HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Do we like PETA? » Reply #79
In the discussion thread: Do we like PETA? [View all]

Response to Goodheart (Original post)

Sun Mar 3, 2019, 10:36 PM

79. Do we like organizations that euthanize the vast majority of dogs they take in? No, most of us don't

https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2012/03/petas-terrible-horrible-no-good-very-bad-history-of-killing-animals/254130/

Even acknowledging that PETA sterilized over 10,500 dogs and cats and returned them to their owners, it doesn't change the fact that its adoption rate in 2011 was 2.5 percent for dogs and 0.4 for cats. Even acknowleding that PETA never turns an animal away -- "the sick, the scarred and broken, the elderly, the aggressive and unsocialized..." -- doesn't change the fact that Virginia animal shelters as a whole had a much lower kill rate of 44 percent. And even acknowledging that PETA is often the first to rescue pets when heat waves and hurricanes hit, that doesn't change the fact that, at one of its shelters, it kills 84 percent of supposedly "unadoptable" animals within 24 hours of their arrival.


When I contacted PETA for a comment on these numbers, Amanda Schinke, a spokesperson for the organization, sent a thoughtful and detailed response. In it she explained how "euthanasia is a product of love for animals who have no one to love them." She called their killing a "tragic reality," one that forthrightly acknowledges how "sometimes [animals] need the comfort of being put out of their misery -- a painless release from a world in which they were abused and unwanted." Noting that PETA, unlike many "no-kill" shelters, turns no animal away, Schinke added, "we do everything in our power to help these animals." The harsh reality behind the grim numbers, she noted, should never be forgotten: "Millions of homeless animals are euthanized in animal shelters and veterinary offices across America because of simple math: too many animals and not enough suitable homes."

But is this really a simple math problem? Nathan Winograd doesn't think so. Winograd, a Stanford Law graduate and former corporate lawyer, is the author of Irreconcilable Differences: The Battle for the Heart and Soul of America's Animal Shelters. When the data on PETA dropped, he posted a scathing article insisting that the organization's almost 100 percent kill rate was due not to laziness or poor management but to "something more nefarious." Winograd asserts that PETA's failure to find homes for impounded companion animals is the result of founder Ingrid Newkirk's "dark impulses." Performing a virtual psychological vivisection, Winograd diagnoses Newkirk as a "disturbed person," a "shameless animal killer," and the executrix of a "bloody reign" of terror over dogs and cats. At one point, he even compares her to nurses who get a thrill from killing their human patients.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 86 replies Author Time Post
Goodheart Mar 2019 OP
beachbum bob Mar 2019 #1
Goodheart Mar 2019 #2
beachbum bob Mar 2019 #3
Croney Mar 2019 #4
Archae Mar 2019 #22
mucifer Mar 2019 #52
Jake Stern Mar 2019 #60
mucifer Mar 2019 #70
Lucid Dreamer Mar 2019 #81
Caliman73 Mar 2019 #82
ProfessorGAC Mar 2019 #65
Mariana Mar 2019 #69
ProfessorGAC Mar 2019 #84
GeorgeGist Mar 2019 #12
handmade34 Mar 2019 #32
Beringia Mar 2019 #78
yewberry Mar 2019 #5
Goodheart Mar 2019 #6
brooklynite Mar 2019 #20
Amishman Mar 2019 #24
crazycatlady Mar 2019 #62
happybird Mar 2019 #55
yewberry Mar 2019 #68
Mariana Mar 2019 #73
Irishxs Mar 2019 #7
Goodheart Mar 2019 #9
Iggo Mar 2019 #8
Ferrets are Cool Mar 2019 #10
CrossingTheRubicon Mar 2019 #11
comradebillyboy Mar 2019 #29
MiltonBrown Mar 2019 #59
Hortensis Mar 2019 #67
happybird Mar 2019 #13
melman Mar 2019 #14
X_Digger Mar 2019 #15
caraher Mar 2019 #16
Boomerproud Mar 2019 #17
UniteFightBack Mar 2019 #18
hunter Mar 2019 #19
WhiskeyGrinder Mar 2019 #21
Wounded Bear Mar 2019 #23
Meowmee Mar 2019 #25
Bettie Mar 2019 #26
comradebillyboy Mar 2019 #27
Laffy Kat Mar 2019 #28
Iggo Mar 2019 #30
ismnotwasm Mar 2019 #31
mr_lebowski Mar 2019 #33
IluvPitties Mar 2019 #34
mr_lebowski Mar 2019 #36
ProudLib72 Mar 2019 #61
yewberry Mar 2019 #71
ProudLib72 Mar 2019 #74
IluvPitties Mar 2019 #77
ProudLib72 Mar 2019 #80
True Dough Mar 2019 #35
crazycatlady Mar 2019 #64
True Dough Mar 2019 #76
handmade34 Mar 2019 #37
still_one Mar 2019 #39
crazycatlady Mar 2019 #85
still_one Mar 2019 #38
CrossingTheRubicon Mar 2019 #40
Blue_true Mar 2019 #45
CrossingTheRubicon Mar 2019 #46
Blue_true Mar 2019 #48
Jake Stern Mar 2019 #41
Blue_true Mar 2019 #47
happybird Mar 2019 #54
Blue_true Mar 2019 #42
OnDoutside Mar 2019 #43
Kaleva Mar 2019 #44
nini Mar 2019 #49
jpak Mar 2019 #50
Bayard Mar 2019 #51
mucifer Mar 2019 #53
DinahMoeHum Mar 2019 #56
aikoaiko Mar 2019 #57
jmowreader Mar 2019 #58
ProfessorGAC Mar 2019 #66
Xolodno Mar 2019 #63
tandem5 Mar 2019 #72
PTWB Mar 2019 #75
LineNew Reply Do we like organizations that euthanize the vast majority of dogs they take in? No, most of us don't
pnwmom Mar 2019 #79
CrossingTheRubicon Mar 2019 #86
TheBlackAdder Mar 2019 #83
Please login to view edit histories.