Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

progree

(10,901 posts)
75. I'm not rooting for a crash that severe, which was the worst collapse since the Great Depression
Mon Mar 2, 2020, 03:09 PM
Mar 2020

Last edited Mon Mar 2, 2020, 09:54 PM - Edit history (5)

but we're overdue for a severe stock market pullback. If we're going to get one in the next 1-5 years, which I think is inevitable from stock market history, I'd rather it be before November than afterwards.

This chart of the S&P 500 illustrates what I talked about as far as bear markets and recessions in post #63:

https://www.macrotrends.net/2324/sp-500-historical-chart-data

Do you see the little gray bands? Those are recessions. They happen an average of about every 10 years. We're past that -- we're in the longest expansion in history.

Do you see the bigger dips? They happen, with bear markets (20% or more) every 3.5 years on average.

Do you think Trump's presidency so far and 2 Supreme Court picks was a good thing? I didn't.

Do you want him to pick another 2 Supreme Court picks? I don't

Do you think millions losing health insurance coverage is a good thing? I didn't. I think it is genocide.

And he's still whacking away at it in every way he can. The ACA was saved only by 1 vote in the Senate. But he keeps whittling away on the ACA with executive orders and court challenges to be eventually ruled on by the most conservative Supreme Court in history.

Are you happy with him unraveling the social safety net? I'm not.

Are you happy with his response to Coronavirus so far? I'm not.

Are you happy that he can launch nuclear weapons at any time? I'm not.

Do you think it's only a minor problem that we won't start dealing with the climate crisis until no sooner than 2025? I don't. As it is, I doubt that any climate scientist really thinks we're going to stay within 1.5 deg C. There is some hope for 2.0 deg C.

Seeing what we're already seen out west and in Australia and yada at +1.0 C, a +2.0 C deg world would make the damage from the 2008 crash look like a walk in the park. Especially if we do pass a catastrophic climate tipping point that we haven't already passed. You know, things like permafrost melting 70 years earlier than projected.

Four more years of Trump (with an inevitable big stock market pullback or crash before his second term is over) will do a hell of a lot more harm to the economy and Americans and the world than a pullback in the stock market through November. Far more. Far far more.

I have most of my nest egg in equities, and I'm old and long retired, so I'm not happy either watching the balance go down down down. But if it gets the psychopathic nuclear-button-enabled shit maggot out of office, it is absolutely, completely, and totally worth it. Particularly considering it's almost a certainty (see those graphs again) that we're going to get a big downturn anyway before his 2nd term is over).

And the stock market always recovers and goes on to set new all-time highs. It always has. It has never, ever, set a new all-time low. Never.

People don't lose in a market downturn unless they panic and sell. If you hold on, it's a temporary paper loss.

(Although all bets are off if we continue with Caligula-style policies and/or catastrophic global heating, something to think about for those who are whimpering about their 401k's)

The choice: a temporary paper loss before November, or having the psychopathic nuclear-button-enabled shit maggot for 4 more years and big stock market pullback or crash in his second term?

Looking at a lot of replies to this thread, there are a lot of people who seem to think their retirement savings are never going to suffer from a big dip. ("I don't want to lose any more money in my 401k" ). That somehow, something has eliminated economic and stock market cycles. That somehow, a recession or big stock market downturn (in the 40% or more range, like 73-74, 2001, 2008-9) will never happen again, bar a massive Spanish flu like pandemic or other massive external shock. I am just appalled by the degree of this mass delusion.

