The DU Lounge
Related: Culture Forums, Support ForumsThis subgenre called 'cozy murders'--Isn't this a rather bizarre concept?
Srkdqltr
(6,256 posts)The way I understand there is no gore, sex, language , usually police are rejected.
PoindexterOglethorpe
(25,839 posts)It's mostly and English thing.
The word cozy is simply being used rather differently from what you're used to.
Mopar151
(9,977 posts)April is the cruelest month, sez TS Elliot (IIRC).Beware The Ides Of March! especially if there is an employer in your life.... It's also when a lot of "hardship exemptions" to eviction, foreclosure, utilities cutoff happen.
No rest for the wealthy, either. Keeping the estate up to standards, and Taxes Death Match season, keep all the strivers awake at night.
Polly Hennessey
(6,793 posts)They are my just before turning out the lights enjoyment. Am reading Blackberry Pie Murders by Joanne Fluke now. Delicious! My daytime reads are: Sepulchral by Kate Mosse and re-reading Beowulf (great fun and Grendels mother is a hoot).
The Velveteen Ocelot
(115,658 posts)who regularly discover bodies and/or cleverly solve the crime before the local bumbling police constable can do it. "Father Brown" is one of those shows on PBS - he's the town priest who usually either finds the neatly dead but unmangled body (the murder rate in his bucolic little town is amazing, but they are usually committed tidily with minimum blood) or is involved somehow with the deceased, and the cop is an idiot who is always wrong about whodunit, while Father Brown follows the clues and solves the murder. "Midsomer Murders" is another one, although in that one the cops are the heroes, and the murders tend to be a little more violent and bizarre than is typical. The murder rate in this area is also quite remarkable, probably worse than Detroit, per capita.
There are also many series of books following the same basic pattern: the "detective," often a woman who runs a bookstore or a bakery or an art studio (and she's beautiful but lonely, so there's that angle) stumbles upon a corpse; the police are stupid and ignore her, except for the handsome one, and with the help of her cat she solves the crime. These usually take place in small towns in New England.
I prefer the dark, brooding Scandinavian crime stories but I guess there's a market for this formula.
Wounded Bear
(58,620 posts)You wonder how there is anybody left alive to kill in those small villages sometimes.
Coventina
(27,089 posts)I've found it a little funny myself, as a name.
As a genre, they can be really fun if well done.
A beautiful, small town setting, with an unsettling underbelly that spurs the crime.
The protagonist is usually female, but can be of any age. Romance is often a sub-plot.
There's a lot of poorly done "by the numbers" stuff in there, but the good ones are quite enjoyable.
An even shorter nickname for the genre is just "Cozy".
Shrike47
(6,913 posts)Of course, they are totally unrealistic but have a little intrigue in a light, non-threatening way. They arent intellectually challenging but when well written, enjoyable. Try Murder with Peacocks, by Donna Andrews. Its a hoot.
Hers are fun. If you need escape and light they fit. Janet Evanovich's are funny too. Don't read hers in public. LOL.
Little Star
(17,055 posts)rampartc
(5,400 posts)she has every "murder she wrote" book and dvd, and is always reading the "murder she baked" books and anything where a cat is the detective.
i guess it is better than the romance novels.
smirkymonkey
(63,221 posts)I have never really heard of the genre before, but I am assuming that it is something along those lines. I do find the settings and communities rather "cozy".
tanyev
(42,541 posts)Its not so bad when you read the first one, but most of them are a series of books. How cozy can it be when murders keep happening in an adorable small town? Why cant they sometimes be about Farmer Jims missing cow or finding the con man who tricked Widow Brown into giving him a couple thousand dollars?
Codeine
(25,586 posts)but now theyre just more deliberately crafted to appeal to a very trope-specific genre market. If you think about it, the Miss Marple books were cozies.
Take that Marple aesthetic and boil it down to a few very identifiable key elements, then massage them like a Top 40 record producer churning out trash pop and youve got the cozy mystery phenomenon.
Same thing happened a decade ago with Scandinavian crime fiction; a few great examples became popular and the paint-by-numbers crowd followed up with heaps of dreck.