Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BeckyDem

(8,361 posts)
Mon Apr 15, 2019, 09:31 PM Apr 2019

Noam Chomsky: America's Extraterritorial Reach Is Its Own Scandal

* Excellent.


AMY GOODMAN: This is Democracy Now! I’m Amy Goodman in Boston, as we sit down with Noam Chomsky for a public conversation. I asked him about the arrest of Julian Assange.

NOAM CHOMSKY: Well, the Assange arrest is scandalous in several respects. One of them is just the effort of governments—and it’s not just the U.S. government. The British are cooperating. Ecuador, of course, is now cooperating. Sweden, before, had cooperated. The efforts to silence a journalist who was producing materials that people in power didn’t want the rascal multitude to know about—OK?—that’s basically what happened. WikiLeaks was producing things that people ought to know about those in power. People in power don’t like that, so therefore we have to silence it. OK? This is the kind of thing, the kind of scandal, that takes place, unfortunately, over and over.

To take another example, right next door to Ecuador, in Brazil, where the developments that have gone on are extremely important. This is the most important country in Latin America, one of the most important in the world. Under the Lula government early in this millennium, Brazil was the most—maybe the most respected country in the world. It was the voice for the Global South under the leadership of Lula da Silva. Notice what happened. There was a coup, soft coup, to eliminate the nefarious effects of the labor party, the Workers’ Party. These are described by the World Bank—not me, the World Bank—as the “golden decade” in Brazil’s history, with radical reduction of poverty, a massive extension of inclusion of marginalized populations, large parts of the population—Afro-Brazilian, indigenous—who were brought into the society, a sense of dignity and hope for the population. That couldn’t be tolerated.

After Lula’s—after he left office, a kind of a “soft coup” takes place—I won’t go through the details, but the last move, last September, was to take Lula da Silva, the leading, the most popular figure in Brazil, who was almost certain to win the forthcoming election, put him in jail, solitary confinement, essentially a death sentence, 25 years in jail, banned from reading press or books, and, crucially, barred from making a public statement—unlike mass murderers on death row. This, in order to silence the person who was likely to win the election. He’s the most important political prisoner in the world. Do you hear anything about it?

https://www.truthdig.com/articles/noam-chomsky-americas-extraterritorial-reach-is-its-own-scandal/

21 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Noam Chomsky: America's Extraterritorial Reach Is Its Own Scandal (Original Post) BeckyDem Apr 2019 OP
From the article: guillaumeb Apr 2019 #1
Yes and we must change that reality and replace it with humanity as central to BeckyDem Apr 2019 #2
Chomsky is being arbitrary as fuck in discussing "nations with extraterritorial reach" Blue_Tires Apr 2019 #6
China is following the example of all Empires. guillaumeb Apr 2019 #7
Sure as hell doesn't feel like it... Blue_Tires Apr 2019 #8
Extradition is goverened by treaties. guillaumeb Apr 2019 #9
I'd like to speak about espionage and ratfucking elections and acting as Blue_Tires Apr 2019 #10
Understood. My suggestion is to start a post about it. guillaumeb Apr 2019 #11
Greenwald floated that "COUP!" balloon about Dilma and it didn't fly Blue_Tires Apr 2019 #12
Does the US have a right to interfere in the affairs of another country? guillaumeb Apr 2019 #14
Does Russia have the right to fuck with us? Does China, Israel, India, etc? Blue_Tires Apr 2019 #15
What has happened to Lula is nothing short of evil. That's how the fascists won. n/t Judi Lynn Apr 2019 #3
Totally. BeckyDem Apr 2019 #4
GMAFB... If Assange want to fuck with us we'll fuck with him right back... Blue_Tires Apr 2019 #5
Chomsky carries water for no one. BeckyDem Apr 2019 #13
I hate to break it to you, but Blue_Tires Apr 2019 #16
You don't have anything to break for me. and most especially Chomsky. BeckyDem Apr 2019 #17
His actions speak for themselves... What other conclusion are we to make? Blue_Tires Apr 2019 #18
Chomsky was unavailable for comment: Blue_Tires Apr 2019 #19
Chomsky: Arrest of Assange Is "Scandalous" and Highlights Shocking Extraterritorial Reach of U.S. BeckyDem Apr 2019 #20
Thanks, Noam, we'll get back to you after we throw the treasonous shithead out of the WH. Hassler Apr 2019 #21

guillaumeb

(42,641 posts)
1. From the article:
Mon Apr 15, 2019, 09:38 PM
Apr 2019
The other scandal is just the extraterritorial reach of the United States, which is shocking.

