The FBI Just Admitted It Bought US Location Data
https://www.wired.com/story/fbi-purchase-location-data-wray-senate/
The FBI Just Admitted It Bought US Location Data
Rather than obtaining a warrant, the bureau purchased sensitive dataa controversial practice that privacy advocates say is deeply problematic.
Dell Cameron
MAR 8, 2023 2:45 PM
THE UNITED STATES Federal Bureau of Investigation has acknowledged for the first time that it purchased US location data rather than obtaining a warrant. While the practice of buying peoples location data has grown increasingly common since the US Supreme Court reined in the governments ability to warrantlessly track Americans phones nearly five years ago, the FBI had not previously revealed ever making such purchases.
The disclosure came today during a US Senate hearing on global threats attended by five of the nations intelligence chiefs. Senator Ron Wyden, an Oregon Democrat, put the question of the bureaus use of commercial data to its director, Christopher Wray: Does the FBI purchase US phone-geolocation information? Wray said his agency was not currently doing so, but he acknowledged that it had in the past. He also limited his response to data companies gathered specifically for advertising purposes.
To my knowledge, we do not currently purchase commercial database information that includes location data derived from internet advertising, Wray said. I understand that we previouslyas in the pastpurchased some such information for a specific national security pilot project. But thats not been active for some time. He added that the bureau now relies on a court-authorized process to obtain location data from companies.
Its not immediately clear whether Wray was referring to a warrantthat is, an order signed by a judge who is reasonably convinced that a crime has occurredor another legal device. Nor did Wray indicate what motivated the FBI to end the practice.
In its landmark Carpenter v. United States decision, the Supreme Court held that government agencies accessing historical location data without a warrant were violating the Fourth Amendments guarantee against unreasonable searches. But the ruling was narrowly construed. Privacy advocates say the decision left open a glaring loophole that allows the government to simply purchase whatever it cannot otherwise legally obtain. US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) and the Defense Intelligence Agency are among the list of federal agencies known to have taken advantage of this loophole.
[...]