The DU Lounge
Related: Culture Forums, Support ForumsInformal poll: Do you still listen to vinyl records?
Im getting an album ready to go to print for my studio partner and we are thinking of doing a run of vinyl lp records in addition to the CDs and digital downloads. Just trying to get a rough idea of how many we should print vs CDs
Thanks!
Edit to add: each record will come with a digital download card so the album can also be downloaded in digital format also
hlthe2b
(102,138 posts)He has both the equipment and the collection (as well as the ability to really "restore" vinyl) to make it a real pleasure. I DO appreciate the difference between quality LPs on a great system and even the "best" digital alternative. If money were no object, I'd likely go that route too.
So, yes, I imagine if you have a group of fans that are particular audiophiles, pressing a few LPs might boost your popularity.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)when you say "restore" do you mean an elaborate record cleaning system or transferring to digital and cleaning it up with software?
hlthe2b
(102,138 posts)though he has equally good digital equipment-- I know he prefers vinyl and plays it almost exclusively.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)I've got a lot of good old vinyl that just needs a good cleaning after being around for 30-40 years
Brickbat
(19,339 posts)Many people are rediscovering vinyl. All the hip kids are doing it.
I love a good audiophile system,thanks for the response
Scuba
(53,475 posts)... my ears aren't discerning enough to care about vinyl over digital, but I've got thousands of LP's.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)Thanks for the response
What are your favorite genres?
Scuba
(53,475 posts)Taj Mahal to Jimi Hendrix, David Bromberg to Miles Davis.
Joni Mitchell to Ellen McIlwaine, lots of Clapton, BB King, Stevie Ray, Nighthawks, Count Basie, Ella, the Dead, Stones, Airplane, New Riders and on and on. Can't forget Hot Tuna or Les McCann.
When I'm home alone, the place rocks.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)We just happen to have Tulsa legend Chuck Blackwell playing drums on this record. He played on Taj's Natch'l Blues album in '68. He also played on Freddie King's Texas Cannonball album, played percussion on Joe Coker's Mad Dogs and Englishmen, Leon Russell's Shelter People and Carney albums.... gawd only knows how many records he's on. He's 71 now and still pops a fat backbeat as well as he ever did
Scuba
(53,475 posts)... now I've just gotta find a tab for "Cakewalk into Town".
HopeHoops
(47,675 posts)guitar man
(15,996 posts)Great big video discs
HopeHoops
(47,675 posts)OriginalGeek
(12,132 posts)that is only because I don't have a good place to do it right now. We have lived in our house for 25+ years and seem to have accumulated an extra room full of stuff but have not accumulated an extra room. But sometime in the next couple years we are moving to a bigger house and I will have a place to set up my good ol' record player.
I've noticed a boom in vinyl recently and I plan to begin collecting new records to go with my decent sized old collection - again, when I have the space lol. I often see vinyl for sale at shows in smaller clubs and since I'm at those shows it's usually vinyl I want and most of my online music retailers (or band's individual sites) offer vinyl selections too. A lot of the bands I like release special edition vinyl with cool art and other goodies (alternate versions of and/or different songs, booklets, etc...) and I am all for that - especially when I can buy right from them.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)I've vowed to haul a bunch of stuff off but haven't done it yet
Kali
(55,004 posts)mostly because I'm lazy and have a pretty good community radio station, but also due to my invisible budget
guitar man
(15,996 posts)I think I'm going to be bankrupt by the time we get this record to market
progressoid
(49,951 posts)I listen to more music in the car than at home so the new music is in digital form.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)Each lp will come with a digital download card so the album can also be downloaded at no additional cost
The Velveteen Ocelot
(115,608 posts)I'd like to get some of them converted to CDs. Most date from the '60s and early '70s.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)There is a good range of new turntables that are being produced with usb outputs on them so you can take vinyl straight into your computer. The playback quality is dubious on some of the cheapest ones but some of the ones a step or two up from the bottom don't sound too terrible.
Tikki
(14,549 posts)Is there any way you can stamp sequence each album cover?...kinda cool.