I mean, why should the United States—why should any—no other state could possibly do it. But why should the United States have the power to control what others are doing elsewhere in the world?

I mean, it’s an outlandish situation. It goes on all the time. We never even notice it. At least there’s no comment on it.


From the earliest stages of US history, the Monroe Doctrine defined how US elites saw the role of the US. It started with the Americas, and was extended to the entire globe.

Over 700 overseas bases and military spending that far exceeds any other country.

Blue_Tires

(55,445 posts)
6. Chomsky is being arbitrary as fuck in discussing "nations with extraterritorial reach"
Wed Apr 17, 2019, 04:53 PM
Apr 2019

because China to cite one example certainly says 'hi', but that's for another thread.

So you'd what; prefer to let the ICC handle Assange?

Blue_Tires

(55,445 posts)
8. Sure as hell doesn't feel like it...
Wed Apr 17, 2019, 06:04 PM
Apr 2019

So should extradition not be a thing at ALL in any circumstance? Or do we just have a problem with it because Assange has nailed himself to a faux cross again before the media??

Blue_Tires

(55,445 posts)
10. I'd like to speak about espionage and ratfucking elections and acting as
Wed Apr 17, 2019, 06:17 PM
Apr 2019

a blackmailing information broker under the guise of "journalism", but we'll table that for now...

How is this an example of "imperial overreach"? Did we drag his filthy ass out of the embassy or something? Which law is being broken in requesting extradition for Assange? Ironically jail is the safest place for him right now because I assure you his life isn't worth $10 on the street...

Why is an intellectual like Chomsky missing the actual story here, which is Julian Assange, however pure and high-minded he started out over a decade ago, is now a fucking criminal extortionist/data thief/agitprop peddler acting DIRECTLY on behalf of the Russian Intelligence Services (which Assange doesn't even bother to pretend to deny anymore)?

guillaumeb

(42,641 posts)
11. Understood. My suggestion is to start a post about it.
Wed Apr 17, 2019, 06:51 PM
Apr 2019

Assange claims to be a journalist. And he might make that case.


edited to add:

but Chomsky also addresses US interference in Latin America.

Blue_Tires

(55,445 posts)
12. Greenwald floated that "COUP!" balloon about Dilma and it didn't fly
Wed Apr 17, 2019, 07:34 PM
Apr 2019

So Chomsky wants to make the same assertion with conjecture and circumstantial-at-best evidence? Good luck with that shit; which would be funny if Chomsky wasn't bending over backwards to explain how Russia's *proven and documented* ratfucking of Hillary Clinton didn't make any difference in the election result...

And lemme guess -- Tomorrow, Maduro will be some glorious hero of the leftist revolution under siege from the Imperial Evil Great Satan U.S. and pay no attention to the decomposing piles of protesters who 'accidentally' got shot, newspaper staffs rotting in jail, a completely dead economy replaced by a black market, medical aid he won't allow into the country and hundreds of thousands of former middle-class people who have to dumpster dive for today's sustenance...

Noam is cancelled...

guillaumeb

(42,641 posts)
14. Does the US have a right to interfere in the affairs of another country?
Wed Apr 17, 2019, 08:41 PM
Apr 2019

And does US interference ever hurt? The list of American countries that the US has invaded is long, as is the list that have suffered from US interference.

Blue_Tires

(55,445 posts)
15. Does Russia have the right to fuck with us? Does China, Israel, India, etc?
Thu Apr 18, 2019, 08:59 AM
Apr 2019

Because if it's wrong and immoral when WE do it then the same rule applies when other world powers do it elsewhere... Like I said, Chomsky is being selective as all balls in his outrage and it looks like he's playing an agenda.

