Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Miles Archer

(18,837 posts)
Fri Jan 3, 2014, 06:10 PM Jan 2014

Rolling Stone poll: "What Is the Best Double LP of All Time?"

I'm torn between "The White Album" and "Exile On Main Street."

What Is the Best Double LP of All Time?
Cast your vote in our weekly poll



http://www.rollingstone.com/music/news/what-is-the-best-double-lp-of-all-time-20140103

Pop acts have been releasing double albums since Bob Dylan's Blonde on Blonde in 1966. There have been countless classics since then, from The White Album by the Beatles all the way to Reflektor by Arcade Fire.

So we have a question for you: What is your favorite double album? We're going to count anything that was originally released on two vinyl records or two CDs. (Some releases, like London Calling and Exile on Main Street were two records, but fit onto a single CD. Those will obviously count.) There's a ton to pick from, including Pink Floyd's The Wall, Genesis' The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway and OutKast's Speakerboxxx/The Love Below.

You can vote in the comments section below, on facebook.com/rollingstone or on Twitter using the hashtag #weekend rock.
69 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Rolling Stone poll: "What Is the Best Double LP of All Time?" (Original Post) Miles Archer Jan 2014 OP
Bob Seger & the Silver Bullet Band Live Bullet Kaleva Jan 2014 #1
+1, nt. LumosMaxima Jan 2014 #2
'White Album,' 'Blonde on Blonde,' 'Exile,' 'London Calling,' 'Live/Dead,' 'Live Rust' (Neil Young), nomorenomore08 Jan 2014 #3
The White Album Mr.Bill Jan 2014 #13
Out of my list I'd probably go with either 'Blonde' or 'Exile' because they're both such towering nomorenomore08 Jan 2014 #15
They're all good picks. Mr.Bill Jan 2014 #17
IIRC they were pretty much recording all their individual parts in separate rooms by that point. nomorenomore08 Jan 2014 #18
And Ringo Starr's... whatever Art_from_Ark Jan 2014 #23
Electric Ladyland aint_no_life_nowhere Jan 2014 #4
Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness- Smashing Pumpkins Gravitycollapse Jan 2014 #5
Also, Refklektor has been out for a couple months. You can't call it a classic so soon. Gravitycollapse Jan 2014 #6
The Allman Brothers: Eat A Peach bluesbassman Jan 2014 #7
Forgot about the Allmans! Need to pick up the 'Fillmore East' one now that I have a turntable. nomorenomore08 Jan 2014 #19
The Who- "Quadrophenia" Doc_Technical Jan 2014 #8
Yes!! The Who really rock ailsagirl Jan 2014 #10
I'd go with the expanded 'Live at Leeds' or 'Live at the Isle of Wight' (both double CD's) myself. nomorenomore08 Jan 2014 #20
"Live at Leeds" is phenomenal ailsagirl Jan 2014 #39
'Tommy' kicks so much more ass live that it's not even funny. nomorenomore08 Jan 2014 #40
It's so true ailsagirl Jan 2014 #44
That was the first dbl album I ever bought. progressoid Jan 2014 #62
Loved "Blonde on Blonde" ailsagirl Jan 2014 #9
Probably the first album that ever made me think of rock'n'roll as high art. nomorenomore08 Jan 2014 #41
Exile on Main Street kwassa Jan 2014 #11
My first pick as well!!! pink-o Jan 2014 #55
I remember interviews with Jagger right before this was released Miles Archer Jan 2014 #61
I also liked Beggars Banquet a lot ... sort of a lead in to all that. kwassa Jan 2014 #66
Cream Wheels of Fire. Mr.Bill Jan 2014 #12
Second that! n/t DFW Jan 2014 #14
'Wheels of Fire' and Floyd's 'Ummagumma' would both be fantastic as standalone live albums. nomorenomore08 Jan 2014 #16
The Nick Mason portion Joe Shlabotnik Jan 2014 #53
Goodbye, Yellow Brick Road... regnaD kciN Jan 2014 #21
Mellon Collie civillawyer Jan 2014 #22
Diehard fan of pipi_k Jan 2014 #24
I favored "How The West Was Won" over that one Miles Archer Jan 2014 #35
I dig Zep in general, but some of their live stuff could be downright painful. 10-minute drum solos nomorenomore08 Jan 2014 #42
Yes-- that babybabybaby gets old n/t ailsagirl Jan 2014 #45
Physical Graffiti KG Jan 2014 #25
I at least like and for some, love, every record mentioned so far OriginalGeek Jan 2014 #38
On Your Feet or on Your Knees KG Jan 2014 #26
Jeff Wayne's 'War of the Worlds' SeattleVet Jan 2014 #27
I have to give a mention to Sky Moves Sideways by Porcupine Tree Bjorn Against Jan 2014 #28
I'm torn between 'Electric Ladyland' and 'Physical Graffiti' pokerfan Jan 2014 #29
We Sold Our Souls For Rock 'n' Roll. Iggo Jan 2014 #30
Humble Pie - "Rockin' the Fillmore" ksoze Jan 2014 #31
Love that one front to back, but what gets me is... Miles Archer Jan 2014 #37
The two Ray Charles covers ("I Don't Need No Doctor" and "Hallelujah I Love Her So") nomorenomore08 Jan 2014 #43
Neil Young Live Rust... lame54 Jan 2014 #32
Have you heard Greendale or the Greendale live? hibbing Jan 2014 #49
The movie's great lame54 Jan 2014 #54
The White Album or the Minutemen's Double Nickels on the Dime: boguspotus Jan 2014 #33
I can't decide...too many good ones (most of the ones I like have been mentioned). Here's one more: Captain Stern Jan 2014 #34
Best concept album too! 7wo7rees Jan 2014 #36
Johnny Winter - Second Winter HarveyDarkey Jan 2014 #46
I also loved "Alchemy" by Dire Straits ailsagirl Jan 2014 #47
"Songs in the Key of Life" Enrique Jan 2014 #48
I saw a couple I totally agree with..Goodbye Yellow Brick Road and Framptom nirvana555 Jan 2014 #50
"Kiss Alive"! Just kidding...it's "Bitches Brew" Tom Ripley Jan 2014 #51
Hendrix's Electric Ladyland is my favorite, Joe Shlabotnik Jan 2014 #52
"Electric Ladyland" really builds a case against the posthumous Hendrix albums. Miles Archer Jan 2014 #60
Genesis - "The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway" ksoze Jan 2014 #56
The River - Bruce Springsteen... nuff said. nt justiceischeap Jan 2014 #57
Living in the Past opiate69 Jan 2014 #58
"Frampton Comes Alive" Jokerman Jan 2014 #59
Toss-up between "The White Album" and "Fillmore East." Paladin Jan 2014 #63
You're all wrong! It's Metal Machine Music!!! malthaussen Jan 2014 #64
Bob Dylan and The Band. bluedigger Jan 2014 #65
Antal Dorati and the Minneapolis Symphony Orchestra Sognefjord Jan 2014 #67
Blonde on Blonde. retread Jan 2014 #68
The poll results: Miles Archer Jan 2014 #69