As we post, I am listening to my vinyl:
Joe South.."INTROSPECT"
circa '68
Tikki
guitar man
(15,996 posts)I love Joe South
I'm thinking you're probably about right on the number to have pressed. I'm not expecting to make any money on the LPs, I'd just like to cover the cost of them if we can. We have some legendary studio musicians playing on it so we thought it would be nice to have some LPs , they seem to be more collectible than CDs
wakemewhenitsover
(1,595 posts)But your idea of including the digital download card is cool. If I were huge fan of a band that offered something like that, I'd bite. Besides, the vinyl pressings will become collectors' items when you guys become bigger than Jesus.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)Been at this music thing as a performer and recording engineer for about 30 years, still waiting for that big one to hit
But indeed it does make sense, people want the portable and convienent formats in this day and age too, and if they can get something collectible at the same time I think that's a good thing. What I miss most about LPs is the cover art, a square foot of real estate to put it on
wakemewhenitsover
(1,595 posts)The size of CD's reduces cover art to a joke. Here's an article I found interesting about the fate of vinyl in the digital age; you might find it interesting: http://www.boston.com/ae/music/articles/2009/12/13/what_a_collector_loses_and_gains_in_the_age_of_music_downloading/?page=1
The author's into classical, and I'm into rock, but I like what he says about the "physical charisma" of a vinyl album. Great expression. Captures what's missing with CD's.
On the other hand, what I love about CD's is their near indestructibility. I find CD's in thrift stores (see a pattern here?) that are so scratched-up, they look like someone used them for street-hockey pucks; yet, they still play just fine.
Good luck with your latest effort!
guitar man
(15,996 posts)They've been around for 30 years as a commercial audio medium and there are reasons for that, one of which you mentioned above. Manufactured CDs can take a lot of abuse and keep playing pretty reliably. CDRs not as much but that's a different animal.
A well recorded, mixed and mastered CD delivers pretty good audio quality IMO. I think a lot of the bad rap CDs get from some quarters is not as much a weakness in the media itself, but what's been done to it for the sake of making the music on it "louder". The "loudness war" as some call it has produces some CDs that sound really harsh, grating and just generally bad because they've been hit so hard with compression and limiting to drive up the volume that there's nothing left but shredded bits. each record label wants their kids to be the loudest on the block so they pound the mastering engineers until they get what they want . Metallica's "Death Magnetic" is often touted to be the loudest cd produced to date and as a result, it sounds like shit
These practices have driven modern CDs so far above proper gain staging it's just ridiculous. That's not the case with vinyl records. A record can only be driven so loud before the needle will jump out of the groove ajnd go skipping across the record. That being the case, LPs aren't mastered for just sheer loudness like many CDs and of late have been a welcome relief to my ears
wakemewhenitsover
(1,595 posts)Actually, I'm happy with the sound quality of most CD's. Perhaps my equipment is not fine enough to pick some of the problems you mention (plus, I own no Metallica... loudest CD... funny claim!), but I have trouble distinguishing between most CD's and vinyl (aside from the occasional pop on some of my old albums).
Fascinating stuff about the loudness war!
guitar man
(15,996 posts)They might not be mastered as loud as a lot of this later stuff is...gives me a headache to listen to some of it.
Here's a link to the wiki article
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudness_war
Brother Buzz
(36,384 posts)My resident computer whiz transferred most of my vinyl to MP3. I seem to visit my vinyl collection less and less frequently, and then just to find an obscure track that didn't make the leap into the twenty-first century. My three turntables are growing old, two have arthritis and are slow starters in cold weather.
That being said, we still love to spin the vinyl on a Saturday morning. Playing Louis Jordan, with biscuits in the oven, is as close to heaven as I choose to get.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)I've got 3 turntables... the direct drive is running fine but the other two have broken belts I haven't gotten around to replacing yet.
thanks for the response
pintobean
(18,101 posts)a receiver and a pair of speakers out of my basement and hooked them up in my living room, two weeks ago. It's been well over a decade since I've used them. My 22 yo daughter has been going through my LPs and wanted to be able to play them. We've both been enjoying it.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)Hearing it on the records after not hearing one for a long time is pretty cool I think
grasswire
(50,130 posts)I've been looking for a console stereo for a few years -- one of those old models from the 60s with beautiful wood, ya know. What happened to them all? There aren't even very many at estate sales. I have a LOT of LPs in storage that I miss hearing.
In regard to your particular situation, I can say that here in the PNW, vinyl is very hot with the hipsters. It's a growth scene, definitely.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)from time to time. I love those old consoles, awesome furniture, I wish I had room for one. I think a lot of them finally wore out and wound up in the city dumps rather than being refurbished...it's really a shame
pintobean
(18,101 posts)quite often. I've been keeping an eye out for one of these.
grasswire
(50,130 posts)What's the brand on that?
pintobean
(18,101 posts)It sounded pretty good and was fairly portable. Ours didn't have a tuner, though. The platter and arm are still in my mom's basement; that's all that's left. My younger brothers were rather brutal to nice things. Seeing it makes me think of what once was.
