The US middle class is in the top 1% ....
of the world economically.
As liberals, shouldn't we be equally concerned about the other human beings on our planet?
Shouldn't we be willing to share the wealth and the jobs and the industries with other countries and peoples?
We have been very privileged...and like the silver spoon portion of our society, most of that good fortune has been an accident of birth rather than something we have earned.
Trade agreements in spite of their ugly local side effects are good for the worlds populations.
The problem is not disruption due to trade agreements, it's the failure of the social safety net including job training and housing/food assistance.
We shouldn't be trade isolationists any more than we should be political isolationist.
= new reply since forum marked as read
Resistance is futile. the Peon should accept the status quo
suicidal crap
We need to end our global military empire that supports the global corporate elites thumb on the scales, we need to stop killing people across the globe because they were unlucky enough to be sitting on "our" resources
you are supporting the race to the bottom and suggesting that American workers are somehow fucking obligated to compete for wages with people makes pennies on the dollar. Bullshit. Sounds quite republican to me. 
Sound like the New World Order. I don't owe then that. I owe them my bet attempts to end our illegal wars on them and to get our corporations under control and off their backs. I can offer them a hand up but I do not owe them my job.
Seriously?
Here's a very, very basic arithmetic lesson:
If 2 people go from $200 to $120
And 100 people go from $0.80 to $3
Net income has gone up.
This isn't actually very difficult.
Do you actually not understand that?
You are completely ignoring the staggering size of the developing world's growing middle class.
that have been imported to take over American positions.
<I saw that under BS plan my taxes will increase by more than $30K a year.
I can't afford it.
The increase under HRC is 1/10th of that.
And I will reap 5 digit windfalls under Trump.
The BS tax increases are substantial on much more modest incomes.
I've got to believe that numbers like those will cool voters enthusiasm for BS.
I don't watch any television...so I don't know if people realize what he's proposing and how it will impact their lives.
Is it known..and I'm just unaware or is this something the GOP is holding in reserve for the GE?>
Troll Alert!!!!!
They don't give a shit about us here in the US. They have their wealth and privilege and status. They just want to take what is left from us and give it (hahaha!) to some body us in another country. The irony of course is that the only ones that will benefit will be the 1% but not us or those other country's populace.
and the fucking guilt trip you are trying to lay on me and us.
We rebuilt Europe through the Marshall Plan after WWII. We had fair trade under FDR through JFK even until Nixon. Free Trade is a product of neoliberalism and you are falling for the guilt hook line and sinker.
I do not support lowering the standards of living in any country in order to slightly raise it in another. I do not support the shifting of all manufacturing from one nation to another such that the only ones that benefit are the corporate stockholders. I do not appreciate someone attempting to shame me about being the supposed 1% in the world when I will be paying student loan debt until I die, I struggle with medical care and medical costs weekly, and freelance work that I do is often under cut by cheap foreign laborers who will take $5.00 an hour for a job that should be making $25.00 given the amount of work.
There is a ton of research that shows how fucked up Mexico is after NAFTA and corporate manufacturing moved there. It did nothing to raise those communities out of abject poverty and in fact in most cases made it far worse.
Sorry your bullshit is not going to work on us. The only reason you give a shit about other people over there is because you obviously don't have to worry about survival over here. I fucking hate your kind of liberalism. 
with tech support in SE Asia on an eBay issue with a fraudulent buyer.
The guy couldn't really help and given the current financial and health stress I am under, I said to him well it is $37.00. I guess I just have to accept it as a total loss. He sniped quite unprofessionally that that was 3 days work for him. I responded that being medically disabled, struggling to not be evicted this month, and worrying about my own financials stress, yes $37.00 is a big deal for me as well. But your corporate masters don't see it that way and will do nothing to help me recoup that from the fraudulent buyer y'all allowed to rip me off. I am glad y'all record this because that was damn unprofessional to say.
And this is what they want. They want conflict between us at the bottom struggling for every last dime. They are fine up on top. The CEO of eBay doesn't want for shit. He isn't trying to live where this kid was on $37.00 a day. He isn't trying to live here like me struggling for rent and medical costs not covered by my insurance in Phoenix.
But then fuckers like this OP have the balls to come in here and shame me for my circumstance. They try to tell me I am the 1% if I just allow them to fuck me over more then that kid in SE Asia will be middle class. And it is all bullshit. They don't care about me and will continue to fuck me over. They don't care about that kid because eBay is NOT going to pay them more.
So fuck them! I am ready for a bloody revolution at this point.
look up disingenuous, then have a good night.
You clowns need to get some fresh material, this shit was rotted the first time the Corporate Teabaggers tried to run it out several years ago.
Of course we should. And if we don't, nobody will because conservatives certainly are not going to be concerned with poor people anywhere.
Should people with more be willing to share with people who have less? That's a pretty good definition of 'liberal'.
Winning the 'birth lottery' (witness the Donald) says a lot about your prospects in life. If you or I had been born in Bangladesh or Nigeria, our life prospects would be significantly diminished.
I don't know that it is 'trade agreements' themselves. Few of the really poor countries in south Asia or Africa or the rest of the world have trade agreements with Western countries unless you count belonging to the WTO as a 'trade agreement'.
You could make the case that trade, in general, has contributed to the increasing incomes of the worlds poorest 70%. That would not have surprised FDR. Increased global prosperity was one of the reasons he wanted to promote international trade after WWII.
True. That is why progressive countries can trade 2 to 3 times as much as the US and have stronger unions and middle classes than the US has. They provide the safety nets, progressive taxes, business regulation, etc. that FDR provided to the US.
True indeed. Trump and Cruz are classic republican isolationists like Coolidge and Hoover of the pre-FDR era. They love walls and tariffs; they want to break our international agreements; withdraw from international organizations, etc. Basically they are the opposite of what FDR was trying to accomplish.
