Environment & Energy
Related: About this forumAmazon Deforestation In Overdrive Because That's Just How Brazil's Govt. - At Every Level - Wants It
EDIT
This mismatch too few inspectors for too much deforestation is one of a cascading series of shortfalls and failures that are enabling criminals to raze the worlds largest rainforest with impunity. Law enforcement misses the majority of deforestation in the Amazon. The fines that the few state and federal inspectors here write are seldom paid. The occasional cases that spill into the criminal justice system languish for years. And in the rare instance of a criminal conviction, it almost never draws a prison sentence, The Washington Post found in a review of a years worth of cases.
The violent and lawless erasure of the Amazon is perhaps the worlds greatest environmental crime story. Scientists warn that the forest, seen as vital to averting catastrophic global warming, is at a tipping point. But in Brazil, home to about 60 percent of the Amazon, nearly one-fifth has already been destroyed. And virtually no one, law enforcement officials say, has been held accountable. No one goes to jail, said Luciano Evaristo, former chief inspection officer of Ibama, the federal environmental law enforcement agency. For example, in 2016, we took apart a large deforestation ring in the south of Pará state. They deforested 50 square miles. There were 23 arrests. In the end, no ones in jail. And this was the biggest deforestation ring in Brazil.
EDIT
It hadnt always been like this. When Pedralino joined the agency in 2012, the government had seemed on the cusp of eliminating illegal deforestation. Each federal and state environmental agency staffed an inspection force. Pedralino would travel down distant roads, hand out the tickets and be on his way, free of concern for his safety. But that was before the election of Bolsonaro. Before Bolsonaros environmental minister met with gold miners, loggers and land grabbers. Before the number of Ibama inspectors plummeted. Before Acres conservative new governor told accused environmental offenders not to pay fines issued by state inspectors. Before the rise of a politics of grievance that presented deforesters not as criminals, but as honest workers oppressed by authoritarian environmentalists. And before Pedralino realized that this job, a job for which he felt no personal affinity, was putting his life at risk.
He had always considered himself willing to do whatever was necessary to perform his work. But now, when asked to investigate deforestation, all he could see was the violence that might happen. He remembered when dozens of angry ranchers, some of them armed, surrounded his truck in 2013. He thought about the illegal logger who went to get something from his house, and Pedralino was sure it was a gun. He heard his own pleas, begging visiting environmental agents in 2019 not to destroy the logging equipment theyd confiscated because that could trigger retaliation, and he was the one who lived here and would have to suffer the consequences.
EDIT
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/interactive/2022/brazil-amazon-deforestation-enforcement/?itid=sf_climate_article_list