nomorenomore08

(13,324 posts)
3. 'White Album,' 'Blonde on Blonde,' 'Exile,' 'London Calling,' 'Live/Dead,' 'Live Rust' (Neil Young),
Fri Jan 3, 2014, 09:40 PM
Jan 2014

'Made in Japan' (Deep Purple), Derek and the Dominos 'In Concert'...

Overrated (but has some great tunes nonetheless): 'Physical Graffiti.'

Mr.Bill

(24,263 posts)
13. The White Album
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 12:39 AM
Jan 2014

is my "if I was stranded on a desert island with only one album" pick. That's because it contains such a wide variety of music. Kick-ass rock, ballads, love songs, art music, etc.

nomorenomore08

(13,324 posts)
15. Out of my list I'd probably go with either 'Blonde' or 'Exile' because they're both such towering
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 12:55 AM
Jan 2014

works of art, as far as pop music goes anyway. But as you said, the 'White Album''s sheer diversity is a good argument for it.

Mr.Bill

(24,263 posts)
17. They're all good picks.
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 12:59 AM
Jan 2014

The White Album is really a lot of solo work from individual Beatles, with some great guest musicians added. Ironically, the actual name of the album is The Beatles.

nomorenomore08

(13,324 posts)
18. IIRC they were pretty much recording all their individual parts in separate rooms by that point.
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 01:12 AM
Jan 2014

And you really can see the emergence on that album of a more individual style for each member - Lennon's stark anger and emotional ballads, McCartney's whimsy and occasional silliness, Harrison's almost instinctive ear for a great pop tune.

Art_from_Ark

(27,247 posts)
23. And Ringo Starr's... whatever
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 04:23 AM
Jan 2014

"I'm sorry that I doubted you
I was so unfair
You were in a car crash
And you lost your hair..."

