deported, and then they might re-enter this country illegally anyway. Our laws mean nothing, we might as well not have any immigration laws.
kysrsoze
(6,019 posts)They also didnt realize what they said in the last paragraph...
Democrats who choke on the wall, loath to hand Mr. Trump a political triumph, might ask themselves what other deals they might strike that would do so much tangible good, for so many people, so immediately and at such a relatively modest price. The likely answer is: very few.
Exactly... Drumpf and the Repubs wont do ANY other deals with them. Plus the battle is still going through the courts. Stupid, naive notion on the part of WaPo.
rzemanfl
(29,554 posts)live in comfort in a more civilized country. It would not be right, but would cost less than the damned wall.
dubyadiprecession
(5,676 posts)mahatmakanejeeves
(57,284 posts)murielm99
(30,713 posts)to normalize trump and his half-baked ideas. No other President would get anyone to listen to such a crazy idea.
Stop placating this madman.
russ1943
(618 posts)Pass legislation guaranteeing a pathway to citizenship or permanent legal status for nearly 700,000 young immigrants brought to this country as children by their parents, tied to his (stupid) wall. Funding for the wall as he has frequently stated, to come from Mexico, no US funds.