LynneSin
(95,337 posts)Last purchase was The Beastie Boys 'Hot Sauce Committee Part 2' and a WXPN album (because it also came with a code for digital download of the album too).
guitar man
(15,996 posts)I think it's great that people are still buying vinyl even if it is only a small fraction of the market, it's like keeping a tradition alive.
We got kinda revved up about doing vinyl since the guy playing bass for us on this record as well as producing it for us is the bass player for Shooter Jennings and the .357s. Shooter released most of his stuff on vinyl too, and a lot of the other cool kids like the Drive By Truckers and North Mississippi Allstars are all still making vinyl records so we want to join the party
barbtries
(28,769 posts)and i have the stereo with the turntable, but i haven't listened to it in years. when we moved to NC i put it in storage and didn't get it back for two years, it's in my place now and still in the bubble wrap.
bif
(22,685 posts)I'd probably listen to them if one of my turntables was hooked up. I met a younger music buff who only buys lps. Both new and used. If it's not on lp, then she doesn't buy it--i.e. no cds in her collection.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)good to hear the young people are rediscovering vinyl
hunter
(38,303 posts)... a 1960's school model.
It's got a 100% time period authentic sound, especially accompanying film strips or with old music classroom 78's, which is why I love it.
But you might not want me to play your beautiful vinyl on it. I've got a fairly nice turntable stashed away in my garage somewhere, but I haven't set it up for a long time. I made digital copies of my old vinyl or bought the CD versions a long time ago.
I might buy vinyl just for the cover art, even if I only played the digital version and left the vinyl alone. The saddest thing about digital music of any kind is the loss of large format album art. It just isn't the same on a CD or an iPod.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)The cover art is a big part of what makes the lp so collectible IMO. And having the digital download card is a great option for a collector who wants to keep the record in unplayed condition but still wants to listen to the music. It's win-win in my book
Swede
(33,208 posts)His crapped out.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)passing it down to the next generation
hifiguy
(33,688 posts)I have more than 5000 LPs and have written about high-end home audio, in magazines and now on the web, for 15 years. Vinyl rules!
guitar man
(15,996 posts)I've been wanting to ask your opinion of the vinyl versions of a couple albums, if you've heard them that is. One is Primus, Pork Soda and the other Alanis Morrisette's Jagged little pill.
hifiguy
(33,688 posts)and slightly preferred the vinyl to the CD. Not one of those "Holy crap, so this is what it really sounds like" experiences on hearing the LP after hearing the CD.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)The reason I was asking is, Pork Soda was recorded on ADAT tape, 16 bit digital, which was the first digital multitrack format I had before getting my 24bit HD24 hard disk recorder. Since we are about to print a digitally recorded album to vinyl ourselves I was just curious about how those sounded since I haven't been able to find an affordable copy of either to listen to.
sakabatou
(42,136 posts)guitar man
(15,996 posts)JK, thanks for the response
Rochester
(838 posts)skypilot
(8,851 posts)We don't have many large music stores left here in Philadelphia so I'm not able to go out and buy the CD version of all the vinyl stuff I have. I probably wouldn't want to even if that were more of an option. There are just certain things that I own on vinyl that I prefer to listen to that way--old Stevie Wonder and Earth, Wind and Fire for example.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)Funny you mention EWF, I just found a very good condition LP of "That's The Way of The World" at the flea mkt last weekend for the grand sum of $1.
skypilot
(8,851 posts)I have never listened to that on anything except vinyl. I used to play that album over and over and over again when I was a kid, playing one side and then the other and then flipping it over again. Can't see myself just popping it into a CD player or a computer now. I think I'm going to own a vinyl copy til the day I die.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)And it sounds really good, mainly because it's a stellar recording engineered by George Massenburg. I had it for years on reel to reel tape. When I was a youngster we had this awful music pirating scheme where when one of us would get a new record the others would download it from them via analog tape recorder. It was like Napster 0.1
My friend brought it by and I slapped it on my Sansui SR-929 turntable and rolled it off to my Teac 2340 onto Ampex 456 at 3 3/4 ips. Good times
The 929 finally gave up the ghost several years ago and I've been trying to find another one that I don't have to hock my house to buy. But I did find a 2340 at a pawn shop a couple years ago... $60 cash
6000eliot
(5,643 posts)and there is very little surface noise, even after 37 years!
trackfan
(3,650 posts)guitar man
(15,996 posts)well cared for vinyl on a quality turntable with a good stylus delivers every time. Thanks for the response
unionworks
(3,574 posts)If you listen CAREFULLY at the beginning of this bitchin' tribute to Lightfoots "Sundown", you will hear the sound of a needle tonearm dropping onto a vinyl record. I can think of no finer salute to this classic song of the Great Lakes. And only the old heads will get this, I think... Erie Pa. is known for it's glorious "Sundowns"...
guitar man
(15,996 posts)I'm listening on a set of EV Sentry 100a Studio Monitors driven by a Crown D-75a power amp so the needle drop was right up there
thanks for posting this
unionworks
(3,574 posts)Keep on rockin'!!!
pacalo
(24,721 posts)I have to laugh because I do have some "skips"!