Of course not, that is nonsense. mahina Feb 2020 #1
The financial hit is worth it if it takes down Trump budkin Feb 2020 #2
Having gas at about $5 a gallon Dagstead Bumwood Feb 2020 #5
Yeah, that'd be great. cwydro Feb 2020 #9
Didn't think it necessary Dagstead Bumwood Feb 2020 #17
Good. Sorry, but I have seen people here hoping for that. cwydro Feb 2020 #19
I focus all of my negative thoughts and wishes Dagstead Bumwood Feb 2020 #22
With you on that! cwydro Feb 2020 #25
Well, more than just one person... Wounded Bear Mar 2020 #40
focus harder! n/t orleans Mar 2020 #46
I'm re-watching Dagstead Bumwood Mar 2020 #48
I know we're sorta friends and all (maybe not after this) but I'm rooting for $10/gallon gas mr_lebowski Mar 2020 #78
I'm not in favor customerserviceguy Mar 2020 #60
Neither am I Dagstead Bumwood Mar 2020 #81
If people were serious about reducing fossil fuel usage, it needs to be much higher than $5 MichMan Mar 2020 #71
I paid 1.95 at the pump today. Dagstead Bumwood Mar 2020 #82
Sell! Sell! Sell! Shermann Feb 2020 #3
I've been expecting the market drop, and been accused of 'rooting for it'... Wounded Bear Feb 2020 #4
Same here. LuvNewcastle Mar 2020 #39
Despite how incompetent the Trump Administration is yuiyoshida Mar 2020 #84
I'm sure not, but I've seen that on DU. cwydro Feb 2020 #6
It has crossed my mind, but no. Polly Hennessey Feb 2020 #7
Insane... I lost $5500 on my RSUs lapfog_1 Feb 2020 #8
Looks like you're getting your answer in several responses to this thread. cwydro Feb 2020 #10
I'm rooting for COVID-19 to get Drumpf and Pence, actually. n/t rzemanfl Feb 2020 #11
What rzemanfl said. Sugar Smack Feb 2020 #15
Wall Street is full of crooks GusBob Feb 2020 #12
If rooting for something caused it intrepidity Feb 2020 #13
If Coronavirus causes a stock market collapse, that means more disease and more deaths. Cousin Dupree Feb 2020 #14
I'm rooting for sane government that values lives over politics flibbitygiblets Feb 2020 #16
Only ones I see spreading things like this Andy823 Feb 2020 #18
Fuck no. nt jmg257 Mar 2020 #74
of course not, but that will be the bee ess the Trumpigists will be spreading. Thomas Hurt Feb 2020 #20
Sixty percent of Americans make less than forty thousand dollars a year pecosbob Feb 2020 #21
Because the feeling is mutual...nt Wounded Bear Mar 2020 #41
No! My husband is quite ill and we've Laurian Feb 2020 #23
I'm not too worried about the stock market captain queeg Feb 2020 #24
***YES I AM, ABSOLUTELY***. I don't think Trump can be beaten in November if the stock market progree Feb 2020 #26
I don't want to see people stillcool Feb 2020 #27
Nope... 2naSalit Feb 2020 #28
I'm, that's a big no. That is where my IRA money is bottomofthehill Feb 2020 #29
No one wants the stock market to crash. eilen Feb 2020 #30
Lots of gleeful posts here on DU everytime it drops MichMan Mar 2020 #59
I want it to crash hard Calculating Feb 2020 #31
Hell No if the stock market collapses it will carry over in to the economy and affects jobs housing lunasun Feb 2020 #32
Make no mistake,that POS would NEVER give presser on a Sat..... Bengus81 Feb 2020 #33
I'd rather a hamburger got him Joinfortmill Feb 2020 #34
No, but when millions of people warned what a disaster the Retrumplicans would be maxrandb Feb 2020 #35
What goes up must come down TexasBushwhacker Feb 2020 #36
+1000 smirkymonkey Mar 2020 #42
Couple the stock buy backs with a big helping of irrational exuberance TexasBushwhacker Mar 2020 #47
Not really Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Feb 2020 #37
Stock market rownesheck Feb 2020 #38
No. I want a stock market collapse so I can make money from it. roamer65 Mar 2020 #43
A long overdue correction to this bloated, overvalued stock market is a good thing. ooky Mar 2020 #44
Wall Street has been enjoying their ill gotten gains for awhile RhodeIslandOne Mar 2020 #45
Ugh. Fox News is the fucking worst! Initech Mar 2020 #49
I wish Bloomberg would buy Fox News. walkingman Mar 2020 #54
Not at all, but all the same, it had no business being as high as it was DFW Mar 2020 #50
My pension is invested in the stock market, so, no. nt tblue37 Mar 2020 #51
If that's what it takes. We can recover from another collapse with good leadership. The markets brewens Mar 2020 #52
No - I'm hoping the market recovers without the FED - everything is so politicized these days. walkingman Mar 2020 #53
Only if it beats quick results. Cartoonist Mar 2020 #55
No, I want Trump to hurt Trump and his enablers... WePurrsevere Mar 2020 #56
Actually I was rooting for a host of God's seraphim Vogon_Glory Mar 2020 #57
I'm rooting for a half a dozen SallyHemmings Mar 2020 #58
That's why we have yuiyoshida Mar 2020 #61
I'm rooting for people to see what a menace Trump is when crisis strikes SiliconValley_Dem Mar 2020 #62
"If the gains of 2019 are erased & it causes people to rethink their support of this psychopath..." progree Mar 2020 #63
I think you can count the Coronavirus yuiyoshida Mar 2020 #64
Investors don't seem to be all that worried at this point -- S&P 500 futures up 0.50% progree Mar 2020 #66
Frankly with the incompetence of the Trump Administration yuiyoshida Mar 2020 #67
Yes. My biggest worry is the very small number of people who have been tested. progree Mar 2020 #68
Did you think the crash in 2008 was a good thing ? MichMan Mar 2020 #70
I'm not rooting for a crash that severe, which was the worst collapse since the Great Depression progree Mar 2020 #75
No! bobGandolf Mar 2020 #65
fuck no Demonaut Mar 2020 #69
um, no. Javaman Mar 2020 #72
better question: is the GOP supporting Trump's lies scrabblequeen40 Mar 2020 #73
No, I'm retired and can't afford it. The Velveteen Ocelot Mar 2020 #76
No. exboyfil Mar 2020 #77
"Even a whiff of that from our leadership would lead to an electoral wipe out." LenaBaby61 Mar 2020 #79
No Mz Pip Mar 2020 #80
Nope... though I did buy some more whistler162 Mar 2020 #83
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Are you rooting for a st...»Reply #75