Ruling on Contraception Draws Battle Lines at Catholic Colleges

[alp227]

Bridgette Dunlap, a Fordham University law student, knew that the school’s health plan had to pay for birth control pills, in keeping with New York state law. What she did not find out until she was in an examining room, “in the paper dress,” was that the student health service — in keeping with Roman Catholic tenets — would simply refuse to prescribe them.

As a result, students have had to go to Planned Parenthood or private doctors to get prescriptions. Some, unable to afford the doctor visits, gave up birth control pills entirely. In November, Ms. Dunlap, 31, who was raised a Catholic and was educated at parochial schools, organized a one-day, off-campus clinic staffed by volunteer doctors who wrote prescriptions for dozens of women.

Many Catholic colleges decline to prescribe or cover birth control, citing religious reasons. Now they are under pressure to change. This month the Obama administration, citing the medical case for birth control, made a politically charged decision that the new health care law requires insurance plans at Catholic institutions to cover birth control without co-payments for employees, and that may be extended to students. But Catholic organizations are resisting the rule, saying it would force them to violate their beliefs and finance behavior that betrays Catholic teachings.

“We can’t just lie down and die and let religious freedom go,” said Sister Mary Ann Walsh, a spokeswoman for the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops.

full: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/30/health/policy/law-fuels-contraception-controversy-on-catholic-campuses.html?pagewanted=all

Whose freedom is more important, people's freedom of medical choice or private organizations' right to discriminate? Christian conservatives complain about their tax dollars going to birth control and other things that go against their beliefs. So much that this country manages to have the Hyde Amendment, separation of church and state be damned. Yet I never hear Muslims or Jews complain about subsidies to factory farms given that those farms aren't exactly halal or kosher. Or Buddhists complaining about the defense budget.

[rurallib]

1. they need to empty the pews and collection plates to get the bishops attention

someone should call a boycott some Sunday.
If I know my church they are more about the money than anything.
Instead of the church they could give to Planned Parenthood.

[immoderate]

2. Sex is the only thing they can pretend to control, though.

They could go to the mat for this one.


--imm

[virgogal]

3. The wisest thing would be to attend a college that isn't a Catholic. I

left the church many years ago because of the birth control issue so these kids should go elsewhere.

[liberal_biker]

4. Freedom of choice and religion are just that

One's freedoms. Why should the kids have to go elsewhere or the church change its position to satisfy a government demand?