Court To Catholic School: No, You Can’t Fire People Because They Are Gay
Matthew Barrett (right) with his husband, Ed Suplee. (CREDIT: Matthew Barrett)
by Zack Ford
Dec 17, 2015 1:49 pm
A Massachusetts court has ruled against a private Catholic school that denied employment to a man because he was married to a man. This warranted unlawful discrimination on the basic of sexual orientation, the court found.
Plaintiff Matthew Barrett had applied for a job at Fontbonne Academy, a Catholic prep school for girls in Milton, Massachusetts, as a Food Services Director. After several interviews, he was offered the job. On his new hire form, Barrett listed his husband as his emergency contact. Two days later, Fontbonne informed him that he could not have the job because his marriage was inconsistent with the teachings of the Catholic Church.
Fontbonne defended the decision, claiming its belief about the definition of marriage had nothing to do with sexual orientation. In fact, the school includes sexual orientation in its own nondiscrimination statement. But Associate Justice Douglas H. Wilkins found this distinction wholly unconvincing. It is no answer to say that Fontbonne denied Barrett employment because he was in a same-sex marriage, not because of his sexual orientation, he wrote. The law recognizes no such distinction.
Massachusetts nondiscrimination laws do include some exemptions for religious institutions, but Fontbonne did not qualify. The exception applies to organizations that limit membership to persons of the same religion or denomination, but as Wilkins pointed out, Fontbonne has no such limitations. It does not require its employees to be Catholic. In particular, the Food Services Director does not have to be Catholic. Moreover, its student body has included non-Catholics, including Muslims, Jews, Baptists, Buddhists, Hindus, and Episcopalians.
http://thinkprogress.org/lgbt/2015/12/17/3733518/massachusetts-catholic-school-anti-gay-discrimination/