An ideology without promise (conservative Michael Gerson, WaPo)
Great article. Old-style republican (the kind with a heart, a brain, that you can talk to) eviscerates today's GOP, most all their candidates and Ayn Rand libertarian "values."
http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/michael-gerson-a-republican-mind-set-without-promise/2012/09/20/798901f8-0344-11e2-91e7-2962c74e7738_story.html
Is such a story really explainable as a failure of personal responsibility? That seems both simplistic and callous. Putnam describes these social conditions as depressingly typical in Americas working class. He measures a number of growing gaps between poorer and more affluent Americans gaps of parental time and investment, of religious and community involvement, of academic achievement that widen a class divide and predict a social mobility crash for millions of Americans.
This crisis has a number of causes, including the collapse of working-class families, the flight of blue-collar jobs and the decay of working-class neighborhoods, which used to offer stronger networks of mentors outside the home. Perverse incentives in some government programs may have contributed to these changes, but this does not mean that shifting incentives can easily undo the damage. Removing a knife from a patient does not automatically return him to health. Whatever the economic and cultural causes, the current problem is dysfunctional institutions, which routinely betray children and young adults. Restoring a semblance of equal opportunity promoting family commitment, educational attainment and economic advancement will take tremendous effort and creative policy.
Yet a Republican ideology pitting the makers against the takers offers nothing. No sympathy for our fellow citizens. No insight into our social challenge. No hope of change. This approach involves a relentless reductionism. Human worth is reduced to economic production. Social problems are reduced to personal vices. Politics is reduced to class warfare on behalf of the upper class.
A few libertarians have wanted this fight ever since they read Atlas Shrugged as pimply adolescents. Given Romneys background, record and faith, I dont believe that he holds this view. I do believe that Republicans often parrot it, because they lack familiarity with other forms of conservatism that include a conception of the common good.