What type of music do you perform & do you have any samples online?
guitar man
(15,996 posts)Some call it alt.country some call it Americana.... Shooter Jennings is working on creating a sub-genre for it called "xxx" (after the old xxx symbol on the little brown whisky jugs etc.). Basically it's country-southern-rockish stuff that doesn't fit the Nashville mainstream music machine.
Here's a song we cut during the sessions we did back in May that wound up on a various artist download compilation called "Southern Independent Vol. III" that Shooter is promoting on his record label to try and help us indy artists and labels out. The writer ,singer, bass player on this is Ted Russell Kamp, who in addition to being a great solo artist is also the bass player for Shooter Jennings and the .357s.
He's a good friend of ours
This is called "Another Love Song"
Ted calls his particular flavor "California Country Rock"
http://soundcloud.com/gtrman4931/05-another-love-song
unionworks
(3,574 posts).... thanks and I want to tell you that tune hit the spot!
As most of you know, vinyl records are more than just a bygone media. They are the living, breathing history of an America that I'm afraid is gone forever. It is an art form deserving of respect and perhaps even a certain reverence.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)There were a few great records made in the UK too
I never get into the "which format is best" argument because ultimately that comes down to the choice made by the end user. The format that is "best" is the one that does what the user wants it to do. I've got a cd player in my car, an ipod on my phone and several fornmats including lp in the house. They all have their uses. They all have their strengths and weaknesses. As a recording engineer I've had to embrace digital recording technology as it developed or get tossed aside onto the ashbin of history
But then... in the evening with a drink and relaxing in my chair....nothing like putting on a nice vintage piece of vinyl and relaxing to the grooves
pacalo
(24,721 posts)They were outstanding! I'm very impressed! I'm saving the page to listen to the others. Can't wait to hear "Sultans of Swing".
I wish you the best!
guitar man
(15,996 posts)The "You Don't Know Me At All" cut is of my cover band that I play local clubs with, it's going to be on a demo CD I'm working for us. The Sultans of Swing cut is not a very good recording, I recorded that one inside a club where we were playing with a couple room mics and an old reel to reel 4 track deck.
pacalo
(24,721 posts)guitar man
(15,996 posts)we're just a lil ol bar band but we try do our best.
WCGreen
(45,558 posts)quakerboy
(13,917 posts)when used as frisbees.
Never had a Record player worth getting records for, nor a record worth getting a player for.
unionworks
(3,574 posts)...if you did some checking, and found out you used a 45 or a 33 lp for a frisbee that turned out to be worth thousands on the collectors market. A pjeorative from "that 70's show" comes to mind. It bbegins with a "D"
quakerboy
(13,917 posts)I'm no dummy. When in doubt, check it out. There are a few that are worth dozens, hundreds, or even thousands of dollars.
Most are not.
Particularly not with my families unfortunate musical tastes. But I still check them. Because who knows when that free one they got at the gas station in the 50's somehow became a collectable.
And when they prove to be completely worthless monetarily, as well as musically, then they become Frisbees.
unionworks
(3,574 posts)...narrated by some guy named "Downey" in '69. Worth maybe 5 bucks. It had the actual news reporting of the lunar landing on one side. On the other side was JFKs speech vowing to reach the moon by the end of the decade. To me - priceless. But I get where you're coming from. Awe of the past should not be allowed to stand in the way of tomorrow.
unionworks
(3,574 posts)is... sometimes you will be digging in a stack in some dusty used record store and find something like this, a gem forgotten by time...
