HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » NEW: CDC guidance on mask... » Reply #107

Response to demmiblue (Original post)

Sat Mar 28, 2020, 02:59 PM

107. This thread proves how susceptible Americans are to fear and spin.

First, this should be considered a rumor and nothing more. Statements like this can endanger front-line medical personnel.

Second, it's probably the worst idea I've heard being tossed about at this stage of the outbreak for a number of reasons (most having to do with American culture). If you think masks are hard to come by now...think toilet paper. Where the hell will our medical personnel get masks if every asshole in America hoards a few hundred in their garage (and they will)?

Third, there's little scientific evidence that wearing masks substantially reduces everyday citizen's risks for this novel virus vs careful sanitation, isolation and safe distancing. The problem is that any measure we take can create a false sense of security and most people then become far more careless with the other components of protection.

Fourth, it is known that the virus can be spread in air both by droplets (of a wide variety of size) and by aerosolization which is extremely dangerous in public places and masks available to the public will not stop it (virus particles are sub-micron). In addition, very few public places have HEPA-rated air filtration in their HVAC systems.

Fifth, few Americans are trained on the proper use and handling of particulate masks and are unaware their design is for short term use, typically being disposed of after one work shift or less. Handling of them reduces effectiveness.

My strong suspicion is that Trump's greed-driven people are about to pump this as a magic solution to enable millions of people to go back to work. The net result is that thousand more will die.

I'm expressing these opinions relative to the American public as a whole, including the rich and the poor and the smart and not-so-smart from all regions.


Just My Humble Opinion........

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 115 replies Author Time Post
demmiblue Mar 28 OP
Chiyo-chichi Mar 28 #1
OhNo-Really Mar 28 #33
Meowmee Mar 29 #115
TheBlackAdder Mar 28 #38
zonkers Mar 28 #52
TheBlackAdder Mar 28 #58
Hortensis Mar 28 #60
DENVERPOPS Mar 28 #82
Hortensis Mar 28 #90
C_U_L8R Mar 28 #41
TheBlackAdder Mar 28 #44
Scarsdale Mar 28 #62
DENVERPOPS Mar 28 #112
LiberalArkie Mar 28 #70
ChiTownDenny Mar 28 #73
thesquanderer Mar 28 #102
luvs2sing Mar 28 #2
madaboutharry Mar 28 #3
greatauntoftriplets Mar 28 #7
TheBlackAdder Mar 28 #48
liberalmuse Mar 28 #20
bullwinkle428 Mar 28 #4
hlthe2b Mar 28 #6
NightWatcher Mar 28 #11
greenjar_01 Mar 28 #46
Lars39 Mar 28 #21
greenjar_01 Mar 28 #42
The Velveteen Ocelot Mar 28 #5
dalton99a Mar 28 #8
LisaL Mar 28 #28
Butterflylady Mar 28 #89
jzola Mar 28 #64
getagrip_already Mar 28 #9
Arkansas Granny Mar 28 #15
central scrutinizer Mar 28 #18
MontanaMama Mar 28 #84
2naSalit Mar 28 #96
central scrutinizer Mar 28 #105
2naSalit Mar 28 #106
The Blue Flower Mar 28 #10
evilhime Mar 28 #68
cynatnite Mar 28 #12
LisaL Mar 28 #26
honest.abe Mar 28 #13
dweller Mar 28 #23
LisaL Mar 28 #25
still_one Mar 28 #31
dewsgirl Mar 28 #27
Kaleva Mar 28 #51
honest.abe Mar 28 #94
ooky Mar 28 #92
Chainfire Mar 28 #14
durablend Mar 28 #17
The Velveteen Ocelot Mar 28 #16
dalton99a Mar 28 #19
onecaliberal Mar 28 #30
LisaL Mar 28 #32
ooky Mar 28 #93
bronxiteforever Mar 28 #22
magicarpet Mar 28 #36
bronxiteforever Mar 28 #49
Igel Mar 28 #88
LisaL Mar 28 #24
BusyBeingBest Mar 28 #45
LisaL Mar 28 #50
underpants Mar 28 #29
magicarpet Mar 28 #34
clutterbox1830 Mar 28 #35
duforsure Mar 28 #37
greenjar_01 Mar 28 #39
OrlandoDem2 Mar 28 #40
dalton99a Mar 28 #43
greenjar_01 Mar 28 #47
NYC Liberal Mar 28 #53
Ohiogal Mar 28 #54
c-rational Mar 28 #55
LisaL Mar 28 #56
c-rational Mar 28 #101
dalton99a Mar 28 #57
c-rational Mar 28 #103
WhiskeyGrinder Mar 28 #59
Bayard Mar 28 #61
ffr Mar 28 #63
ffr Mar 28 #65
DallasNE Mar 28 #66
OverBurn Mar 28 #67
Takket Mar 28 #69
LisaL Mar 28 #80
Takket Mar 28 #83
LisaL Mar 28 #87
WheelWalker Mar 28 #71
csziggy Mar 28 #72
LiberalArkie Mar 28 #74
jeffreyi Mar 28 #75
Generic Brad Mar 28 #76
LisaL Mar 28 #78
Generic Brad Mar 28 #79
LisaL Mar 28 #81
Sunsky Mar 28 #77
Chainfire Mar 28 #85
Takket Mar 28 #91
NoMoreRepugs Mar 28 #86
carlvsam Mar 28 #95
LisaL Mar 28 #97
UCmeNdc Mar 28 #98
demmiblue Mar 28 #99
Hobo Mar 28 #100
dalton99a Mar 28 #104
LineNew Reply This thread proves how susceptible Americans are to fear and spin.
KY_EnviroGuy Mar 28 #107
LisaL Mar 28 #108
KY_EnviroGuy Mar 28 #109
LisaL Mar 28 #110
Kaleva Mar 29 #113
KY_EnviroGuy Mar 29 #114
Takket Mar 28 #111
Please login to view edit histories.