Blue_Tires

(55,445 posts)
5. GMAFB... If Assange want to fuck with us we'll fuck with him right back...
Wed Apr 17, 2019, 04:50 PM
Apr 2019

I'm disappointed to see Noam carry water for a Kremlinist piece of shit like Assange. Odd that Noam didn't see fit to mention Assange publishing the very real personal details of innocent people in the Sony hack... Odd that he didn't mention Assange outing GLBT folks in Saudi Fucking Arabia or working for Assad's re-election or any of a hundred other things... There's this weird subset of the left who still see Assange and Wikileaks as their circa 2008 version before they sold out to Moscow.

And to make things worse he props up that Greenwaldian "coup in Brazil" conspiracy theory with Lula?? For Christ's sake, Chomsky is supposed to be smarter than this and Goodman is supposed to be better than this. DN started with promise but now it's only slightly better than the leftist version of Infowars...

Tune in tomorrow as Chomsky mourns over the tragedy of Alan Garcia the martyr...

Blue_Tires

(55,445 posts)
16. I hate to break it to you, but
Thu Apr 18, 2019, 09:01 AM
Apr 2019

anyone at this point still whoring that "KremlinGate is a overblown myth" deza is either really ignorant, hasn't bothered to keep up with the story, or they're getting their strings pulled directly from Moscow.

BeckyDem

(8,361 posts)
17. You don't have anything to break for me. and most especially Chomsky.
Thu Apr 18, 2019, 03:44 PM
Apr 2019

Anyone even suggesting he is getting his strings pulled by Moscow should be embarrassed.

Blue_Tires

(55,445 posts)
18. His actions speak for themselves... What other conclusion are we to make?
Thu Apr 18, 2019, 04:54 PM
Apr 2019

On the day that the redacted Mueller report gets released, no less?

BeckyDem

(8,361 posts)
20. Chomsky: Arrest of Assange Is "Scandalous" and Highlights Shocking Extraterritorial Reach of U.S.
Fri Apr 19, 2019, 08:39 PM
Apr 2019


NOAM CHOMSKY: Well, the Assange arrest is scandalous in several respects. One of them is just the effort of governments—and it’s not just the U.S. government. The British are cooperating. Ecuador, of course, is now cooperating. Sweden, before, had cooperated. The efforts to silence a journalist who was producing materials that people in power didn’t want the rascal multitude to know about—OK?—that’s basically what happened. WikiLeaks was producing things that people ought to know about those in power. People in power don’t like that, so therefore we have to silence it. OK? This is the kind of thing, the kind of scandal, that takes place, unfortunately, over and over.

To take another example, right next door to Ecuador, in Brazil, where the developments that have gone on are extremely important. This is the most important country in Latin America, one of the most important in the world. Under the Lula government early in this millennium, Brazil was the most—maybe the most respected country in the world. It was the voice for the Global South under the leadership of Lula da Silva. Notice what happened. There was a coup, soft coup, to eliminate the nefarious effects of the labor party, the Workers’ Party. These are described by the World Bank—not me, the World Bank—as the “golden decade” in Brazil’s history, with radical reduction of poverty, a massive extension of inclusion of marginalized populations, large parts of the population—Afro-Brazilian, indigenous—who were brought into the society, a sense of dignity and hope for the population. That couldn’t be tolerated.

After Lula’s—after he left office, a kind of a “soft coup” take place—I won’t go through the details, but the last move, last September, was to take Lula da Silva, the leading, the most popular figure in Brazil, who was almost certain to win the forthcoming election, put him in jail, solitary confinement, essentially a death sentence, 25 years in jail, banned from reading press or books, and, crucially, barred from making a public statement—unlike mass murderers on death row. This, in order to silence the person who was likely to win the election. He’s the most important political prisoner in the world. Do you hear anything about it?

Well, Assange is a similar case: We’ve got to silence this voice. You go back to history. Some of you may recall when Mussolini’s fascist government put Antonio Gramsci in jail. The prosecutor said, “We have to silence this voice for 20 years. Can’t let it speak.” That’s Assange. That’s Lula. There are other cases. That’s one scandal.

The other scandal is just the extraterritorial reach of the United States, which is shocking. I mean, why should the United States—why should any—no other state could possibly do it. But why should the United States have the power to control what others are doing elsewhere in t

he world? I mean, it’s an outlandish situation. It goes on all the time. We never even notice it. At least there’s no comment on it.


https://www.democracynow.org/2019/4/12/chomsky_arrest_of_assange_is_scandalous
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Editorials & Other Articles»Noam Chomsky: America's E...