amyrose2712
(3,391 posts)Generic Brad
(14,272 posts)I converted my vinyl collection to digital copies. It's kind of cool to listen to music on an iPod and still hear the faint and familiar pops and snaps in the background right where I used to hear them on my turntable.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)I leave the tonearm moving, needle drop, runout groove noise and everything on them
Generic Brad
(14,272 posts)It's great to hear my old record collection 35 years later and it sounds the same as when I used to listen to it on my old stereo.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)I record the records in at 24 bit uncompressed then take them down to 16 bit for CD, but I save a 24 bit version of each and put them on data DVDs. That way I can load them up into Logic on one of my macs and listen to them in a really high quality digital format. You can close your eyes and you'd almost swear it's on the turntable....almost
Arugula Latte
(50,566 posts)To be honest, the minimalist/de-clutterer in me loves digital downloads. No messy CDs or records or cassette tapes or 8-tracks to store! Yeah, I'm not a purist.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)thanks for responding, that's the kind of info I'm looking for
shanti
(21,675 posts)guitar man
(15,996 posts)you might be surprised , they may be in better condition than you think
kwassa
(23,340 posts)I still have all my records from the late 60s onwards ..... scratched, worn, well-used. I still have a stereo with a turntable. I listen to vinyl once or twice a year.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)That little piece of slow moving 1/8' tape sure had a good long run, it was our generation's portable music format
JCMach1
(27,553 posts)Did I mention it still works great?
guitar man
(15,996 posts)My favorite of the 3 I own right now is a Fisher Studio Standard MT-6224 direct drive with strobe speed lock on it...still sounds awesome
unionworks
(3,574 posts)...is to own a VOM professional grade turntable. I onnce had a stereo console display model (stereophonic high fidelity) that was made in 1958. The friggin' needle cartridge was make of fuggin' BRASS! I used to listen to Stills "Manassus" and Leon Russel's Asylum Choir, and Karen Carpenter and Jefferson Airplane singles, and ...sob...choke....
unionworks
(3,574 posts)Above described '58 stereo was VOM. Made in Benton Harbor, Michigan, USA. For years other manufacturers used VOM turntables in their stereos under their name, such as Magnavox, Zenith, etc.. I lost this rare '58set in an eviction late 2000 something, but got to enjoy it. I presently own a 1966 Zenith portable turntable so cherry it still has the instruction paper on the turntable, and the brass protector over the needle - never been played! The first vinyl played on it will be Stones "Paint It Black". And yes, it is a VOA turntable in a Zenith product.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)I had an old console, a Magnavox if I remember correctly that had one of those turntables in it. Worked like a charm.
My dream would be to own another one of these....Sansui SR929. I had one and played the hell out of it for a long time and it finally crapped out one day. I took it to a "friend" who was supposed to fix it. He had it for months then he moved away without saying a word...don't kmow where it wound up
I know there are turntables on the market that cost tens and hundreds of thousands of dollars but the 929 will always be the king of the turntables to me
GReedDiamond
(5,310 posts)...with our Green Sparkle Frog CD, except, I'm considering putting out (as a promo thing) a 7" 45 RPM vinyl record of the song we have on the CD called, not so coincidentally, "45 RPM." Not sure what the B side would be...?
Anyway, a direct answer to your question: yes, I still listen to vinyl, but I cannot say I listen to vinyl being originally produced today. When I buy a vinyl record, it is an old one, and I'm usually replacing a copy of something that got lost or worn out, or maybe a rare piece of vinyl not otherwise available on CD.
ON EDIT: Don't know what your numbers are on the CD vs Vinyl (quantities being pressed), but I'd probably limit the vinyl version to a quarter of the CD.
In my case, the % will be less than that - if I do the "45 RPM" 45 rpm 7 incher, it's going to be literally 200 copies or less, and it'll be used to promote the CD to whatever mailing list that ends up going to.
Hey, I recently read a thing about how Cassettes are making a comeback!
guitar man
(15,996 posts)45 rpm records are a time honored tradition .
Or you could really mess with people and cut the "45 rpm" song at 33
We are still in the process of crunching the numbers on how many to produce. I can tell you this much, it's not cheap to do. The one thing you don't want to do is skimp on the mastering job, it'll sound like shit if you do.
I'm thinking we will wind up with around a 10:1 ratio of CDs vs lps. I could be way off though lol
dimbear
(6,271 posts)JCMach1
(27,553 posts)Ziggy Stardust on vinyl...
Blondie, Parallel Lines
I even have some of the specially pressed Super Discs...
Peter Gabriel's first solo album...
Roger Waters, The Pro's and Con's of Hitchhiking...
My original Beatle's vinyl.
Even some of my symphonic recordings...
Sigh...
Digital is not always better... with the exception of portability... my vinyl and turntable sit in my home back in America.
guitar man
(15,996 posts)It just doesnt sound right without Bernie Grundman's brilliant vinyl mastering job. It's like a sundae without the cherry on top ...