Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

uawchild

(2,208 posts)
Sat Nov 5, 2016, 08:44 PM Nov 2016

Black apathy key to Trump's poll success

This is from the Telegraph in Calcutta, India. The writer has a very startling personal impression of Washington, DC that I felt compelled to share it. Pardon the quoted length, he rambled some but made some provocative points through out.


"A few metro rides through downtown Washington and the suburbs of America's national capital are enough to grasp why Donald Trump, the unlikeliest of presidential candidates, now stands a heartbeat away from occupying the White House.

In all the years when suburban Washington was my home and metro rides were my preferred means of commute, I have not seen beggars in the metro system like, say, in Mumbai's local trains. At the height of winters, homeless African Americans buy a metro ticket and spend the entire day on heated trains to shelter themselves from sleet and icy winds. But beggars, no!

These days, however, beggars on the capital's metro trains are not an uncommon sight. Among these beggars are a sprinkling of deprived white Americans with their arms outstretched for any handouts.

"When I first arrived in Washington to make it my home, U Street was considered dangerous although it was once the fountainhead of America's black culture: the jazz legend Duke Ellington was born there. In those years, any place lower than 14th Street even in the well-to-do north west of Washington was considered unsafe.

Today, all these areas of the city have been gentrified. U Street will soon be home to the Indian embassy's swanky new cultural centre being built to reflect the present heady heights of Indo-US friendship, often described as a "natural alliance". U Street no longer sleeps, at any rate, on weekends.

Yesterday I took a walk along 14th Street towards U Street and beyond. Many black residents have left because they can no longer afford to live there. Farther in the city's southeast and northeast, which were once entirely black, homes are now increasingly owned by white people.

African Americans who made way for gentrification have not just moved out of the city, they have gone to towns in neighbouring Maryland state, as far away as Hancock near the border with Pennsylvania or Hagerstown in the state's far away Washington county.

If the turnout of black voters next Tuesday is low, as expected, it may well propel Republican Trump into the White House. An enthusiasm deficit for Democrat Hillary Clinton would be a reflection of how black Americans are disappointed by one of their own: America's first black President Barack Obama.

What startled me was the profusion of beggars along 14th Street. Washington has always had a smattering of beggars, almost entirely African Americans. They usually sat outside metro stations. They were permanently there and they had regular benefactors.

Both sides engaged in banter and these beggars never sent anyone into bouts of depression the way child beggars or maimed men and women at traffic stops in New Delhi do.

Not any more. There is hopelessness writ large on faces of today's beggars in the capital of the most powerful nation on earth. Such hopelessness may turn into apathy on voting day and help Trump. These black men and women wallowing in misery have no cellphones and are not covered by opinion polls."

http://www.telegraphindia.com/1161106/jsp/foreign/story_117711.jsp#.WB56PBSTXoA
___________________________________

Woah. I take issue with this comment:

"An enthusiasm deficit for Democrat Hillary Clinton would be a reflection of how black Americans are disappointed by one of their own: America's first black President Barack Obama."

No, I disagree. How could there not be a drop in enthusiasm for African-Americans after voting in two elections for the first black President? Sorry, but any drop in turnout is very natural now that the President Obama is not on the ballot -- its not a negative reflection on him or Hillary.

13 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

UCmeNdc

(9,600 posts)
2. I think Black apathy is not the main problem. Voter suppression is the culprit.
Sat Nov 5, 2016, 08:51 PM
Nov 2016

For many Black people in the United States voting is really hard to do. There are many roadblocks that the GOP has constructed since 2012.

brush

(53,743 posts)
13. The writer does not truly understand African-Americans. The poster, OTOH, has an agenda
Sat Nov 5, 2016, 09:54 PM
Nov 2016

There is no black apathy. Just google some of the polls. Trump is getting 0% of the African-American vote in many of them.

This "black turn out low" is just a meme spread by lazy pundits and journalists who hear it and repeat it without doing any research. If they did they would know that repugs have thrown as many obstacles in the way of black voters that they could think of legally, and in some cases, illegally.

It won't work. Early voting percentages may have started off down from 2012 because of these dirty tricks but the totals are being made up and will continue to climb through to election day.

It's a false repug talking point. No self-respecting AA will be caught dead voting for Trump. And I happen to be one of them.

I registered voters, canvassed and phone banked and AA voters are very enthusiastic and let me know straight out they were certain to vote and Hillary was who they were going to vote for.

spooky3

(34,407 posts)
3. This author has made some huge (il)logical leaps
Sat Nov 5, 2016, 09:00 PM
Nov 2016

based on extrapolating from questionable anecdotes.

I've lived in the DC metro for nearly 20 years. Sadly, there have always been beggars and homeless people, of all races, ages, etc. Many have mental illness; many may be hopeless. I'm not sure that is different. I don't see what voting has to do with the author's observation, and it seems racist to me that he is drawing inferences about how blacks feel and how they may decline to vote based on his questionable observations. Why not say the same thing about whites?

BumRushDaShow

(128,516 posts)
7. WTF? From a country that has a caste system firmly in place.
Sat Nov 5, 2016, 09:11 PM
Nov 2016

and is apparently attempting to dog-whistle associate their "untouchables" with AAs here in the U.S. :facepalm"

redwitch

(14,941 posts)
10. Your constant posting of negative polls and stories like this are depressing.
Sat Nov 5, 2016, 09:33 PM
Nov 2016

Try finding something positive to share. Please.

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»Black apathy key to Trump...