I don't think this is correct (Reply #33)

In the discussion thread: Am I crazy for suspecting this video is a Right Wing hail mary? [View all]

Sat Sep 15, 2012, 02:02 AM

jsmirman (4,507 posts)

33. I don't think this is correct

not the part about me being crazy - that's a separate debate - but it's my understanding that although the video was published in July, it was dubbed into arabic and was brought to the attention of an Egyptian Islamist television station by Morris Sadek some time around September 8th.

I think that kind of answers to your point, if it is indeed correct (and I think it is).

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

42 replies	Author	Time	Post
Am I crazy for suspecting this video is a Right Wing hail mary? [View all]	jsmirman	Sep 2012	OP
Could this be the October surprise?	broiles	Sep 2012	#1
This sure blows the whole 2016 movie out of the PR water.	Lint Head	Sep 2012	#2
I don't know that your premise is true, but I wouldn't put ANYTHING past them.	lob1	Sep 2012	#3
I hesitated to give voice to this, but it's been gnawing at me	jsmirman	Sep 2012	#4
That would explain romney's idiotic statements regarding Libya.	Stargazer09	Sep 2012	#5
They have done this before, Rachel Maddow talked about it tonight	Heather MC	Sep 2012	#9
I'm looking forward to catching the Maddow podcast later tonight	jsmirman	Sep 2012	#10
Rachel's show is a bit of a jaw dropper tonight	Heather MC	Sep 2012	#14
Yes, someone posted that link recently	jsmirman	Sep 2012	#34
The actors and crew involved should sue the "filmmakers"	jsmirman	Sep 2012	#6
I totally & completely agree that is exactly what is happening.	JaneyVee	Sep 2012	#7
Your suspicion is shared by many	Jessy169	Sep 2012	#8
I certainly think the people who made and released this film hoped to influence the election	Douglas Carpenter	Sep 2012	#11
Good thought	brush	Sep 2012	#12
I am also suspicious of this, but proving it will be difficult to impossible	davidpdx	Sep 2012	#13
A couple more crazy ideas	TexasBushwhacker	Sep 2012	#15
Six possible suspects or more	lofty1	Sep 2012	#16
... ..the heart of the Islamophobia industry in America.	mrJJ	Sep 2012	#17
Given past history, it seems highly plausible.	xfundy	Sep 2012	#18
I think the video is a bizarre sidebar to all of this.	Bolo Boffin	Sep 2012	#19
They seem more than dumb enough to be manipulated	jsmirman	Sep 2012	#22
Well, do you have any evidence they were manipulated or given marching orders? n/t	Bolo Boffin	Sep 2012	#25
If I had evidence, I would have said "I know"	jsmirman	Sep 2012	#31
I said so earlier today:	DevonRex	Sep 2012	#20
I agree that the Romney	jsmirman	Sep 2012	#21
I have a lot more to say on the subject but	DevonRex	Sep 2012	#28
Well	jsmirman	Sep 2012	#32
By the way, this could just mean that we both are crazy.	jsmirman	Sep 2012	#23
Ha.	DevonRex	Sep 2012	#29
These things we know...	CoffeeCat	Sep 2012	#24
Obama did not refuse to meet with Netanyahu... that is pure FUD and republican FUD at that	Egnever	Sep 2012	#27
It is strange that you would BELIEVE all of the hate outlets	Doctor_J	Sep 2012	#41
Yes you are crazy	Egnever	Sep 2012	#26
I don't think this is correct	jsmirman	Sep 2012	#33
But it was shown in Arabic in Libya this week	Doctor_J	Sep 2012	#40
Yes, you are crazy	cthulu2016	Sep 2012	#30
Am I right that the Arabic dubbing was a very recent addition--	eridani	Sep 2012	#35
I'm not sure, but that's my initial understanding	jsmirman	Sep 2012	#36
Hell no, you are not crazy! Hell I figured	B Calm	Sep 2012	#37
When in doubt, ask the question, "Who benefits"	Doctor_J	Sep 2012	#38
Well, it's keeping Obama tied to the WH and unable to campaign..	ananda	Sep 2012	#39
Not big on conspiracy theories, but Sheldon Adelson, Koch Bros, and Rove Crossroads	emulatorloo	Sep 2012	#42

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.