Opinion: How Trump's pardons could get even more bizarre
President Donald Trump announced a wave of pardons on Tuesday for people ranging from Republican allies to two men who pleaded guilty in Robert Mueller's Russia investigation. Meanwhile, speculation grows about whether President Trump will pardon three of his adult children, his son-in-law, or even himself before his term ends on January 20.
But what if he issues these pardons and -- unlike those just made public -- no one finds out? That is not as far-fetched as it seems.
Trump's pardon power derives from a brief clause in the Constitution that simply gives him the authority to grant "Reprieves and Pardons" for federal offenses. But the Constitution imposes no requirement that a pardon be made public, filed, or disclosed at any time, including before the President leaves office. Although a federal law, the Presidential Records Act, does require that all presidential decisions be adequately documented and that those records be filed with the National Archives when the President leaves office the law is relatively toothless and does not include a process for enforcing it.
More importantly, the failure to keep a pardon on file under a law passed by Congress could not supplant the President's authority under the Constitution. As the Supreme Court has held, a presidential pardon is a defense to a federal prosecution that takes legal effect if someone under indictment presents it to the court in response to the charges. We saw with the dismissal of former Trump National Security Adviser Michael Flynn's prosecution earlier this month that all that is necessary to nullify criminal charges is that the pardon have been genuinely issued by the president, cover the crime or crimes at issue, and have been accepted by the recipient.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/opinion-how-trump-s-pardons-could-get-even-more-bizarre/ar-BB1cbvaB?li=BBnbfcQ&ocid=DELLDHP
Swede
(33,234 posts)Fiendish Thingy
(15,585 posts)The pardon would become public once an indictment is filed, as the defendant would have to assert that the pardon was cause for dismissal of charges.
Criminal charges would be dismissed, however, civil liabilities, including fines and asset seizure would remain.