Latin America
Related: About this forumNicaragua a 'Dictatorship' When It Follows US Lead on NGOs
JUNE 16, 2022
JOHN PERRY
President Daniel Ortegas government in Nicaragua is laying waste to civil society, according to the Associated Press (6/2/22). The Guardian (6/2/22) called it a sweeping purge of civil society, while for the New York Times (2/14/22), Nicaragua is inching toward dictatorship. According to the Washington Posts Spanish edition (5/19/22), the country is already a dictatorship laid bare. In a call echoed by the BBC (5/5/22), the UN human rights commissioner urged Nicaragua to stop its damaging crackdown on civil society.
What can possibly have provoked such widespread criticism? It turns out that the Nicaraguan National Assemblys sweeping purge was the withdrawal of the tax-free legal status of a small proportion of the countrys nonprofit organizations: just 440 over a period of four years. In more than half the cases, these non-governmental organizations (NGOs) have simply ceased to function or no longer exist. In other cases, they have failed (or refused) to comply with legal requirements, such as producing annual accounts or declaring the sources of their funding. Modest legal steps that would go unnoticed in most countries arein Nicaraguas caseclear evidence that it is inching toward dictatorship.
None of the media reports asked basic questions, such as what these nonprofits have done that led to the government taking this action, whether other countries follow similar practices, or what international requirements about the regulation of nonprofits Nicaragua is required to comply with. There is a much bigger story here that corporate media ignore. Lets fill in some of the gaps.
Three basic questions
There are three basic questions. First, is Nicaragua exceptional in closing nonprofits on this scale? No, the practice is widespread in other nations. While figures are difficult to find, government agencies in the United States, Britain, Australia and elsewhere have closed tens of thousands of nonprofits in the last few years.
For example, between 2006 and 2011, the IRS closed 279,000 nonprofits out of a US total of 1.7 million; it closed 28,000 more in 2020. The Charity Commission in Britain closes around 4,000 per year. And in Australia, some 10,000 nonprofits have been closed since 2014, one-sixth of the total. In Nicaragua, four years of closures have so far affected only 7% of a total of more than 6,000 nonprofits.
More:
https://fair.org/home/nicaragua-a-dictatorship-when-it-follows-us-lead-on-ngos/
inwiththenew
(972 posts)Get ready to hear a lot more talk like this.
tirebiter
(2,535 posts)Why is abortion illegal in Nicaragua?
David__77
(23,367 posts)Its good to note the variable standards.