Gravitycollapse

(8,155 posts)
6. Also, Refklektor has been out for a couple months. You can't call it a classic so soon.
Fri Jan 3, 2014, 11:09 PM
Jan 2014

Especially since it's arguably not as good as their previous work. While it is great, I think The Suburbs and Neon Bible are unquestionably superior.

bluesbassman

(19,366 posts)
7. The Allman Brothers: Eat A Peach
Fri Jan 3, 2014, 11:39 PM
Jan 2014

Even though two of the tunes (Mountain Jam and One Way Out) were leftovers from Live at Fillmore East (which is a contender itself) those tunes and the rest of the studio recordings on Eat A Peach stand the test of time and are still fresh and musically relevant today. Just an outstanding album from an incredible collection of musicians IMO.

nomorenomore08

(13,324 posts)
20. I'd go with the expanded 'Live at Leeds' or 'Live at the Isle of Wight' (both double CD's) myself.
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 01:18 AM
Jan 2014

As great as the Who could be in the studio, I tend to think their real strength was as a live act. Although their early singles ("The Kids are Alright" especially) are arguably some of the greatest songs ever written.

nomorenomore08

(13,324 posts)
40. 'Tommy' kicks so much more ass live that it's not even funny.
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 09:01 PM
Jan 2014

Live versus studio is like night and day.

nomorenomore08

(13,324 posts)
41. Probably the first album that ever made me think of rock'n'roll as high art.
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 09:05 PM
Jan 2014

Or one of the first, along with 'VU and Nico,' and in its own way, Husker Du's 'Zen Arcade.'

Though keep in mind I was getting into all these 20-35 years after their release.

pink-o

(4,056 posts)
55. My first pick as well!!!
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 08:53 AM
Jan 2014

All killer, no filler, as the DJ's used to say in the 70s. Well, maybe I could do without "Happy". But Keith does all right, all things considered!

One thing, though: I know the "Glimmer Twins" produced, and I know Mick has an ego the size of Alaska, so WHY didn't they crank up the vocals? They're mixed down too much for my taste. I used to plug my vinyl record player into a studio mixer and tweak the sound, raising the vocals to a more prominent position (long before Karaoke machines!). It sounded way better.

Not that you can improve that much on perfection!

Miles Archer

(18,837 posts)
61. I remember interviews with Jagger right before this was released
Mon Jan 6, 2014, 11:57 AM
Jan 2014

Something along the lines of "It's a lot to digest, but I think people will find SOMETHING they like on it."

There is a core set of albums...Let It Bleed, Get Yer Ya Yas Out, Sticky Fingers, and Exile...that represent, for me, the Stones at their peak.

By the time of "Goats Head Soup" they were already turning into something else.

By the time of "Only Rock & Roll," they had already turned into the Ron Wood Stones, just waiting for Ron to show up.

kwassa

(23,340 posts)
66. I also liked Beggars Banquet a lot ... sort of a lead in to all that.
Mon Jan 6, 2014, 08:22 PM
Jan 2014

you named the rest of their peak period

Mr.Bill

(24,263 posts)
12. Cream Wheels of Fire.
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 12:36 AM
Jan 2014

great studio stuff on one disk, and possibly the greatest live recording ever on the other disk.

nomorenomore08

(13,324 posts)
16. 'Wheels of Fire' and Floyd's 'Ummagumma' would both be fantastic as standalone live albums.
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 12:56 AM
Jan 2014

Whereas, particularly in the case of 'Ummagumma,' I'm not quite so fond of the studio half.

Joe Shlabotnik

(5,604 posts)
53. The Nick Mason portion
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 03:13 AM
Jan 2014

kind of dragged the album down a bit, but I love the rest of the studio side. As much as I thought Sid Barret was one very cool cat, this album was the coming out party for Floyd.

regnaD kciN

(26,044 posts)
21. Goodbye, Yellow Brick Road...
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 03:35 AM
Jan 2014

...an album that I've even grown to appreciate more over the years. (Originally, I thought it had some great songs but was uneven; now, I can't find a single track I don't love.)

Miles Archer

(18,837 posts)
35. I favored "How The West Was Won" over that one
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 08:12 PM
Jan 2014

Like most Led Zeppelin fans I enjoyed "Song" when it was released, but after "West" came out, I preferred it.



nomorenomore08

(13,324 posts)
42. I dig Zep in general, but some of their live stuff could be downright painful. 10-minute drum solos
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 09:14 PM
Jan 2014

and "babybabybabybaby" ad nauseum.

OriginalGeek

(12,132 posts)
38. I at least like and for some, love, every record mentioned so far
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 08:19 PM
Jan 2014

But PG was my first answer and always will be. I've been a Led Zep fan since first discovered there was something other than church music.

SeattleVet

(5,477 posts)
27. Jeff Wayne's 'War of the Worlds'
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 11:28 AM
Jan 2014

This one still amazes me every time I listen. Always hearing something new buried in there. I have English and German versions, on vinyl and CD, and it's still holds up very well.

