I find it stunning how many people believe the Oscars are nominated on pure merit

[La Lioness Priyanka]

as though there is a perfect criterion to meet to win the Oscars, instead of a very arbitrary and subjective set of criterion. So many people seem to be making the argument that there are no AA's nominated on the pure basis of merit.

Is it more likely that not a single black actor was talented this year, or more likely that they got overlooked because those who nominate them don't recognize black actors as talented unless they play some very specific roles?

I think the answer to that question reveals something important about oneself, and less about the actual value/talent of people of color.

random thoughts on #OscarSoWhite

[JustAnotherGen]

1. Specific Roles for the complacent who believe it is about 'merit'

For black actresses who win the Oscar

Maid
Slave
Addict


This is precisely what the Leadership in Hollywood thinks of black women - and what they then export around the world.

ETA - be careful if you say this and mention anyone who HAPPENS to be Jewish at the same time. You will get accused of being an anti semite because you are for YOU first - and not some billionaire head of a production company white guy - who HAPPENS to be Jewish.

[emulatorloo]

2. Never has been based solely on merit, probably never will be

Industry insiders patting each other on the back.

[JI7]

3. I'm glad i stopped watching these shows long time ago

Although chris rock was the only reason i had interest this time. And this was even before the nominees were announced.

There are also wayy too many of these award shows

[JustAnotherGen]

4. I'm watching because of Chris Rock

Can we be honest? Anyone whose seen his routine where he talks about Hollywood/Entertainment (several years ago) knows we are going to hear -

Once again I am the ONLY BLACK PERSON HERE!

The quality and extent of discomfort in the audience is going to be pure comedic gold!

[randys1]

5. I wish Chris could have Ricky Gervais come out at some point

and do some shtick with him

Ricky is relentless

[JustAnotherGen]

6. That would be awesome!

[Travis_0004]

7. Chris rock should be good. He does a good job hosting.

I think the Martian will win a few awards. Best movie of the year IMO.

[JustAnotherGen]

8. Kick