LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Free speech is a fundamental U.Va. value

[mahatmakanejeeves]

Thank you to
@LarrySabato
and the
@UVA
professors who spoke up in support of freedom of speech.

The First Amendment and fostering the marketplace of ideas is the bedrock of a free society.

Link to tweet

Opinion

LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Free speech is a fundamental U.Va. value

The Cavalier Daily should embrace First Amendment freedoms

By Concerned Faculty
April 5, 2022

As faculty members at the University, we are writing to object to The Cavalier Daily’s recent editorial arguing that former vice president Mike Pence is “not entitled to a platform” at the University.

We are not interested in either defending or attacking Pence and whatever he might say. We are more concerned that The Cavalier Daily believes that his speech constitutes “violence” that “threatens the well-being and safety of students on Grounds.” This speech-is-violence argument is not only wrong — no calls for violence will be issued April 12 — but also contradicts the letter and the spirit of the First Amendment, which generally creates space for a wide range of views to be expressed so long as the relevant speech does not incite violence. It is also a disservice to those who are the victims of actual physical violence — whether those injured and killed during the many civil rights struggles in American history, those who fought and died for our constitutional rights as members of our armed services or the brave people of Ukraine who are fighting and dying for their freedoms, including free speech.

Moreover, what saddens us about the mindset of The Cavalier Daily editorial is its assumption that the editors should enjoy the freedom to say what they want but others with whom they disagree should not. The First Amendment protects not just those whose views the editors deem harmless. Those of us who support free speech do so, in part, because, in a democratic society, none of us can see the whole truth and all of us benefit from being exposed to perspectives that may comprehend some aspect of the truth better than we do.

The University’s recent Statement on Free Expression and Free Inquiry put it best — “freedom of speech is among the most powerful tools by which wrongs are righted and institutions are improved or abolished. Principles of free inquiry extend to robust discussion and critical examination of the past. Equally importantly, they live in the present and extend to the future, in a shared commitment to free expression for all speakers and all views.” ... We stand in that commitment to free expression for all speakers and all views, inspired by the University’s founder, Mr. Jefferson, who wrote the following about our institution — “for here we are not afraid to follow truth wherever it may lead, nor to tolerate any error so long as reason is left free to combat it.” We invite the editors of The Cavalier Daily to renew their dedication to this fundamental University value.

Signed,

Monika Abramenko, Engineering

Peter Abramenko, Mathematics

Gerard Alexander, Politics

Colin Bird, Politics

James Ceaser, Politics

Lee Coppock, Economics

Kenneth Elzinga, Economics

Christian Gromoll, Mathematics

Jason Johnston, Law

Julia Mahoney, Law

Paul Mahoney, Law

John Owen, Politics

Larry Sabato, Politics

Allan Stam, Batten

Paul Wagner, Drama

June West, Darden

Brad Wilcox, Sociology

[mahatmakanejeeves]

1. Free speech -- at a cost. Schapiro: Wahoo-ping and hollering at UVA over Pence visit

Schapiro: Wahoo-ping and hollering at UVA over Pence visit | Govt-and-politics | http://richmond.com

Link to tweet

TOP STORY

Free speech — at a cost

Schapiro: Wahoo-ping and hollering at UVA over Pence visit

BY JEFF E. SCHAPIRO Richmond Times-Dispatch Apr 6, 2022

In 1957, as Virginia and the rest of the white South boiled with rage over Black mobilization for civil rights, the famed novelist William Faulkner settled in at the University of Virginia as its first writer-in-residence. Faulkner was delighted to be there, partaking in such diversions as riding to the hounds in the surrounding countryside.

{snip}

“I love Virginians because Virginians are all snobs, and I like snobs,” Faulkner told an all-white audience at the university during a talk in which he said Black Americans, emboldened by legal and legislative advances, had to learn responsibility for freedom — a paternalistic notion that seemed moderate to some Southerners, a betrayal of white supremacy by others.

{snip}

In 2022, Faulkner’s critique of Virginians — it was an effective lampoon because there was a grain of truth to it — might apply to the overwrought controversy at the university over an appearance there next Tuesday by former Vice President Mike Pence. He is scheduled to speak as a guest of the school’s chapter of Young Americans for Freedom, a conservative organization inspired by William F. Buckley that’s had an off-and-on presence at UVA since the 1960s.

In a fresh kerfuffle over free speech at UVA, The Cavalier Daily student newspaper — through its editorial page — is arguing that the university should be closed to Pence because he is hostile to immigrants, gay and trans people. ... Plus, a March 17 editorial said, there is the company Pence keeps: He was No. 2 to President Donald Trump, who said the white supremacists who carried out a deadly siege of Charlottesville over two days in August 2017 were “very fine people.” Trump applied that description as well to the liberal counter-protesters who battled the racist invaders.

{snip}

Contact Jeff E. Schapiro at [phone] or [e-mail]. Follow him on Facebook and on Twitter, @RTDSchapiro. Listen to his analysis 7:45 a.m. and 5:45 p.m. Friday on Radio IQ, 89.7 FM in Richmond and 89.1 FM in Roanoke, and in Norfolk on WHRV, 89.5 FM.