Bjorn Against

(12,041 posts)
28. I have to give a mention to Sky Moves Sideways by Porcupine Tree
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 11:35 AM
Jan 2014

I was first going to say The Wall, but while that is a great album it is not Pink Floyd's best album.

Porcupine Tree is a somewhat obscure band, but they are incredibly talented and Sky Moves Sideways is probably my favorite album of theirs. If you like psychadelic rock I highly recommend it, Steven Wilson is one of the most talented artists in music today and he deserves far more recognition than he gets.

Iggo

(47,546 posts)
30. We Sold Our Souls For Rock 'n' Roll.
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 12:18 PM
Jan 2014

Yeah, yeah, yeah...it's a compilation album. But back when you had to carry all your music with you, this was the one we brought, and this was the one we shared.

This is how it happened: "Play something else!" "Whaddaya got?" "I dunno check the box." "Okay...Zep...Zep...Zep...Bon Jovi?!?!?" "Dude! It's my sister's!" "Yeah, whatever...okay, Zep...Zep..Zep...Sold Our Souls!" "Put it on!"

ksoze

(2,068 posts)
31. Humble Pie - "Rockin' the Fillmore"
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 12:40 PM
Jan 2014



Featuring a then relatively unknown 20 year old guitarist named Peter Frampton and some of the the best vocals from Steve Marriottt. The 25 minute complete LP side Dr. John take on "I Walk On Gilded Splinters" is unreal.

Miles Archer

(18,837 posts)
37. Love that one front to back, but what gets me is...
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 08:15 PM
Jan 2014

...the "Leaving Trunk" insert in "Gilded Splinters." My personal opinion is that the single greatest vocal performance of Steve Marriott's career came when he split the sky on the line "I'm going back to Memphis babe, where I'll have much better luck..."

nomorenomore08

(13,324 posts)
43. The two Ray Charles covers ("I Don't Need No Doctor" and "Hallelujah I Love Her So")
Sat Jan 4, 2014, 09:21 PM
Jan 2014

are pretty freakin' sweet. About as good as amped-up R&B ever got post-'68 or so.

hibbing

(10,095 posts)
49. Have you heard Greendale or the Greendale live?
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 01:57 AM
Jan 2014

I like him, but really appreciated him even more after listening to the story presented in Greendale.

Peace

Joe Shlabotnik

(5,604 posts)
52. Hendrix's Electric Ladyland is my favorite,
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 03:05 AM
Jan 2014

followed by Allman Brothers Band Live at the Filmore East, and Pink Floyd's Ummagumma.

Miles Archer

(18,837 posts)
60. "Electric Ladyland" really builds a case against the posthumous Hendrix albums.
Mon Jan 6, 2014, 11:52 AM
Jan 2014

I LOVED the first one...never really cared for "Axis." I always felt that of there was a single Hendrix album that had the greatest influence on Prince, "Axis" had to be it. But "Ladyland" was a MONSTER. I see the first three albums and "Band of Gypsys" as the "official" Hendrix catalog. I've listened to pretty much every other album that followed his passing but NONE of them equal the albums HE had a hand in assembling.

Even "Cry of Love" which turned into "Voodoo Soup" which turned into "First Rays Of The New Rising Sun"...the "4th studio album" he was working on at the time of his death...nice stuff on it, but who KNOWS what the hell THAT one would have sounded like after he had final say?

Paladin

(28,246 posts)
63. Toss-up between "The White Album" and "Fillmore East."
Mon Jan 6, 2014, 12:53 PM
Jan 2014

(Thanks, guys. I didn't want to piss away my 10,000th post in a gun thread....)

malthaussen

(17,183 posts)
64. You're all wrong! It's Metal Machine Music!!!
Mon Jan 6, 2014, 02:17 PM
Jan 2014

Normally, I wouldn't do this, but

Those who know the album, know what I mean.

-- Mal

Miles Archer

(18,837 posts)
69. The poll results:
Wed Jan 8, 2014, 08:12 PM
Jan 2014

10. The Smashing Pumpkins - 'Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness'

9. The Clash - 'London Calling'

8. The Allman Brothers Band - 'At Fillmore East'

7. The Who - 'Quadrophenia'

6. Bob Dylan - 'Blonde on Blonde'

5. Led Zeppelin - 'Physical Graffiti'

4. Bruce Springsteen - 'The River'

3. The Rolling Stones - 'Exile on Main Street'

2. Pink Floyd - 'The Wall'

1. The Beatles - 'The White Album'

http://www.rollingstone.com/music/pictures/readers-poll-the-10-greatest-double-albums-of-all-time-20140108

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Rolling Stone poll: "...